Fairy Tail Chapter 518 Discussion

Jelal will come and save her!

DeLegendarySwag said:
saltncheese said:
Next week!



Erza will be dying after taking on the meteor, Irene will pity her, swap bodies with her, Erza survives in Irene's body, Irene finally get's the body she wants and dies in it.



YES! I was thinking this as I read that chapter too, :D . Good, now this theory has a following.

Just as long as the ending isn't super basic, ie. Erza wins against the meteor and Irene is forgiven.



What´s the point of this.



That theory makes zero sense.



1. It goes against everything established between Irene and Erza. The whole biological family vs spiritual family, notion, thrown out the window.

2. It goes against everything Irene was established as and has not a single ounce of foreshadowing.

3. This would have major repercussions for Erza, both bodies look different and she would a be fucking Dragon, that transforms into a humna. Hiro barely writes his story with repercussions for the good guys and never for the Main cast.  What you guys demand was never there in the series. Why would he start now instead of just delivering his predictable shit?

4. It adds zero flavor to the story if they immediately find a convenient solution afterwards to have Erza turn back into her body or look the same and if she doesn´t, which would never happen because all her marketability and  her recognizeability would go poof, it adds nothing besides a changed character design, because Hiro Mashima is not an author that would go in depth with the consequences of living in someone elses body. How do i know that I read 518 chapters of this shit.



5. Now to the most retarded part of all that. Irene actively tried to do that and it failed. Why would it work now?



There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

If only Irene stops the meteor herself I would accept it as a some-what decent conclusion otherwise it will remain a big bunch of bs.

Noted:Erza can with broken bones and only one hand to reach the stratosphere.

I stopped reading this manga a few months ago, but since it was a new year and I heard Irene had finally confronted Erza, I was excited to catch up but I wish I hadn't.... now the only reason why I keep reading is to see a possible natsu vs acnologia fight (I'm guessing the reason why acnologia is not shown yet is because of the possible upcoming confrontation)

I don't know how to feel about this chapter honestly. I don't really care for any fight's of Erza's because the end result is just unsatisfactory in my opinion.



Just waiting till we go back to Natsu and the E.N.D stuff.

I'm sorry but this arc has been more of a chore to read. Back in Tartaros there were flaws(like every other arc) but it was clear Hiro was doing everything he could to bring his A game. My third favorite after Phantom and TOH



This just feels like padding. I can't explain it exactly. Obviously this Erza bullshit has to stop.. I think people in Japan love Erza when she does unrealistic things and Hiro has no reason not to stop I guess but come one I somehow find this worse than Kyouka



But besides that this arc just feels not needed. 465 is still one of my favorite chapters considering it contains 2 of the 3 characters this arc should be focused on

This chapter was pretty cool.



Then that last part happened.

My goodness! Irene is such a terrific villain. Erza proving once again she's the best ever heroine. Goddamn... this manga, such a fucking masterpiece.