Beck Chapter 102 Discussion

I think it ended ok, what more could have happened xD, the series left a deep influenc in me, I can play every song which was in the show, but I wuld like to see Eddie playing whit them xD.

arimakenshin said:
I'm actually quite disappointed in this manga. It had so much potential but the mangaka wasted it by repeating the same pattern of "Oh no, you might not be sponsored -> you are sponsored but let's create drama between Maho and Yukio -> Eddie/Chiba drama -> somehow manage to make it concert -> "awesome" concert -> everyone's weird respect for Yukio.



I believe it's suspension of disbelief. The mangaka failed to suspend mine and I am quite let down by the story.



Story - 7/10

Art - 9/10

Overall - 8/10I don't quite see how that contributes to a pattern since most of the things that you mentioned happened either once or twice besides the whole drama with Maho and Koyuki thing. Which was mainly a side story since in every coming-of-age type of story it's somehow mandatory for there to be a constantly conflicting love interest. Anyways,  noone's going to change your mind about what you thought of it. At least you still gave it a decent score.



One manga series can't please everyone so I guess you're one of the few that were disappointed.

pinayloserr said:
this was a freakin good manga series ! i really want them to make it into an anime !!



There already is an anime series. It only covers the first arc though.

This ending was beautiful.. simply beautiful. I listened to slip out for the last 10-15 pages.



Such an incredible and interesting journey.

I'm actually quite disappointed in this manga. It had so much potential but the mangaka wasted it by repeating the same pattern of "Oh no, you might not be sponsored -> you are sponsored but let's create drama between Maho and Yukio -> Eddie/Chiba drama -> somehow manage to make it concert -> "awesome" concert -> everyone's weird respect for Yukio.



I believe it's suspension of disbelief. The mangaka failed to suspend mine and I am quite let down by the story.



Story - 7/10

Art - 9/10

Overall - 8/10

beautiful ending and a great explanation to eddies life, though i wonder why he said thank you when he died

It's a wonderful ending, not just the plot but also the way the mangaka presented it. Though of course there are still questions about Maho and Koyuki's relationship and other stuff, i think the ending being quite an abstract shows how their journey and lives are still ongoing.

what a manga, finished in 2 days after watching the anime in one day. The only thing i'm disappointed in is the same as most people, that there wasn't some kind of epilogue or a bit more to close out Maho x koyuki, gotta say they are the best couple and i really enjoyed their relationship throughout they had some really great moments that i loved. I knew they would never really be unfaithful but it still kept me really on edge :D just a bit of closure would have been nice.



But all in all it's a 10 from me, i can't give it anything less it was too amazing for me.



Where's this damn 100 episode anime at? lmao, i wish, a man can dream xD