D.Gray-man Chapter 219 Discussion

I KNEW IT. I KNEW MANA WAS THE EARL!! But why did earl became a baby? why did they separate ? Then who was the one who died and got revived as akuma by allen? Who is allen? why is the memories jumbled up? Urgh so much questions and only four times a year?

man i need to read all the other chapters again to understand what was happening ;;

but i had chills all over my body nevertheless

Wow, finally some good news!



Anyway, at first I was kinda having fun, saying "GAAAAYYYY" because of that long hug... Then I gone "What...?" Ok, to be REALLY honest, I´m not that surprised. Coming to think, it makes some sense when you think about the clown Mana being drawn to child Allen in the circus.



But as usual, we got more questions than answers. Now, how both the versions of their story together connect to each other? Why the "Earl" had his memories changed? And why exactly the Millenium Earl was "reborn" into "twins"? Aaaah, my head.

At the end of the chapter I finally realize the full weight of Cross' words. "What if i told you, that you'll have to kill someone, you love. When you become the 14th."

Barion-Zara said:
Finally reread most of the series and read the new chap. It feels good to go in while remembering everything and understanding lots of the stuff. Still didn't prevent me from dropping a jaw or 2 getting mindf***ed ever every other page XD



@RandomTopic...ur analysis seems to be pretty damn good. But what is the Essence of the Earl ur talking about? I mean after he split into twins, are u saying there was still an Earl roaming around? That's the only part I couldn't get from ur explanation.



Because it did say the Earl vanished here



And



14noah said:
The Millennium Earl being Mana and Nea was very much surprising and confusing but it explains why the 14th is  technically not supposed to exist. Their are 13 Noahs but the Millennium Earl got separated into 2 being. My theory is that the Millennium Earl had the mission to deliver 'God wrath' thus eradicate humanity however he felt lonely and end up felling in love with Katerina or something. As a result of being conflicted, he was separated thus 'Mana' took the role of the Millennium willing to destroy humanity and 'Nea' took another different path. The only thing that is odd is the akuma scene with Allen so maybe the 'Mana' that Allen always knew was in fact Nea or that scene was just a memory manipulation.



Yeah that's how I'd summarize my thoughts.



Amazing come back chap :D



Caterina was one hot chick :L And Dat long Hug while all the plot twists were happening was really nice XD



Yes, the Earl did "come back" somehow. This is left unexplained, but it does say that after Nea ascended to being a Noah, he was with the Earl and the other Noah for a while until deciding to rebel and to kill the Earl. Obviously Nea couldn't have gone to war with the Earl and tried to kill him unless the Earl (or some part of him) had come back. Remember that there is a picture in one of the chapters that has the dying Nea in the arms of Mana as the Earl gloats over them.

Wisely said that if the Millennium Earl is no more then the Noah will be destroyed by the heart... so possibly Allen is the accomodator of the heart, but now that Nea has taken over his body, killing Nea (the Earl) would also kill Allen. In other words, in order to kill the Earl, Allen would have to die as well.

Either that, or killing Nea that would also be killing Allen, and so the heart would be unable to destroy the rest of the Noah.



I may be forgetting something that could prove this theory wrong though, but it seems like it could be a likely plot twist that Hoshino would make to spice up the story

Akarin said:
What a sweet yaoi chapter.

more like bromance

Omg never saw that coming !!! :D