- #10
What I've found that the problems you see in this book are fairly common in Japanese web novels. The problem with them is that they tend to be written by complete amateurs with no experience in creative writing. All they can do is draw on the material they read, and a lot of the material they read is just like this.
The way I see it is that a lot of this kind of writing would be okay in a manga where you have other visual detail to add to the story, but it sucks when all you have to work with is the written word. For examples, a lot of the expository material is taken care of by just seeing what the action looks like, and the first person problem is a non issue because the POV is handled by not being in your face. The fact that many protagonists are purposefully designed to be nonentities doesn't help things.
There are better Japanese web novels out there. Usually this happens when the writer can bring something extra to the story. But as this tends to require either real life experiences or that the writer has interests outside of otaku material, it's not all that common to encounter. I've found that Chinese web novelists tend to be much better when it comes to the mechanics of writing, but bear in mind that I don't read xianxia novels and these tend to draw the biggest complaints.
The way I see it is that a lot of this kind of writing would be okay in a manga where you have other visual detail to add to the story, but it sucks when all you have to work with is the written word. For examples, a lot of the expository material is taken care of by just seeing what the action looks like, and the first person problem is a non issue because the POV is handled by not being in your face. The fact that many protagonists are purposefully designed to be nonentities doesn't help things.
There are better Japanese web novels out there. Usually this happens when the writer can bring something extra to the story. But as this tends to require either real life experiences or that the writer has interests outside of otaku material, it's not all that common to encounter. I've found that Chinese web novelists tend to be much better when it comes to the mechanics of writing, but bear in mind that I don't read xianxia novels and these tend to draw the biggest complaints.