Fairy Tail Chapter 438 Discussion

Erza as GM was logically sound. With the exception of Laxus but we didn't see anything from anyone else that screamed Guild Master. Mira doesn't count. For her being the right hand of Makarov we NEVER see anything of it. We never see her participate with Makarov in anything guild or council related.



Show us don't tell us.



Only two that made sense was Laxus or Erza. The leadership(more on Erza's side) the power the influence. The ability to get shit done. Erza can get hotheaded but that applies to Laxus and Makarov as well





Makes perfect sense. Some need to separate their bias

TheGrandSage23 said:
Durekan said:
Darklight0303 said:
Nuvi said:
I was hoping for Mira or Laxus to be the 7th master, damn.



You and me both my friend. Oh well at least with this Erza's screentime will be drastically reduced.



Totally agreed. Please, she has nothing to be an good guildmaster, even Natsu would be better.



Give a good logical reason on how Natsu would be better. Your opinions on Erza doesn't change the fact shes qualified and capable. If you want to suggest Natsu go ahead and that way I can list days on end why he's not a fit



In fact you're right. Natsu wouldn't be an good guildmaster too. It was emotional point with no logic, I'm sorry for that.



But it doesn't change the fact she's not the best for guildmaster too.



The reasons:

- She's not political at all, she can talk with some people, but can't have the contact  with other guilds, too much reserved. A guildmaster need to be political. That's the reason why I thin Gildarts wouldn't be an good guildmaster too.

- People don't respect her, they fear her. Between respect and fear has a huge apot.

- She sacrificed Juvia health in order to take down Avatar. A guildmaster could do that with no problem, but no the guildmaster of Fairy Tail. They prefer to die than make a friend suffer.

-She stop some fights, like in this chap, but in others she made part of it. Like in the bar in GMG.

-She don't have any personality to do the paper work, and do all that stuff. She's wild, and that's really good, but not combine with the guildmaster.



Still there other reasons, but my point is, the best members to be the guildmaster are Laxus and Mira. If Laxus isn't there, why not Mira? She's really more capable in all that aspect.  She's political, she never showed to sacrifice anyone, she never be part of fights, and can do all paper work. And if it to stop a fight with fear, everyone knows she can be REALLY fearsome.

Nostalgic chapter. Takes me back to my early days of reading FT. The obligatory Lucy fanservice, the rumble, Erza owning them. And, of course, the saving of a fellow guild member. Only this time, it's the Guild Master who needs saving.

Chierii said:
That gossip tho.



So Erza's going to be the (temp) guild master?

Would have preferred it to be someone else....



Yeah, until they find Makarov I assume..

Darklight0303 said:
TheGrandSage23 said:
Erza as GM was logically sound. With the exception of Laxus but we didn't see anything from anyone else that screamed Guild Master. Mira doesn't count. For her being the right hand of Makarov we NEVER see anything of it. We never see her participate with Makarov in anything guild or council related.



Show us don't tell us.



Only two that made sense was Laxus or Erza. The leadership(more on Erza's side) the power the influence. The ability to get shit done. Erza can get hotheaded but that applies to Laxus and Makarov as well





Makes perfect sense. Some need to separate their bias



Leadership my ass she almost left Juvia to die for a stupid mission that didn't get them anything in the end.



"Almost left Juvia to die" when? The Avatar Arc? Where she had everything in her power to actually do something but sit and sulk?

"Didn't get them anything in the end" yet the sacrificial process was literally stopped in one day with thousands of lives saved and the council(aided by Erza) was practically knocking on Avatar's door



Thousands of lives>Juvia

SUP MEST!!

Ah yes, Erza being the seventh Guild master I can just imagine her making them do all the crazy things she wants. That'll be fun.

lmao the rumors about Gray, that was great.

metsujin said:
And of course everyone has their own opinion, on who the next master should be. I personally think she'll be temporally (maybe idk), and I would like her to have less screen time. Make her appear hear and there, but let the action to someone else.



Laxus Laxus

Darklight0303 said:
Trentor11 said:
KingAce261 said:
Trentor11 said:
I thought we were done playing Juvia as a victim in the Avatar Arc. She was pathetic and made her character worse

Plus besides being the leader of three wizards nothing about Laxus screams leadership. Mira doesn't count Lucy and Natsu sure as hell doesn't count either





Laxus does scream leadership he is the grandson of Gramps. He has more than enough power to maintain as well as protect the guild. The only candidate better to be temp GM would be Gildarts who knows lumen historie and was GM.



Being the grandson of Makarov doesn't put leadership in his blood. Gildarts doesn't scream leadership either



What's with people thinking power=leadership



And yet that's exactly how Erza got put as termporary master. Because she scared people aka POWER. Not because she earned it or deserved it. Double Standard much?

Technically she kinda earned temp cuz at one point in the anime Gramps considered her but said she was too young