Okay, Claymore is one of the best, if not the best, in terms of balancing action and plot development. The story unfolds in a nation where monsters known as 'Youma' prey on humans, marking the introduction of our protagonist Clare. An organization recruits and trains young female warriors (half-human, half-Youma) to combat the Youma population for a fee. Clare, one of these so-called 'Claymores' (a nickname given by villagers due to their weapon), dutifully carries out the organization's orders. However, as I mentioned, Claymore excels in plot development, branching into various sub-plots that offer different perspectives.
Story: 10/10
The narrative stands out as the series' highlight, growing more captivating with each chapter. The initial chapters set up the scenario, gradually revealing details about the organization and introducing new characters. Predicting the next event is nearly impossible; it’s an enthralling story. Despite its shounen genre, the plot's logic remains impressive and grounded.
Art: 10/10
Nohiro Yagi shines both as an artist and a writer. His depiction of Youma aligns perfectly with imagination, yet he leaves nothing to the imagination in terms of detail. Each Youma is unique, showcasing remarkable creativity. The Claymores, being female warriors, share certain characteristics, but their designs are distinct. The meticulous artwork in each chapter enhances readability, making the story not just captivating but also easy to follow.
Character: 8/10
This is the sole area where Claymore doesn't earn a perfect score from me. While characters like Clare and those close to her are well-developed, others remain somewhat enigmatic. Character development could use some improvement, especially regarding personality depth among the Claymores. Although they are partially human, they possess human consciousness and emotions, which should be explored further. This minor flaw, however, does little to detract from the overall excellence of the manga.
Overall: 10/10
As you delve into the manga, you'll notice how character development intertwines seamlessly with the story and art. Everything in this series meshes perfectly, creating something truly unique. I might be biased since Claymore is the best manga I've ever read, but rest assured, it won’t disappoint. It never feels repetitive, with each chapter leaving you eager for the next. Though released monthly, the wait is worthwhile because there’s nothing quite like it. I recommend it to anyone who enjoys deep plots coupled with intense action—oh, and did I mention the fierce female warriors? :)
Typically, I'm not someone who delves into dark fantasy stories often, but "Claymore" turned out to be an exceptionally captivating experience. The narrative revolves around a group of Claymores battling monsters of various strengths and powers. Despite the potential for a formulaic storyline, it successfully sustains an air of mystery, gradually building on its foundations and introducing numerous twists that keep the plot unpredictable. Characters frequently face life-threatening situations, leaving readers uncertain of their fates, as deaths occur regularly. The violence depicted in "Claymore," while sometimes spectacular, can evoke genuine terror. The story is skillfully crafted, maintaining a consistent tone of grimness and despair while remaining believable. The flashback arc at the beginning establishes a strong foundation, from which the narrative continues to evolve, providing clear motivations for the characters. What intrigued me was that the main character isn't the sole catalyst for the plot; there are multiple moving parts, sometimes resulting in 3-4 events unfolding simultaneously, creating chaotic scenarios.
There's a rich cast of characters in "Claymore." Clare serves as a strong yet flawed protagonist, not overpowering but deeply human, making her relatable and likable. Her growth is evident both in strength and character development. Along the journey, we encounter many companions, some of whom don't receive extensive development, but their interactions and motivations make them distinct and endearing.
The manga introduces an easily understandable ranking system, giving readers a sense of each character's strength relative to their foes, instilling awe and wonder about how certain enemies might be defeated. The power system is intriguing, with each character possessing unique moves that add strategic elements to the fights.
The artwork is one of the manga's standout features. Though the Claymores' similar appearances can cause confusion at times, it doesn't detract significantly from the experience. The action sequences, enhanced by speed lines, keep things engaging and fast-paced. Many monsters, especially later in the story, have intricate and unique designs that look cool, often showcased in full-page spreads highlighting their features.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this manga and would highly recommend it to those seeking a well-thought-out and compelling fantasy. While I usually avoid overly violent stories, this one feels appropriately balanced—not too dark—and excels in developing both its setting and characters meaningfully. It kept me engaged from start to finish with its creativity, plot twists, and stunning artwork.
