Hoshi no Koe Chapter 10 Discussion

Just like I said, too fast and nothing much happened.

The ending was fine, but it wasn't as dramatic as it should've been. At least a scene where they said, "I love you" to each other and then kissed would have made it better. But overall, it was an enjoyable read.

it's safe to assume that they'll meet again, he'll be one of the crews for search and rescue operation, cause they're taking/recruiting volunteers for it, seeing the fact that he'll not age also when he embarks on this mission...so its a big possibility that

it will end in a happy ending...



"Love conquers all..."



just sharing my thoughts :)

Amazing manga. Suddenly a favorite.

I watched 5 cm/s and liked the style. Hoshi no Koe was recommended to me. I watched the OVA, but... I honestly didn't like it. It was so fast, so rushed, I didn't like the characters' designs, etc. But, the story was okay.

When I saw the manga of it, I decided to give it a try. It was so worth it. The manga is so much better, everything on it is so well done. The characters are way better, the story itself is so touching, so beautiful... a masterpiece. I could feel the love and pain, different from the animated version.

Storywise, I liked it better than the anime because of the happy-ish ending. Honestly, it was quite a surprise after all the depressing endings of Shinkai Makoto.

8/10

I rewatched the anime after reading the manga, and in my honest opinion, the manga is way better than the anime ! I have the feeling the anime is rushed... everything go fast, and there is just not enough details. In the manga, you see much deeper feelings, and the add of new characters is really great and useful. The distant relationship impact is more detailed in the manga too. The character design is also better in the manga. Moreover, I prefered the ending in the manga... When she saw the name on the board, it was so intense ! And you are more convinced that they will meet again.



In conclusion, the anime is just nice while the manga is a timeless masterpiece.

it was a pretty fun read overall.

I really love this manga!!

I wish they'd have at least met again in the ending, but it was still good! Leaves you to draw your own conclusion!