Karin Chapter 58 Discussion

azmaty said:
a classical "And they lived happily ever after" ending ^_____^'

Would have liked that :D  altrough I got to disagree on the anime and manga difference. Iit was hell to start the manga for me. Very difficult to get in the story as it was so different.

I want continuation, well we can assume that Karin can't be a Pure human, so what about her daughter, Kanon ?



It can be a nice plot for a second manga...

azmaty said:


Yeah, I was about to put "LOVED IT" when I voted...but I noticed that an end shouldn't make me CRY ! x') (yeah...I really cried...)

I voted "DISLIKED IT" because they erased her memory...it's abnormal that she's still able to talk and everything if she doesn't remember her family ! Or maybe she just "imagines" that she's been living all alone in her house ? (since her parents were sleepin'...) WEIRD !



AND ! I just can't imagine Karin puttin' her blood in someone's body...BY BITING THEM ! Well, she just leaves her teeth's marks ! Is she vomiting her blood ?



AND ALSO ! Thanks to you, Anime-Roach, because it's thanks to you if I read this ending ! I only watched the anime, and when I saw your forum post, I read it immediately ! <3 It's kinda awkward that Winner doesn't exist ! :

- SINCLAIR FAMILY DOESN'T EXIST

- ELDA WASN'T IN LOVE WITH A HUMAN (ALFRED)

- ANJU DOESN'T LIKE THE BLOOD OF A "JEALOUS PERSON" (BUT A LONELY PERSON INSTEAD) > since Maki isn't in love with Winner etc...

- BOOGIE-KUN IS STILL HERE ! (in the anime, he stops talking to Anju when she becomes an adult)...SO MUCH THINGS !

These made the anime funny, but I prefer the dramatic part of the manga (:





Ah np :P.



Warning some spoilers will be in it about the Anime.

But I have to say that the manga was far better than the anime. Altrough I really hated the erase memery part. But the anime just left so many things unanswered

and it sucked that the family got shot but than a few minutes later  just stand up again.



At first it was a bit weird reading the manga after the anime but the manga is far better :P



Overall Karin rules xD and yes I also cried at the end :'O

Anime-Roach said:


They should have just followed the manga. Thats always better as far as I know.



Yeah, but the thing is that most of the time, after seeing the anime, you always want to read the manga...a bit as if it was a publicity, so in a way, like I've been watching the anime before reading it, I'm glad it has been another story, that way, I really enjoyed both of them ! But...I actually would have enjoyed it to be a 2 ending story, like Death Note x) Of course, in the second ending, Karin would not have her memory blank about her family...a classical "And they lived happily ever after" ending ^_____^'

Such a bittersweet ending. It was great that she got to end up with a happy normal life, but losing her memories and not being able to see her family again is just sad. Yes, her life would have been harder with her knowing that she was a vampire, but experiences help build a persons identity so I think that losing all of those memories can be seen as being worse.

Anime-Roach said:
[...]altrough I got to disagree on the anime and manga difference. Iit was hell to start the manga for me. Very difficult to get in the story as it was so different.



Yeah...well, the thing is I read the manga 2...no wait, 3 years after watching the anime, so I think I just enjoyed it that way, to remember Karin's story.

Although the stories or quite different, I really liked both sides. Still, I think if they followed the manga story, I would feel mostly disappointed because the manga series usually last for 24 episodes and I think it would have just cut the manga short.



Like in Kaichou wa maid-sama...I kind of really dislike the anime for some reason.

good series but the ending feel very anticlimatic... 8/10

very very bad ending, dam