I don't understand why this series is so underrated. It's seldom discussed, but for me, it's excellent and thoroughly satisfying to read from start to finish. It has a similar vibe to Berserk, with the main difference being the numerous female swordswomen in this series. It feels like a sibling to Berserk, sharing settings of dark and medieval ages. The protagonist is very likable; she may not be the strongest, but she is brave and determined. She isn't afraid of dying. Her sole mission is to kill the person who murdered her foster mother figure, which motivates her journey and becoming one of the Claymores. She follows in the footsteps of her mother figure.
The child companion of the main character grows up to be quite impressive. Initially useless, he becomes strong after a seven-year time skip and finally learns to hit enemies with his sword. The man who teaches him swordsmanship is a male Claymore, showing that Claymores aren't just women fighting monsters—there are male Claymores too. For me, the ending was immensely satisfying.
This is one of the most stunning manga I've ever read! If that statement isn't enough to convince you, let me elaborate.
Fantasy settings have always been brimming with highly acclaimed works, and Claymore is no exception. The reason I hold this manga in such high regard and believe it deserves all the praise is primarily due to three reasons.
1. The Art: If you think manga with black and white imagery can't look gorgeous, once you start reading Claymore, you'll reconsider. The art genuinely astonished me; I've never seen a series with such consistent and meticulously detailed artwork from start to finish. I honestly don't know how the author (Norihiro Yagi) managed to produce weekly chapters, but it deserves serious accolades. Sometimes in manga, there are panels where you're unsure of what's happening, but this issue is absent in Claymore because the drawings are so detailed that even the backgrounds look breathtaking. This manga stands out solely based on its artwork.
2. A Rare Female Cast: There are definitely other anime and manga out there featuring female casts, but what makes Claymore's cast stand out is how they are treated. Every single one of them gets a chance to shine. Usually, in anime/manga, you don't see females getting such prominent roles (not to sound sexist, but it's true). I can confidently say that each character in Claymore is unique, and they utilize strategy rather than relying solely on raw power to defeat their enemies.
3. The Story: It has an amazing start and one of the best endings I've ever seen. While the story becomes somewhat repetitive after a certain point, within the realm of this manga, the author did a great job. So many unexpected plot twists keep you engaged.
Some additional highlights include gorgeously choreographed fights where you can feel every motion of the characters involved. The battles require actual skill, and while the concept of Yoma (the antagonists) seems basic at first, the series later delivers epic moments left and right. Some panels literally made my jaw drop, and I found myself looking at them several times to appreciate their beauty.
I can confidently say that Claymore is one of the best manga I've ever read and think it deserves all the praise it receives.
I'd 100% recommend this to people new to manga or those tired of the typical male protagonist trope who want something fresh and enjoyable from start to finish.
The wonderful thing is that while the art in Claymore is amazing, the story, characters, and world-building are also top-tier. It has everything, and perhaps the only minor criticisms I have are that it could have been longer or if the story was less predictable. All in all, it's a solid 9/10.
If you're looking for a great shounen manga, Claymore is an absolute must-read. It stands out as the best shounen manga I've ever encountered. With its lengthy narrative and dark, intense plot, Claymore offers a thoroughly enjoyable reading experience.
The story unfolds in an alternate medieval world where humans coexist with Yoma—monstrous creatures that feed on human flesh. A secretive organization has created half-human, half-Yoma warriors (all female, with reasons explained) to protect humanity from these creatures, albeit at a high price. These warriors are known as "Claymores" due to the massive swords they carry. Formerly human, Claymores gain supernatural abilities but lose their humanity when injected with Yoma blood. They are feared and distrusted by society. The narrative begins in a village plagued by a mysterious Yoma. The villagers hire a Claymore named Clare to deal with the threat. A young boy named Raki, who lost his family to a Yoma, becomes fascinated by Clare and joins her journey after she slays his brother Zaki, who turned out to be the Yoma. Clare and Raki's journey together forms the core of the story, leading them through various challenges and mysteries.
At first glance, the plot might seem simple and unoriginal. The premise of half-human warriors battling monsters isn't groundbreaking. The beginning moves slowly, with repetitive elements. However, upon closer inspection, the richness of the characters and the sheer enjoyment make up for any perceived shortcomings. What makes Claymore exceptional is its vast array of memorable characters and the pure pleasure it provides. Despite its slow start, the manga quickly becomes captivating. While combat is central, the series also incorporates intriguing subplots, such as the rankings of the 47 Claymores, each with unique abilities. When Claymores exceed their limits, they become powerful Awakened Beings. The storyline evolves into a war-like narrative involving three dominant Awakened Beings controlling different regions, creating complex dynamics with current Claymores and Abyss Feeders.
