Because I’ve Been Reincarnated as the Piggy Duke, This Time I Will Say I Like You (WN)

I've come across numerous light novels with ratings below 3.6, but this particular one really frustrates me. Initially, the protagonist's discovery of his past life and desire for change is engaging, I'll grant that. It's refreshing to see a more grounded storyline compared to others. However, the excessive number of side stories is a major issue – it rivals even the sprawling narratives of One Piece and Naruto. A spoiler: When the MC confronts mercenary Natalia, initially, there's an intriguing plotline. But then, it turns into a pattern: one chapter of action followed by three chapters of irrelevant backstory, only to repeat ad nauseam. The chapters themselves are too short to accommodate such filler content.

As others have mentioned, the frequent and ill-executed point-of-view (POV) shifts significantly disrupt the narrative flow, making it difficult to follow. Despite this flaw, the novel itself is decent on a basic level. If the author were to revise and refine the transitions, it could become a solid read. However, considering its origins as an未经打磨的 webnovel, such inconsistencies are expected. The constant POV changes suggest a lack of planning for the overall plot, with the author seemingly resorting to them as a makeshift solution when facing writer's block. If you're comparing it to the manga adaptation, the manga presents a more polished and lighthearted experience, though it may lack the same intensity and danger found in the original webnovel content, which personally I prefer.

It's difficult to appreciate this series, not because of the translation but the storytelling itself. Protagonists typically exhibit a consistent trait that adheres to a clear character arc. However, the main character in question appears mentally inconsistent, flipping from one personality trait to another without a convincing reason. He veers from humility to confidence, cunning to wisdom, and back to incompetence within the same story. While such character development could be intriguing if executed well, the transitions feel forced and unrealistic, bordering on a开关式人格切换. This portrayal, intended to make him relatable as a protagonist, unfortunately falls short by painting him as mentally unstable, which detracts from his character's credibility. In summary, the author has undermined their own creation, leaving the character's identity unclear and unconvincing.

The narrative was fantastic, but I must point out a minor issue. Early on, I found the main character frustrating because he lacked any distinguishing traits beyond magic, which made him blend in. Additionally, knowing about the future yet being inadequately prepared irked me. The story and characters were excellent, and the translation was satisfactory, despite a few errors. Overall, it was an enjoyable read, but there's certainly room for improvement. The story didn't leave a profound impact, unfortunately.

The narrative appears to follow a familiar trope of an "unlikely hero rising to the top." The protagonist possesses a compelling character and a poignant backstory tinged with tragedy, which offers a promising foundation for the story. At this stage, there's not much deviation from the norm, but there's ample potential for growth and development as the plot unfolds. It remains to be seen how the narrative will evolve, but for now, it holds substantial promise.

In brief, the novel "Redemption of the Piggy Duke" revolves around a character despised by his peers yet adored by readers. When a random Japanese individual merges with our beloved Piggy Duke, he gains access to future insights from an anime and内幕操纵手段 from his former self. This extraordinary fusion creates the new主角: The White Piggy Duke.

I am indeed finding the novel entertaining, but not captivating enough to eagerly await each update. The narrative is somewhat disorganized, with events unfolding randomly and requiring multiple reads to grasp the storyline. The chapters are brief, often taking just five minutes to read but still necessitating careful attention to understand the plot.

This is a slice-of-life isekai story about a man who works out to confess to his childhood servant, with isekai primarily serving as a vehicle for introducing new characters. Unfortunately, certain tropes like the overused "buhihihi" pig-like laughter and the repetitive references to being a "white piggy duke" become tiresome after a while. If you were to remove the piggy duke jokes, the chapter lengths would shrink significantly.

If you're looking for a light read during times when you need something less demanding than a serious or high-stakes tale, this might fit the bill. It features a fat guy's journey, exercise, and his gradual transformation into a sought-after man, all while handling humor. With chapters averaging around one hour to read up to Chapter 75, it's a decent choice for a casual read. Overall, it's an average read, nothing extraordinary.

The premise of "Piggy Duke" (Buta Kōshaku ni Tensei Shitakara, Kondo wa Kimi ni Suki to Iitai) holds promise as a narrative, but it suffers from poorly translated first-person perspective passages. While these might sound more natural in the original language, the objective of a translation is to effectively communicate the intended meaning, not a literal word-for-word conversion. When the translation falls short, it loses potential appeal to readers. Furthermore, the inconsistency in chapter lengths stands out – for ongoing series, a standard of around 4,000 words per chapter is typical.

Based on my assessment, the novel oscillates between extremely short and lengthy chapters, indicating a lack of planning on the part of the author. This haphazard structure disrupts the flow of the story. As a result, I rate "Piggy Duke" 2 out of 5. It has promising potential, but the execution needs significant improvement.