Witches Vs Werewolves

Majorr plothole: No one among the characters in the novel is asking why "Ross is hunting pirates". I mean, come on, I know that he looks at bounty posters for his system, but his crewmates don't. No one ever asked why he keeps on hunting pirates. Even the Marines don't have the curiosity. Ross is clearly a transmigrator, that means, his past life such as childhood came from earth. He has ''no' past in the world of one piece aside from being known as a pirate hunter. I just find it wasteful that the money in his bounty hunts cannot be claimed. Sheeesh... Though, he explicitly made his former cp members-now subordinates to retrieve it for him, I just feel that their is a lack of flavor to Ross's character. I wish for more fillers, I think it would be entertaining if his crewmates overthink of his past hehe...

This is a very good book and can be part of my Recommended List. And for readers like me who like to read reviews first before deciding if they will read the book, this is NOT your TYPICAL werewolf story if you’re like me who loves reading them. BUT it’s very worthy tackling the true concept of MATE

If you're into detective stories, crime, and thrills, Tantei Gakuen Q is definitely worth checking out.  

The stories are incredible, and you'll find yourself straining your brain to solve the mysteries. The crimes are well-crafted (really well-crafted), the detectives are compelling, and the plots are even more impressive.  

The character development is subtle yet effective, especially Ryu's growth, which is truly remarkable. Romance takes a backseat here (what can you expect from a detective manga, right?), and the art is not the main focus. However, the story more than compensates for any shortcomings.  

If you enjoyed the anime, you should absolutely give the manga a try—it's significantly better.  

<p>

Detective School Q, or Tantei Gakuen Q, is an extraordinary manga that stands out as quite unique.  
It falls under the shonen category because it features children, yet it delves into murder mysteries.  

Greatest mystery manga ever. Period. (No spoilers in this review)  

The Story: 9/10  
In Japan, the legendary Detective Dan Morihiko seeks a successor.  
To find one, he announces a detective written and practical exam.  
Many participants show up, but since it's a shonen series, those who qualify are:  
Kyu — A kid with sharp intuition and a never-say-die attitude.  
Megu — A girl with a photographic memory.  
Kinda — A physically gifted individual, possessing both brain and brawn.  
Ryu — A quiet genius.  

These kids stumble upon a murder mystery. And believe me, the mysteries in this manga are UNPARALLELED. They are crafted with great depth.  
I adore Sherlock Holmes, Poirot, and Agatha Christie, yet none of them delve into such intricate detail.  
The mangaka consistently provides clues as the story unfolds. Then, before revealing the solution, they say, "There are 3 clues and only 1 explanation."  
I love that part. I enjoy straining my brain to solve the puzzles, and many times, I succeed. The answers are ALWAYS satisfying, which is rare in the manga world, where loopholes are often easily spotted.  

Detective School Q is like an anthology, offering mystery after mystery. Some last for 5 chapters, while others span over 10 chapters long. But all are a pleasure to read.  
Running parallel to these smaller mysteries is a larger mystery arc that reaches its climax in the final chapters.  

Art: 8/10  
No complaints here. All characters are well-drawn and distinct. Important details relevant to the mystery are always depicted accurately. When re-reading some chapters to understand the mystery, I realized that some clues were hidden within the detailed illustrations too.  

Characters: 7/10  
Honestly, despite how much I cherished the manga, the characters didn't play a significant role. I grew fond of them after reading so many chapters, but there was little character development. Amakusa Ryu showed notable growth, though.  
But the mystery remains the central focus at all times, and both the mangaka and I are aware of this. No complaints here.  

Enjoyment: 8/8  
I adored it!! It was one of the first mangas I started reading. However, due to the lack of scanlations, I couldn't keep up, or else I would have finished it in three days.  
If you're a fan of mysteries, you'll relish this immensely. Just go ahead and read it.  
And if you don't wish to ponder too deeply about the cases, don't worry. The story itself is engaging on its own. It's written in such a way that everyone can enjoy it, provided they read carefully.  

The Devil’s Advocate:  
- At times, the mysteries might seem far-fetched. But who wants to read about simple robberies or violent murders?  
- Murders contain no gore; the story centers on the intellect alone.  
- Don't expect any action scenes or ecchi.  
- You may need to think to fully appreciate the story.  

The Verdict: 8/10  
This is an incredible and distinctive manga. A must-read for mystery enthusiasts.  
This is brain food, folks. Highly recommended.  

And as my favorite character says, "If the detective gives up, the mystery will never be solved."  

Thank you for reading my review! Hope you enjoy the manga!!

tl;dr: A manga featuring decent episodic mysteries but feels like it squanders its potential otherwise.  

As one might expect from the title, this manga revolves around a detective academy aimed at training a new generation of top-tier detectives. More precisely, it focuses on the five students of Class Q at Dan Detective School (DDS). This eclectic group ranges in age from elementary school to high school, with most attending regular schools outside DDS as well. What unites them as Class Q is their shared goal of becoming the successor to Dan, Japan's greatest detective. They must compete against each other for this prestigious title while also vying against other classes, particularly Class A, which constantly seeks to replace them in Class Q. Despite being students, they tackle numerous cases, many of which prove perilous. Notably, those involving the enigmatic evil organization Pluto are especially dangerous. Pluto itself doesn't commit murders but specializes in selling blueprints for perfect crimes.  

This is a serial mystery manga, so naturally, the mysteries take center stage. Overall, I'd say they're decent but not exceptional. They're logically sound, free of glaring plot holes, and adhere to the rules of good mystery writing—meaning they're solvable. However, most aren't particularly engaging. Some of this stems from their tendency toward absurdity, requiring significant suspension of disbelief, yet lacking the audacity to truly astonish. They fall into a gray area where they aren't impressive either in terms of realism or sheer outlandishness. While everything makes sense when piecing together clues, it generally lacks satisfaction. Moreover, the contexts became repetitive, making outcomes predictable even before all clues were revealed. By the second half, I could often guess the culprit based solely on narrative structure and framing, diminishing the impact.  

What made this especially frustrating was that the premise offered far more potential. The plot includes a diverse group of detectives competing among themselves, collaborating against rival classes, and battling an evil organization dedicated to crafting intricate mysteries. This setup promised substantial variety in case dynamics. Although the manga incorporates these elements to some extent, it feels underutilized. Most cases followed a conventional formula, feeling rather mundane. That said, the final case stands out as a notable exception, leveraging these elements effectively for a unique and compelling conclusion, resulting in a strong finale.  

The finale heavily features one of the main characters, Ryu, who undergoes solid character development with a straightforward yet satisfying arc. His friendship with another key character, Kyu, is also developed reasonably well. Unfortunately, the rest of the cast pales in comparison. Kyu receives some background and development, though it feels insufficient given his prominence. The other three members receive even less attention, their sole moments of individuality coming from isolated attempts to solve mysteries independently, as Kyu and Ryu typically shoulder the majority of the investigative work. Romantic undertones exist but remain too subtle to merit much notice. Supporting characters, including criminals and witnesses, also fail to leave lasting impressions, save for Cerberus and Ukon. Consequently, character depth is notably lacking. The sequel, *Premium*, acts as a time-skip continuation but adds little beyond additional mysteries within its limited scope.  

Regarding art, it suffices to communicate necessary information. However, it never shines visually, with a bland style and uninspired designs that lack dynamic framing to elevate them.