Berserk Chapter 355 Discussion
- Thread starter PumpkinKing10
- Start date
- #6
Aardwolf94 said:
WTF is wrong with the artstyle? Casca looks atrocious, like a generic moe character.
Yeah, she looked soooo much different in the Golden Age arc ar- OH WAIT
Aardwolf94 said:
And the Elf queen is stupid, to just send Casca to Guts in a pretty dress and not considering that she doesnt remember everything yet
She clearly remembers enough to tear up at the mention of Guts' name
Aardwolf94 said:
Miura is dragging this story to death
>has one piece rated a 10
First of, GA was 20 years ago so suddenly trying to go back to that style would be a regression anyway. And is that pic somehow supposed to prove your argument? WTF She still looks much more natural in the GA one, in the other one she looks so fake and annoyingly moe that its just sad to see what became of Miura's art. And compare Casca now with art from the MF arc..its ridiculous.
She clearly didn't remember enough, considering her reaction at the end.
Salty Berserk fans as usually, bringing up other manga because they can't stand their overrated shitty series to be bashed. How about discussing this series instead of bringing up by ratings of other series..oh wait thats too difficult right?
At least One Piece knows what it is, a great well done Shounen that uses the tropes well. The story is at times too dragged out (Fishman Island, Dressrosa) but it actually fits the overall story since its an adventure, first and foremost. Not to mention OP's world is much more interesting and fleshed out anyway (berserk is your typical generic fantasy setting, especially now).
OP stayed true to its roots while Berserk which started out as a compelling mature story (hell the GA arc is the best story in any manga) with basically no typical tropes and it ended up being a shitty JRPG manga with cliche characters (Schierke, Isidro etc.), zero depth and annoying humor because the author turned soft. Its like a shell of its former self now
The story being milked out doesn't fit here because you can clearly see that Miura is stretching it out with meaningless detours (sea god) and fights (dragged out attack on Vrtannis, beach etc. that take up whole volumes, same old boring Griffith vs Ganishka).
The female lead suffered as well and was retarded for 20 volumes for this reason which is a damm shame and the MC is no closer to the actual main goal everyone is waiting for (Guts vs Griffith). Short of asspulls how is Guts going to defeat Griffith/God Hand? Time for another 20 volumes to find out
This is basically Bleach levels of pacing.
- #11
Draconix814 said:
Aardwolf94 said:
Draconix814 said:
Save your breath guys, he isn't going to listen no matter what you say. At this point, he's just trying to convince himself that he knows better than 53,140 individuals, and that's just including the people who rated it a 10. I would add everything up from those who rated an 8 or even a 9 and above, but that would just be a waste of time as my point still stands. Save your sanity, I beg of you.
And Aardwolf, if you want to come after me after saying this then be my guest-- just as long as you actually say something worthwhile, and backed up by evidence. Cite it if you have to.
Pack it up boys, Kimi no Na wa is the greatest animated movie ever because 247,965 people gave it a 10. And don't disagree since obviously they know better!
You talk to me about lacking arguments and then bring shit like this, like wtf.
No need to "come after you" (why do Berserk fans have to take their favourite manga being bashed so personally? holy shit), I know you will already ignore all my arguments and act like you know better (just like last time, where you ignored my reply).
According to you no criticism of Berserk's story and characters is worthwhile, lol.
You're acting like you're a super genius because you can apparently see what thousands of people cannot. The reason I said, "I would add everything up from those who rated it an 8 or 9" because chances are the people who do so are also criticizing Berserk for different reasons but can see the appeal and depth of the story even if they aren't huge fans of it. Even they would say that all of your arguments are bullshit. That said, I counted a good amount of dedicated Berserk fans who know the series like the back of their hand and gave you their time with very reasonable and well-constructed arguments. Yet you get butthurt whenever someone gives you a contrary opinion, and the only thing you can muster is simple and vague criticisms that just makes you sound like an edgy teenager that gets a high off of telling people they're wrong.
Though it is genuinely hilarious that you jumped to "no criticisms of Berserk and its story" from "back up your claims with evidence". LOL
So again, if someone bashes something like Kimi no Na wa/some other popular shit it means they are stupid because clearly the majority likes it. Thats a stupid argument and shows how dumb Berserk fans can really get really get since they are not used to their favourite manga being bashed. Its sad really, your posts reek of insecurity and butthurt.
Sry mate but I don't join any circlejerks and bandwagons and you shouldn't either.
When you give something a 8 or 9 that means the criticism you have for it isn't anything really bad & you are still a fan so of course they would disagree with me. How about the people who gave it a 5 and less? They would agree with me (at least some of my points) or are you just ignoring them because they aren't the majority? If there was an entry for the GA arc specifically I would give it a 10 but post Conviction there is just no depth, its shallow garbage as I explained multiple times so it deserves nothing more than a 2 (extra harsh because of good it used to be).
Yeah some did, others got butthurt like you ("can't respond to any of the posts civilly because of how retarded and worst of all, redundant they are") but some did want to have a mature discussion and I replied to them with my own arguments. We disagreed clearly and that's fine.
And nothing vague about my points, I even mentioned proper examples for each of them but of course to someone who thinks his shitty opinion is a fact (and supports it with shit like "majority agrees with me") also can't understand them.
Just stop already. Ignore my posts if you can't handle them
I can totally handle them because there's nothing to handle-- where is your evidence? You seem hell-bent on convincing us that you're right, then you tell us to ignore you, and in the midst of all of this, you still haven't said anything other than oversimplified and subjective (not objective) criticisms feelings. You then go on a tangent in an attempt to strawman the people criticizing your opinions and then you cry about them and say that everyone else is getting butthurt "because they are Berserk fans and can't handle other's opinions". If that isn't edgy af, then you aren't a human being. The world doesn't revolve around you, you know. Your opinions aren't factual or evident in any sort of manner and if you want so desperately to prove that you are correct, then cite your evidence. You are 110% allowed to dislike Berserk, but what I do not tolerate are lies or claims with no factual evidence. If you really want to prove your opinion to us so badly-- which you aren't convincing anybody, by the way, a sign that your arguments hold no merit whatsoever-- then go through every book of Berserk and cite the exact lines, pages, situations etc. in context with the rest of the story and tell us how exactly it fails as a work of art. I'm waiting.