The characters in Claymore are nothing short of remarkable. Each one is intricately developed and compelling, from Clare to her mentor Teresa, friends like Galatea and Miria, and enemies like Priscilla. Even minor characters have interesting backstories without slowing down the pace. The artwork is another standout feature. The clean character designs and stunning monster concepts add a unique flavor to the story. The backgrounds are beautifully shaded, setting the perfect mood. The visual portrayal of Claymores, both in appearance and action, is simply mesmerizing.
While some might argue that Claymore explores deep themes like sin, forgiveness, and humanity, I see it primarily as a source of pure entertainment. For fans of shounen stories, Claymore ranks among the best, comparable to masterpieces like Gintama and Hunter x Hunter. Its innovative take on standard concepts and engaging war-like storyline keep readers hooked. Though it lacks profound philosophical themes, the series remains highly enjoyable. If you love adventure, action, and excellent manga, Claymore comes highly recommended. To reiterate, Claymore is incredibly enjoyable.
It begins straightforwardly, with claymores (also known as silver-eyed witches) performing their duties. A character forms a bond with one, and they embark on journeys together.
The complexity escalates significantly later on, yet it preserves its overall rhythm. My primary issue was the occasional dragging of events. I usually steer clear of animes like Bleach, Naruto, One Piece, Fairy Tail, and similar ones for this reason. Battles extend endlessly, and there can be extensive dialogues at times. So, if this aspect will frustrate you, Claymore might not be the manga for you.
HOWEVER, the prolonged sequences don't emerge until a specific arc. I liken Claymore to Air Gear in this regard. Both Claymore and Air Gear had their anime adaptations cut short. The comparison is apt because both series start encountering drawn-out conversations and battles after their respective anime endings.
I'm uncertain about recommending it wholeheartedly, as many people, myself included, found the ending unsatisfying. This is a significant drawback given that it's quite a lengthy read, so proceed with caution.
Mixed feelings. The manga offers impressive worldbuilding, but it's somewhat incomplete in parts. Ninety percent of the characters are visually appealing, yet their potential is underutilized, and some receive unsatisfactory conclusions. The climax becomes hard to follow due to overwhelming text, leading me to abandon comprehension attempts and just look at the illustrations instead. Additionally, the characters’ similar appearances only add to the confusion. The ending feels abrupt and rushed. And why on earth isn't there a flash-forward? An ending without a flash-forward isn’t truly an ending. Where is my flash-forward?
I would barely rate Claymore as average, heavily carried by a few standout characters. That's the ultimate issue with Claymore, among other things.
While watching and reading both Claymore and Ooku: The Inner Chambers simultaneously, I gave the Claymore anime a higher rating than the Ooku anime, and I don't regret those scores. Claymore did have an intriguing concept and some fascinating characters, like Teresa, her backstory, Riful, Isley, and a handful of others. It offered lore and world-building. Meanwhile, Ooku had a slow start with a narrow perspective. Currently, the Ooku manga is a masterpiece that resolved all the issues from the anime and more. In contrast, Claymore started to decline in quality over time, leading to a reversal in their ratings.
The main problem with Claymore is its bland protagonist surrounded mostly by equally uninteresting characters. They look alike and share similar personalities, making it hard to distinguish one from another. This would be tolerable if it were just a group of five or so, but there are over 40 women who look and act similarly.
Of course, there are exceptions. Characters like the nun Claymore, the mother and daughter Claymore, and Teresa stand out with unique personalities. Two of the awakened beings also have compelling characters. These individuals single-handedly carry the show's score. Without them, this score would plummet to a 4/10.
Would I recommend it? Mixed feelings. There are moments of brilliance within Claymore, such as the great villains Riful and Isley with their interesting personalities. There are memorable characters and heart-wrenching moments. However, these positives are overshadowed by the character Raki (a waste) and the multitude of claymores who all look and act the same. Bonus points for girl power, I suppose. But honestly, you'd be better off reading a girl power manga where the women have diverse looks, personalities, and display different types of strength and resolve.
