Gantz Chapter 372 Discussion

if you guys don't know every human that dies loses 21 gram and science dont know why (some say its a soul). animals stay the same

This was actually Kei 3.0 or 4.0(4.0 if you count the one that was run over by the train)



Will they have to live with the aliens now?

namelessregret said:
KingCez said:
dont see why they would.

Neither do I.



But they are already hating.



Who is hating? In this thread? You must be seeing two dimensions ahead.



The concept of the 21g was supposedly derived from Duncan MacDougall's "experiment". However, the experiments conducted were entirely arbitrary and not scientifically accountable.



However, just like God, so far it is impossible to prove that the soul does not exist. Thus, even from a scientific point of view, you may choose to believe in it or not. It's a personal choice, irrespective of science or not.

Seriously drawing 2 pages of a guy running in tears is kind of a waste...I guess that's how the author works anyways.

Didn't expect Kei #2 to die that fast.

Interesting stuff about peoples "soul"

I appreciate the philosophical battle over what the worth of a human life is, but that was a lot of presumptions made that we actually have no clue about. If (and this is a big fat "if") humans of the future do ever discover if souls are real, and what happens to a soul when a person dies, then this manga will become seriously outdated. ...Unless it is actually correct. Imagine if humans souls really are 21 grams....

Then again, all stories are bound to become outdated after enough time passes so I guess this whole point I made is irrelevant lol

Hey! MR/MRS Alien god .Ya shall aswer everything right?

then I have some questions here



What the hell are u? What your fucking soul is? If human's soul is 21 grams data

And  how can I fly BY MYSELF? How can I have super power in 3 second?

How can I get 1 bilion USD in 1 min?

How can I make 1 kilo of gold with SOMETHING 2$ worth?

How can I make human from nothing like u?

How can I  read/ remember instantly? How can I learn everything in 1 sec.

How can I become u? How can I have your power?

How can I live FOREVER?

....?.....?.....?....

that's it for now.....

BUT most importantly:

HOW CAN I FUCKING KILL U?????



ANSWER ITTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!  fucking alien , dumbass mangaka who drew ittt!!!!

Endar said:
This also brings up something else.  Do Kurono 1.0 and Kurono 2.0 have different souls?  It could be that some time in the next 19 years, Kurono 1.0 dies and is the one used for the rebirth.  Or it could be a combination of the two.



The soul explanation also brings up some more questions .  Does it mean that there are a finite number of souls?  Can a soul be copied for reincarnation to make up for a limit (Besides the cloning thing)?  Is the soul of everyone always a reused soul, or are new souls created?  Do souls eventually stop being used?  Will these questions be answered in the remaining chapters?  Probably not.



Also, if they can tell how someone will be reborn, then couldn't they know how the information they sent to Earth be used?  Though I suppose it could be either they didn't care or it's like that whole "master of fate and tool of fate" thing in Dune.



As for how they get back, I suppose someone on Earth could use one of those alien transports to get to them, or there might be some small craft on that ship or station they can use to get off.  The big problem for the first solution is how does anyone know to come rescue them?



Can't believe no one has posted about 2.0's soul. I'm assuming he has a different divergence of soul that's slightly different than 1.0... but who knows. They just keep adding more questions to the confusing plot.



skualninja said:
Seriously drawing 2 pages of a guy running in tears is kind of a waste...I guess that's how the author works anyways.

Didn't expect Kei #2 to die that fast.

Interesting stuff about peoples "soul"



I think this is called Greed. Remember how Gantz started off, lots of pages per chapter. Slowly less pages per chapter until less than 10? Means he can spread it out and make more money. Well, the author could be doing it or his publishers to get more money.



It's pretty common for popular manga to shorten chapter length to increase profits when it becomes pretty popular.

I actually kind of hated that souls exists in Gantz. For me it ruined a lot of the hopelessness in this manga (which is one of its main appeals in my opinion). When life is really precious, losing it means everything. Now that we "know" that souls exists in this manga, all of sudden it feels like it's ok when people die. "Oh well, they'll be reborn so it's ok". I dunno... I'm disappointed.

Zakeru1221 said:
it's so weird the way they interpret it though;

"in a past life, a boy had sex with his to-be-mother..."



Agreed.

God has left the chatroom

it's so weird the way they interpret it though;

"in a past life, a boy had sex with his to-be-mother..."

wonder what would be Kurono #1 and Tae's reincarnations...

Damn this is getting crazy..