Hoshi no Koe Chapter 10 Discussion

uiosi said:
Interesting is also that when he comes there eg in 8 years she will be  older also. But anyway since the mision failure also probably took 8 years to report they will probably be 8 years older still? But since he got her messege that she sended before fight and he got it a litl more then when he enlisted chances are there is somhow rescue mission been started emidiatly after they jumped? Since mission failure should take 8 years to confirm so they would actualy waited 16 years to get rescued?

Interesting manga defenetly i like the fact that he is coming to get her too :D

ya the whole time thing got me kind of confused when i start thinking about it lol. wish i knew if they actually where able to meet and what the age difference would have been, if any at all. If i remember correctly the ship has faster communication speed but it was only for important messages between the fleet and control

hey! just finished the manga, really good character development compared to the anime. bittersweet open ending which i really hate T.T but i noticed something when noboru was talking to his friend, his friend said something about them sending crap ships and no good crew. That just solidifies me into believing he wont get there safely :/ GOD I HATE THIS FEELING T.T

I wish this manga had about twice the chapters to flesh things out more, as it is a solid job was done with the mere 10 chapters given.  Solid 8/10 for me, ending is a hopeful one that they'll meet again, never saw the anime adaptation and sounds like that's a good thing...

So happy about the ending, so so happy.

i loved this manga, it really gets me emotional!

damn this was pretty sad, art was really nice too. would've been nice if they could've met eachother again in the end but oh well. overall 6/10, can't really say much since it was only 10 chapters but i think the characters and story were done fairly well.

AlexSadist-sama said:
In my opinion, the manga is way better than the anime. The ending was kinda sweet too.

Exactly.

Bigger focus on development for the story and their romance, this really was just a more touching experience, and the ending left at a much more conclusive and gratifying note versus the movie. :)

9/10

Damn, that was so short and yet so beautiful. It made me feel really sad, but the ending was nice. There was hope left.