This manga has a rather weak start, especially with the first 20 chapters being particularly lacking in every aspect. It only began to get interesting more than a third of the way through, which led me to abandon it for something more original.
Art: The initial 20 chapters feature incredibly boring monster designs, consisting merely of featureless silhouettes of large men that all look identical. The faces of human characters are awkwardly drawn, with eyes placed irregularly and unattractively. The action scenes also suffer from poor paneling and logic. Battles often involve characters seemingly teleporting behind each other or floating in the air, despite their inability to actually teleport or fly. While it's fantasy, the lack of realism in fight sequences—whether in terms of movement lines, sword reach, or armor functionality—is quite bothersome. The strategies and context in these fights are mostly typical of standard battle shounen series.
Luckily, by around chapter 30, the monster design becomes truly impressive, and the art generally improves as well. However, many fight scenes still have the same issues.
Worldbuilding/Story: By chapter 60, the story starts to become interesting, but the world remains extremely bland. I'm a third of the way through the series and there is practically no world-building. Every town looks like a generic medieval setting with no unique features to distinguish one from another. I have no idea about the economy, religion, politics, or culture because they simply aren't developed. For instance, even when characters visit a major religious center within the first five chapters, we only see two locations, including the inside of their hotel room. Despite being in a religious hub, I learned almost nothing about the beliefs or lore, other than it being vaguely Catholic. Another example is that Clare’s organization operates in 47 provinces, yet I have no idea who rules any of them, including those Clare has visited. There's also very little information about the organization itself or the origins of the demons they fight.
Character: The characters are serviceable but not particularly likable. It doesn’t help that all the "Claymores" look very similar. There is one character I didn’t like: the boy Clare is protecting. He’s whiny and often gets Clare injured by ignoring her instructions.
If I read everything on my TBR list, I might return to this series to see if it continues to improve until the end. But with an extremely weak first eighth and a mediocre first third, I couldn’t rate the series higher than an 8, even if the ending was flawless.
The only issue I have with this manga is that the characters look quite similar, making it difficult for me to remember their names and distinguish them from one another.
The art style, however, is among the best I've seen, and it's easy to follow the action and understand what's happening in each panel, unlike some other dark fantasy manga out there. The main character reminds me of Lightning from Final Fantasy XIII—she doesn't speak much and lets her actions do the talking. The final battle was absolutely PERFECT for me! (That’s just my opinion, though.)
If you enjoy dark fantasy action adventures where character deaths are depicted without holding back, and if you appreciate a strong and lovable female protagonist, then this manga might be exactly what you're looking for.
Overall, I truly enjoyed this manga and it will always remain one of my favorites.
It's an outstanding manga in the action/fantasy genre.
This manga is set in medieval times and promotes the notion that to defeat a monster, one must become a monster. It highlights the significance of love, teamwork, and friendship. There's a good mix of drama and plot twists. Despite its initial setting, it’s a remarkably complex manga.
It's filled with action and has an incredible storyline. Though it might seem generic and basic at first glance, the art and action sequences keep you engaged until you reach a point where everything intensifies, drawing you completely in.
Out of all the manga I've read as a decade-long enthusiast, for me, Claymore stands out as number one... BY FAR.
Claymore is the embodiment of an RPG-like manga, with its eerie atmosphere and just the right amount of gore and "breasts," making it stand out like a perfectly cooked mild curry dish - not overly spiced yet flavorful enough.
1-Story 10/10
This is undoubtedly the most remarkable aspect of this manga. While the characters didn't exactly leap off the page, the story more than compensated for their shortcomings. Often, the narrative wasn't omnidirectional; instead, it leaned towards a storytelling style that might have been better suited as a novel. However, it worked splendidly as a manga too. The story followed the heroine's point of view, emphasizing her tragic past which profoundly influenced her growth and the plot's progression. Her past had a significant impact on shaping her actions driven by revenge and love. Set in a semi-medieval era, my favorite setting, I admit to some bias. The story isn't overly complex but still offers engaging plot twists and surprising events. The pacing was generally fine, though at times it felt rushed, albeit negligibly so.
