- #82
Yeah, the main storyline is a mess, but Kaname and Yuuki ending up together had been in the cards ever since the begining.
With all due respect, I must disagree. For this particular manga, I don't think you can make the argument that the main storyline is a mess, but a certain pairing was planned out from the beginning.
In VK, the plot and the Love Triangle are totally interwoven into one another. In fact, the mangaka favored the LT above the plot. If there were some direction, some forethought put into one side of the story (whether the romance or the main plot), it would have in turn improved the other side of the story.
And overall, I think if the general readership had a sense that ANY part of the manga was actually planned, fans would be a lot less disappointed than they are now.
As things stand now, people are confused, and were caught off-guard with the way things developed (plot and romance-wise), and it doesn't matter WHICH side of the shipping line you stand on. That's not supposed to happen in a good story.
On the romance side, is there anyone who could have predicted sex would happen in 89? I don't mean sex happening between Yuuki and Kaname in general, if they are the manga's endgame couple, sex is not unexpected, but sex happening in that particular chapter? If anyone tries to say they expected Yuuki x Kaname sex in 89 before any of the spoilers came out, I'll call them a liar.
I think there's strong indications that Hino never knew which pairing she wanted until the last minute and she was forced to pick one.
I say this because of little things and big things. One of the little things I noticed was in the preview for VK that appeared in MeriPuri. The entire preview was Yuuki and Zero talking. There was no mention of Kaname whatsoever. If Kaname was absolutely supposed to be the lead male from the beginning, then why was he not in the preview? As lead male, he'd be one of the selling points of the manga, and therefore should have been in that preview, no?
One of the big things I noticed, probably the biggest, in fact, was that Zero was essentially the main character of the first arc. In fact, Hino herself joked about it in one of her side notes wondering who her main character was, Zero or Yuuki. If Zero's role in the story was always supposed to be merely the Knight, the guy who makes it so the heroine could end up with the guy she really loves, then why did he get a starring role in the first half of the story? There was no point in building up Zero to that degree if he wasn't a legitimate contender for male lead.
Incidentally, I think this is why he's being called "the Kuran's lapdog." His role in the story has ended up being no more than that, I'm sorry to say. If Hino had put Kaname and Yuuki together but let Zero achieve some well-defined major goal, something he'd been working toward for a long time, then that would've been great. He'd be his own person, with his own storyline, and his own set of concerns. Not someone who is a prop for someone else's storyline (Yuuki ending up with Kaname). So "the Kuran's lapdog" it is.
Edit: And let me just say, I think Zero letting go of his hatred is nice from a character development standpoint, but no, it does not count as "achieving a goal." Anything a character desires, works toward, and accomplishes is achieving a goal. "Making Yuuki happy" is, unfortunately, the only thing that qualifies in Zero's case.