Good novels are not popular. How do we fix that?

  • Thread starter xiouyu
  • Start date
  • #18
Why?, for the simple reason that it frustrates me to see thread titles that seem like it would be a good discussion, just for it to just be click-bait for shameless advertisement.
Also I can ask you the same thing, why bother replying to my posts when you already claimed to have put me on your ignore list before? lol 
 
  • #19
Viral self marketing?

I don't think blog posts are worth much, though. Not sure how many people are going to bother to read that. I think getting people to talk about the novel is a better idea. Drive discussions. Get people recommending it in I'm Looking For threads or elsewhere. Or do it yourself. ... Hmm.. and maybe see about bumping up ratings/reviews on NU. I don't put much stock in them, but others do.

And even if I say I don't put much stock in reviews, reading someone praise the shit out of something definitely makes me feel more like it deserves a chance. There's no replacement for people passionately recommending your novel.

Anyway, if the novel is "good", it's going to *keep* readers. The only problem is getting them to give it a shot.

If the novel can't keep readers, it's not good, sorry. That's not subjective, it's objective. If you can't get people interested in reading it in the first place, that's on you. If people give it a shot and just don't like it, that's out of your hands. 
 
  • #20
My few cents(for good novels that have a hard time finding success):

Promote! - This can be key. Make & keep people aware of the story. If an author, have the story on as many sites as is comfortable to manage.

Be Responsive and Communicate
- TL/Author Team, the more active the team the more 'free' promotion there is. In addition, communicate when there are issues, this can head off many of the problems that arise between TL/Author & Readers.

Be Smart on Launch - For translations, there should be enough chapters to get people involved in the story. One of the worst things you can do (IMO) is launch with too few chapters so people don't get a chance to get invested in the novel and readers may quickly forget the story.

Decide Best Method to Monetize - Novels that appeal to fewer people can still be very successful, especially via the patreon model where a few dedicated readers can sustain a novel. If using a patreon, have incentives that are achievable.  I.E more weekly chapters, if the # of subscribers reach a certain point and/or more chapters per tier. If you have the license rights, don't ignore eBooks since eBooks(aside from the earnings they bring in) can create more exposure to the story, leading to more patreons, or readers on the websites.

Quality Matters - Nothing has to be perfect, but the better translated/written a story is, the greater the chance it will appeal to more people. Try to find a balance between speed & quality. For authors, this can be even more important, since quality can be the diff between a mediocre rating(3 stars) and a higher rating(4 or 5 stars).

Likewise, use the readers for proofreading! - A sneaky(smart) thing you can do is use your patrons (if there is a patreon) as proofreaders. They pay YOU to proof chapters for you. It can be amazing and satisfying for both parties.  If no patreon, look for the dedicated readers who post corrections.

Keep on top of corrections. - It's less intimidating & easier to stay on top of corrections if they are done regularly (a day or so after each release). The added benefit is that newer readers will suffer fewer distractions while reading and likely become more involved in the story. Never underestimate the powers of immersion or the aggravation of broken immersion!

Consistent Release Rates - Regular release rates help maintain interest in a story. It doesn't always have to be 14 chapters/ week either. Just something that can get people anticipating a release. If it's only twice a week, that can also be alright, as long as it's consistent. Do what is manageable, work to avoid burnout!

Realize that Success Takes Time - Few novels/translations are successful from the get-go. It takes time to build up a loyal reader base. Likewise, have reasonable expectations. 
 
  • #21
You need to be as shameless as possible. Promote the heck out of it, even if the situation doesn't really allow for it.
Praise the good parts to heaven, but omit all the other parts.
Diss other series for doing X worse than the one you translate (pretty effective, though a bit scummy).
Add T&A in your promotion material to trick people into reading it, most people won't mind that there's no booty if the story is good enough. 
 
  • #22

I'm interested in this topic.. so I'd like to share my opinion..
it's sad that a lot of good novels not necessarily popular but the novel with loli butt got a lot of attention. but personally I agree with @Kuro_0ni and @checkm8,
for me, what caught my attention to read a novel at first is: cover, title, and synopsis.
cover, if I see a novel with good illustration I will want to find out if the story is as good as the illustration. we can't deny that people tend to like something beautiful.
title that can grab attention is a good title. for example give a title with familiar word like 'transmigration' and add unique taste like 'as carnivorous flower'. Well, I'm sure it will work somehow.
synopsis exists to give reader idea of what the contents of the novel are. so a good synopsis is important to make people curious and makes them want to know what is the real content of the novel. unfortunately sometime i find a good novel with crapy synopsis and it really make me hesitate to read it at first. maybe translator can make their own synopsis to make it up. ​title, cover and synopsis are like the packaging of a product. the more beautiful and unique the packaging is, the more people will be interested and pay attention to it. and this is the first step to lure people to read a novel.

next step is review. and this is the real advertisement for a novel.
after a novel gets my attention, usually I will read the review. and it becomes a little tricky. not all the review accurate coz people get different taste and preference. but it can't be denied that review has a significant role to make a novel popular. if the review is good even novel with an ugly cover, crappy title and synopsis, it still can become popular.

but the most important is still the content coz however much you advertise your novel if the contents are not good enough it won't work.
lastly keep up release rates and don't make people forget a novel ever exist. unfortunately, a lot of good novel doesn't have an update for weeks even months really makes my heart hurt for waiting. 
 
  • #23
First impressions matter, so get a synopsis that isn't so cheesy? I'm not sure if that'll help, and of course people's tastes vary. Nonetheless, I'd be more concerned about giving a vague summary of the conflict rather than trying to impress your viewer with poetry.

[Edited for syntax error] 
 
  • #24
Sometimes readers quit because they can't wait for the explanation or miss the explanation and made up their mind the novel sucks.

Name drop in recommendation threads, that is how I found a few novels. 
 
  • #25
Totally agree to your comment, here is my 2 cents worth read a few stories here rated as 1-2 star story as very engaging worth my read, while quite a lot of 3-5 stars that I've read turns out to be garbage. This no rating rule seems to apply to the CN novels only. While the Japanese & Korean rating actually appear to be much more reliable. Except from self promoting site won't name them. 
 
You must be logged in to reply here. Register an account to get started.