2-Art 9.5/10
The artwork is stunning and does justice to the story, crafted with evident passion and imagination. Occasionally, distinguishing between characters was challenging due to their identical uniforms, blonde hair, and peculiar names and skills. Conversely, the art for the awakened beings was exceptional and unique, offering much more detail and background than other manga monsters. The landscapes were breathtaking, featuring beautiful European-style plains and hills. The reason for the 9.5 rating was some battle technique panels where the high-speed attacks made comprehension difficult without focused attention, though this rarely occurred.
3-Characters 9.5/10
The characters are great but not extraordinary. Their pasts receive considerable emphasis, which I personally appreciate but others might not. The heroine is exceptionally well-developed, while other characters are nothing short of amazing. My only gripe involves one or two antagonists portrayed as "evil" which felt unnecessary. Otherwise, the characters were well-rounded, each with unique skills rather than repetitive ones. Many characters emerge throughout the manga, each distinct with detailed backstories. They mature alongside the story, showcasing resilience and brilliance. The villain's portrayal is intriguing and best left unspoiled, ensuring you'll be both confused and captivated when discovered later in the story.
4-Enjoyment 1000000000/10!
I often tell friends that if Bones ever animated this, it would be the ultimate anime. The battles, enemies, techniques, and high-speed/phantom attacks... oh, how I dream about it! This manga shines brightly in my eyes, leaving me feeling as if I've completed a masterfully crafted RPG game. It delivers the vibe I've sought since beginning my anime journey, making it the ultimate manga for me.
5-Overall 10/10
I believe I've written extensively about this masterpiece. Just read it; it's only 156 chapters long. IT WILL BLOW YOU OUT OF PROPORTIONS.
Popular Reviews
Okay, Claymore is one of the best, if not the best, in terms of balancing action and plot development. The story unfolds in a nation where monsters known as 'Youma' prey on humans, marking the introduction of our protagonist Clare. An organization recruits and trains young female warriors (half-human, half-Youma) to combat the Youma population for a fee. Clare, one of these so-called 'Claymores' (a nickname given by villagers due to their weapon), dutifully carries out the organization's orders. However, as I mentioned, Claymore excels in plot development, branching into various sub-plots that offer different perspectives.
Story: 10/10
The narrative stands out as the series' highlight, growing more captivating with each chapter. The initial chapters set up the scenario, gradually revealing details about the organization and introducing new characters. Predicting the next event is nearly impossible; it’s an enthralling story. Despite its shounen genre, the plot's logic remains impressive and grounded.
Art: 10/10
Nohiro Yagi shines both as an artist and a writer. His depiction of Youma aligns perfectly with imagination, yet he leaves nothing to the imagination in terms of detail. Each Youma is unique, showcasing remarkable creativity. The Claymores, being female warriors, share certain characteristics, but their designs are distinct. The meticulous artwork in each chapter enhances readability, making the story not just captivating but also easy to follow.
Character: 8/10
This is the sole area where Claymore doesn't earn a perfect score from me. While characters like Clare and those close to her are well-developed, others remain somewhat enigmatic. Character development could use some improvement, especially regarding personality depth among the Claymores. Although they are partially human, they possess human consciousness and emotions, which should be explored further. This minor flaw, however, does little to detract from the overall excellence of the manga.
