After School Nightmare Chapter 39 Discussion

Hoho this was a pretty interesting manga.

I'd have given it 8+ if the story would have actually had any influence on the ending. I think that 10 volumes is too much in order to create a relationship, pull an "it was all a dream" sort of ending and mislead us.

caroxab said:
havelock said:
so the one girl who dissappeared without graduating, was the on one who was miscarried, huh



but were the problems they were trying to solve the ones of their previous life, or something that awaits them when they're going to live?



SPOILERS



yes.. basically she wasn't strong enough to be born (if that makes any sense to you)...



i think the class was a kind of a test, to see who was strong enough to be alive/born



just thought that some of the ones who graduated did it to run away from their problems, and at the other side: surprise surprise the very same awaits you here with armes wide open, no wonder i had a uneasy feeling watching 'em going through the door (even when not knowing whats behind it)

AND it kind of has the message if you're able to kill other in order to get the key you're strong enough to enter life. Oh well, its not like i thought infants actually were as inocent as everyone assumes..



caroxab said:


(remember the part where the nurse asks ichigo if she/he has any recollection or memory of the past, before she had her first period.. and she realizes that she doesn't)



i kind of thought it was the easiest way to let her start of with the way of thinking she had towards herself (honestly it seemed to me when she had her first period it was also the first time she noticed there was something missing down there to make her a real man)

Wow.. really nice! Nice ending.. though i was a little afraid that the romantic connection would be lost in those final pages!

But yeah.. i was like WTF.. throughout the whole chapters!

Luisa-chan said:
I wasn't expecting this kind of ending in fact, well I was a bit disappointed, I never thought that this this of before being born was the true point of the manga, loved everything about the story except the last chapter I guess...



I feel the same way. Whole manga was great and interesting until the last chapter. Although i'm not disappointed  by it, rather  surprised that the story could be ended like that.Still its a pity it  didn't say anything about other characters well-being.  Anyway i'm giving it 8/10

I really liked the ending to this manga, I actually guessed what was behind the door, but i wasnt sure and the hypothesis was vauge :P, i think this story was a bit long though, in the middle i was starting to get the feel of: why the hell are we watching another dream where nothing happens?. But all in all that was the only thing that let the manga down. This is the one of the most unique endings i have come across so far (that i enjoyed some are unique but crap) haha i was getting anixious when i thought every one else wouldnt be "born".

Animefanx3 said:
Wow I don't read that many manga's but I'm glad I choose to read this one. I admit that 10 volumes might be a bit long but I don't think it's dragged out, just very detailed and it showed how conflicted Mashiro was.



I loved the ending, I kind of had a bad feeling about what lies behind the door but it turned out to be better than I expected. I never could've guessed this would be a "before live" story, I'd thought of the possibility of it being a sort of "pre" heaven but not "pre" birth place.



What I don't understand is why everything crumbled when Mashiro was about to graduate...? I mean, was that whole world just made for him and it collapsed after he left that place? So everyone he met there were just "spirits" guiding him in the right direction? * 2 years later *



It was a hospital right? And everyone else who was still there died in the fire or something.



Which is why I'm confused why Sou was still there in the real world, since he should've been dead.

wow..okay. interesting indeed.....



originally, i was gonna just read the beginning and the end but now i'm motivated to look into the middle. putting it on hold for now!

I really liked the ending!

But I think it took too many chapters to get there.