Goth Chapter 5 Discussion

After a long time, somehow I manage to finish a manga. Gotta be like before!



Anyway, the last page explains me what author wanted to make this story. But imo it was a weak story and could been better. Especially the last chapter I feel like one guy or homunculus randomly showed and I don't know who exactly got killed. Orelse the suspense was at a satisfactory level (below average level if compared with DC's mystery). Could had expanded more mystery into it, then it could been an epic ride or a one of "must read manga".



Gets score of 5.5 from me. I will give credit for art and little bit of storytelling part.

The thing Itsuki said to Morino REALLY was interesing... too bad it's the end already. Or maybe good.

Great ending :)

Great ending~

The first two chapters were cool enough but I don't really have much to say for the last three ones. That Takami guy came out of nowhere and any twist that utilized him was too confusing to be effective.



Morino ain't dying yet but she's on a romantic version of death row thanks to Itsuki at least.

Eh, it could have been better. 7/10

FLCLeureka7 said:
It was an interesting ending, I love the way it end, but I'm little disappointed because I really want to see what'll happen after but still this is an great manga :)







I was a tad dissappointed too

I still don't understand what the bondaged girl in chapter 3 is for, or who that is. Is it just here for fanservice or it has a purpose? Who knows.

octal9 said:
beautiful art - really loved the surprise ending  - a true work of dark genius...really wish this series was had more chapters, but i guess the best art leaves you still a little hungry...



I agree 100%. Though parts of the story confused me easily, I enjoyed Goth in the end.

It was pretty awesome. The only thing I didn't like overall was that he let the 2nd murderer in the cafe walk way. But at least I bet he used the knives he stole from his place to  
kill his look-a-like/murderer--his first (and last?) kill The look-a-like Takami guy really confused the hell out of me until I reread chapters 2, 4, and 5.

I honestly didn't like it very much. I know what it was going for but I felt that it was trying to hard and I couldn't take it any seriously.

Saw that switch-a-roo coming a mile away.

Enjoyable for what it is, probably not gonna win any awards or anything like that but it was an interesting read