Overall: 10/10
As you delve into the manga, you'll notice how character development intertwines seamlessly with the story and art. Everything in this series meshes perfectly, creating something truly unique. I might be biased since Claymore is the best manga I've ever read, but rest assured, it won’t disappoint. It never feels repetitive, with each chapter leaving you eager for the next. Though released monthly, the wait is worthwhile because there’s nothing quite like it. I recommend it to anyone who enjoys deep plots coupled with intense action—oh, and did I mention the fierce female warriors? :)
Typically, I'm not someone who delves into dark fantasy stories often, but "Claymore" turned out to be an exceptionally captivating experience. The narrative revolves around a group of Claymores battling monsters of various strengths and powers. Despite the potential for a formulaic storyline, it successfully sustains an air of mystery, gradually building on its foundations and introducing numerous twists that keep the plot unpredictable. Characters frequently face life-threatening situations, leaving readers uncertain of their fates, as deaths occur regularly. The violence depicted in "Claymore," while sometimes spectacular, can evoke genuine terror. The story is skillfully crafted, maintaining a consistent tone of grimness and despair while remaining believable. The flashback arc at the beginning establishes a strong foundation, from which the narrative continues to evolve, providing clear motivations for the characters. What intrigued me was that the main character isn't the sole catalyst for the plot; there are multiple moving parts, sometimes resulting in 3-4 events unfolding simultaneously, creating chaotic scenarios. There's a rich cast of characters in "Claymore." Clare serves as a strong yet flawed protagonist, not overpowering but deeply human, making her relatable and likable. Her growth is evident both in strength and character development. Along the journey, we encounter many companions, some of whom don't receive extensive development, but their interactions and motivations make them distinct and endearing. The manga introduces an easily understandable ranking system, giving readers a sense of each character's strength relative to their foes, instilling awe and wonder about how certain enemies might be defeated. The power system is intriguing, with each character possessing unique moves that add strategic elements to the fights. The artwork is one of the manga's standout features. Though the Claymores' similar appearances can cause confusion at times, it doesn't detract significantly from the experience. The action sequences, enhanced by speed lines, keep things engaging and fast-paced. Many monsters, especially later in the story, have intricate and unique designs that look cool, often showcased in full-page spreads highlighting their features. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this manga and would highly recommend it to those seeking a well-thought-out and compelling fantasy. While I usually avoid overly violent stories, this one feels appropriately balanced—not too dark—and excels in developing both its setting and characters meaningfully. It kept me engaged from start to finish with its creativity, plot twists, and stunning artwork.
I don't understand why this series is so underrated. It's seldom discussed, but for me, it's excellent and thoroughly satisfying to read from start to finish. It has a similar vibe to Berserk, with the main difference being the numerous female swordswomen in this series. It feels like a sibling to Berserk, sharing settings of dark and medieval ages. The protagonist is very likable; she may not be the strongest, but she is brave and determined. She isn't afraid of dying. Her sole mission is to kill the person who murdered her foster mother figure, which motivates her journey and becoming one of the Claymores. She follows in the footsteps of her mother figure.
The child companion of the main character grows up to be quite impressive. Initially useless, he becomes strong after a seven-year time skip and finally learns to hit enemies with his sword. The man who teaches him swordsmanship is a male Claymore, showing that Claymores aren't just women fighting monsters—there are male Claymores too. For me, the ending was immensely satisfying.
This is one of the most stunning manga I've ever read! If that statement isn't enough to convince you, let me elaborate.
Fantasy settings have always been brimming with highly acclaimed works, and Claymore is no exception. The reason I hold this manga in such high regard and believe it deserves all the praise is primarily due to three reasons.
1. The Art: If you think manga with black and white imagery can't look gorgeous, once you start reading Claymore, you'll reconsider. The art genuinely astonished me; I've never seen a series with such consistent and meticulously detailed artwork from start to finish. I honestly don't know how the author (Norihiro Yagi) managed to produce weekly chapters, but it deserves serious accolades. Sometimes in manga, there are panels where you're unsure of what's happening, but this issue is absent in Claymore because the drawings are so detailed that even the backgrounds look breathtaking. This manga stands out solely based on its artwork.
2. A Rare Female Cast: There are definitely other anime and manga out there featuring female casts, but what makes Claymore's cast stand out is how they are treated. Every single one of them gets a chance to shine. Usually, in anime/manga, you don't see females getting such prominent roles (not to sound sexist, but it's true). I can confidently say that each character in Claymore is unique, and they utilize strategy rather than relying solely on raw power to defeat their enemies.
3. The Story: It has an amazing start and one of the best endings I've ever seen. While the story becomes somewhat repetitive after a certain point, within the realm of this manga, the author did a great job. So many unexpected plot twists keep you engaged.
Some additional highlights include gorgeously choreographed fights where you can feel every motion of the characters involved. The battles require actual skill, and while the concept of Yoma (the antagonists) seems basic at first, the series later delivers epic moments left and right. Some panels literally made my jaw drop, and I found myself looking at them several times to appreciate their beauty.
I can confidently say that Claymore is one of the best manga I've ever read and think it deserves all the praise it receives.
I'd 100% recommend this to people new to manga or those tired of the typical male protagonist trope who want something fresh and enjoyable from start to finish.
The wonderful thing is that while the art in Claymore is amazing, the story, characters, and world-building are also top-tier. It has everything, and perhaps the only minor criticisms I have are that it could have been longer or if the story was less predictable. All in all, it's a solid 9/10.
