Fairy Tail Chapter 366 Discussion

Silver, Gray's dad maybe?



Silver and Gray colour related?

Well,Natsu never said that Cana and Gildarts had a similar smell,I suppose...and he sniffed out Gray's smell on Silver right away...so that could eliminate this theory...Also,What kind of thing could make Silver hate Gray so much?Also,Gray guaranteed his parents were all killed.if that isn't the case...the reason could have been gray's mother and it was her grave to whom he was paying his respects...but it could have been Ur.Silver could have been paying her his respects for what happened with Urtear. Her sacrifice and his visit to it were so close...it could be related.



Gray managed to manipulate Silver's ice devil slayer magic...if Gray and Silver are the same person,that could be the reason.



Also, Silver and gray are synonyms ,with the difference being that while Gray is considered dull, silver is considered something more noble, better... if Silver is a future Gray, he has all the reasons to hate his previous human self and change his name...



If he came from the future, he came from future Lucy's timeline or from Future Rogue's future...I imagine that he fought with all his might against the 10.000 dragons/Acnologia....and was forced to watch while his friends were killed...with him unable to do much, while cursing his own weakness, as he did when Ur and Urtear sacrificed themselves for him...when finally he was finished, Zeref could have revived him as an demon...and sent him to the past to join with Tartarus.



I don't think that the splintering of the timeline into three different ones in the grand magic games was an accident.It was most likely calculated by someone...so that this third timeline, the current one, where Natsu defeated Rogue, could be created.



If this theory is true, then the following one could be as well...Silver, knowing the events that would occur in the future...ran away from Tartarus, and met Ur...romanced her...and without knowing got her pregnant...Then, for some reason, he was forced to leave her...possibly Tartarus...If Urtear is Silver's daughter,that could explain why she had so much magic power within her...to the point it made her sick...and then,Silver watched as events repeated themselves.



Well,this could explain why Sillver was so jolly around Natsu...and so pissed at hearing the name Gray...The only thing that could properly  explain his rage at Gray is Ur and Urtear's deaths...but he has Gray's smell,so can he can't be in theory Ur's husband and Urtear's father. Only this way can both theories be true.if not,both would be fake...at least according with the information we have



Well, if Mashima does this, he is basically mindfucking us. What do you think about this theory? Ithink it is madness. So much I am actually expecting it.We need to wait to see how Gray reacts to SIlver,though...if he doesnt recognize him,the father theory is dead.Also,Gray's scar on his forehead could have been covered with that scar Silver has.There is a weakness in this theory.



Yes,I don't think it is the case...when the eclipse was ruined...everyone returned to their proper place in time...could there be another way to travel through time...well,this is a mad speculation,regardless.Well,we will need to wait to check...well,he is connected to Gray,knows him,and even has his smell.This is promising.Poor Gray.

It's about time one of Tartarus finally put Natsu in his place. I mean, really. He better not get out of that ice himself.

short_review,



Because his love Juvia was killed? Rogue sayed that Acnologia will destroy everything and his friend Frosch was also killed during these events. I think it's now the same...

Don't also forget that Silver now is in his human form. What I don't get is if he is a demon himself, why does he like to consume souls of demons?

I'm also wondering if any of them know about Natsu's special connection to Zeref. Particularly Kyouka and if that'll affect how she deals with Natsu