It's definitely one of my favorite manga, haha.
Thanks for reading!
If you're looking for a great shounen manga, Claymore is an absolute must-read. It stands out as the best shounen manga I've ever encountered. With its lengthy narrative and dark, intense plot, Claymore offers a thoroughly enjoyable reading experience.
The story unfolds in an alternate medieval world where humans coexist with Yoma—monstrous creatures that feed on human flesh. A secretive organization has created half-human, half-Yoma warriors (all female, with reasons explained) to protect humanity from these creatures, albeit at a high price. These warriors are known as "Claymores" due to the massive swords they carry. Formerly human, Claymores gain supernatural abilities but lose their humanity when injected with Yoma blood. They are feared and distrusted by society. The narrative begins in a village plagued by a mysterious Yoma. The villagers hire a Claymore named Clare to deal with the threat. A young boy named Raki, who lost his family to a Yoma, becomes fascinated by Clare and joins her journey after she slays his brother Zaki, who turned out to be the Yoma. Clare and Raki's journey together forms the core of the story, leading them through various challenges and mysteries.
At first glance, the plot might seem simple and unoriginal. The premise of half-human warriors battling monsters isn't groundbreaking. The beginning moves slowly, with repetitive elements. However, upon closer inspection, the richness of the characters and the sheer enjoyment make up for any perceived shortcomings. What makes Claymore exceptional is its vast array of memorable characters and the pure pleasure it provides. Despite its slow start, the manga quickly becomes captivating. While combat is central, the series also incorporates intriguing subplots, such as the rankings of the 47 Claymores, each with unique abilities. When Claymores exceed their limits, they become powerful Awakened Beings. The storyline evolves into a war-like narrative involving three dominant Awakened Beings controlling different regions, creating complex dynamics with current Claymores and Abyss Feeders.
The characters in Claymore are nothing short of remarkable. Each one is intricately developed and compelling, from Clare to her mentor Teresa, friends like Galatea and Miria, and enemies like Priscilla. Even minor characters have interesting backstories without slowing down the pace. The artwork is another standout feature. The clean character designs and stunning monster concepts add a unique flavor to the story. The backgrounds are beautifully shaded, setting the perfect mood. The visual portrayal of Claymores, both in appearance and action, is simply mesmerizing.
While some might argue that Claymore explores deep themes like sin, forgiveness, and humanity, I see it primarily as a source of pure entertainment. For fans of shounen stories, Claymore ranks among the best, comparable to masterpieces like Gintama and Hunter x Hunter. Its innovative take on standard concepts and engaging war-like storyline keep readers hooked. Though it lacks profound philosophical themes, the series remains highly enjoyable. If you love adventure, action, and excellent manga, Claymore comes highly recommended. To reiterate, Claymore is incredibly enjoyable.
Claymore, a manga with numerous story arcs.
It begins straightforwardly, with claymores (also known as silver-eyed witches) performing their duties. A character forms a bond with one, and they embark on journeys together.
The complexity escalates significantly later on, yet it preserves its overall rhythm. My primary issue was the occasional dragging of events. I usually steer clear of animes like Bleach, Naruto, One Piece, Fairy Tail, and similar ones for this reason. Battles extend endlessly, and there can be extensive dialogues at times. So, if this aspect will frustrate you, Claymore might not be the manga for you.
HOWEVER, the prolonged sequences don't emerge until a specific arc.
I liken Claymore to Air Gear in this regard. Both Claymore and Air Gear had their anime adaptations cut short. The comparison is apt because both series start encountering drawn-out conversations and battles after their respective anime endings.
I'm uncertain about recommending it wholeheartedly, as many people, myself included, found the ending unsatisfying. This is a significant drawback given that it's quite a lengthy read, so proceed with caution.
Mixed feelings. The manga offers impressive worldbuilding, but it's somewhat incomplete in parts. Ninety percent of the characters are visually appealing, yet their potential is underutilized, and some receive unsatisfactory conclusions. The climax becomes hard to follow due to overwhelming text, leading me to abandon comprehension attempts and just look at the illustrations instead. Additionally, the characters’ similar appearances only add to the confusion. The ending feels abrupt and rushed. And why on earth isn't there a flash-forward? An ending without a flash-forward isn’t truly an ending. Where is my flash-forward?
I would barely rate Claymore as average, heavily carried by a few standout characters. That's the ultimate issue with Claymore, among other things.
While watching and reading both Claymore and Ooku: The Inner Chambers simultaneously, I gave the Claymore anime a higher rating than the Ooku anime, and I don't regret those scores. Claymore did have an intriguing concept and some fascinating characters, like Teresa, her backstory, Riful, Isley, and a handful of others. It offered lore and world-building. Meanwhile, Ooku had a slow start with a narrow perspective. Currently, the Ooku manga is a masterpiece that resolved all the issues from the anime and more. In contrast, Claymore started to decline in quality over time, leading to a reversal in their ratings.
The main problem with Claymore is its bland protagonist surrounded mostly by equally uninteresting characters. They look alike and share similar personalities, making it hard to distinguish one from another. This would be tolerable if it were just a group of five or so, but there are over 40 women who look and act similarly.
Of course, there are exceptions. Characters like the nun Claymore, the mother and daughter Claymore, and Teresa stand out with unique personalities. Two of the awakened beings also have compelling characters. These individuals single-handedly carry the show's score. Without them, this score would plummet to a 4/10.
Would I recommend it? Mixed feelings. There are moments of brilliance within Claymore, such as the great villains Riful and Isley with their interesting personalities. There are memorable characters and heart-wrenching moments. However, these positives are overshadowed by the character Raki (a waste) and the multitude of claymores who all look and act the same. Bonus points for girl power, I suppose. But honestly, you'd be better off reading a girl power manga where the women have diverse looks, personalities, and display different types of strength and resolve.
This manga has a rather weak start, especially with the first 20 chapters being particularly lacking in every aspect. It only began to get interesting more than a third of the way through, which led me to abandon it for something more original.
Art: The initial 20 chapters feature incredibly boring monster designs, consisting merely of featureless silhouettes of large men that all look identical. The faces of human characters are awkwardly drawn, with eyes placed irregularly and unattractively. The action scenes also suffer from poor paneling and logic. Battles often involve characters seemingly teleporting behind each other or floating in the air, despite their inability to actually teleport or fly. While it's fantasy, the lack of realism in fight sequences—whether in terms of movement lines, sword reach, or armor functionality—is quite bothersome. The strategies and context in these fights are mostly typical of standard battle shounen series.
Luckily, by around chapter 30, the monster design becomes truly impressive, and the art generally improves as well. However, many fight scenes still have the same issues.
Worldbuilding/Story: By chapter 60, the story starts to become interesting, but the world remains extremely bland. I'm a third of the way through the series and there is practically no world-building. Every town looks like a generic medieval setting with no unique features to distinguish one from another. I have no idea about the economy, religion, politics, or culture because they simply aren't developed. For instance, even when characters visit a major religious center within the first five chapters, we only see two locations, including the inside of their hotel room. Despite being in a religious hub, I learned almost nothing about the beliefs or lore, other than it being vaguely Catholic. Another example is that Clare’s organization operates in 47 provinces, yet I have no idea who rules any of them, including those Clare has visited. There's also very little information about the organization itself or the origins of the demons they fight.
Character: The characters are serviceable but not particularly likable. It doesn’t help that all the "Claymores" look very similar. There is one character I didn’t like: the boy Clare is protecting. He’s whiny and often gets Clare injured by ignoring her instructions.
If I read everything on my TBR list, I might return to this series to see if it continues to improve until the end. But with an extremely weak first eighth and a mediocre first third, I couldn’t rate the series higher than an 8, even if the ending was flawless.
The only issue I have with this manga is that the characters look quite similar, making it difficult for me to remember their names and distinguish them from one another.
The art style, however, is among the best I've seen, and it's easy to follow the action and understand what's happening in each panel, unlike some other dark fantasy manga out there. The main character reminds me of Lightning from Final Fantasy XIII—she doesn't speak much and lets her actions do the talking. The final battle was absolutely PERFECT for me! (That’s just my opinion, though.)
If you enjoy dark fantasy action adventures where character deaths are depicted without holding back, and if you appreciate a strong and lovable female protagonist, then this manga might be exactly what you're looking for.
Overall, I truly enjoyed this manga and it will always remain one of my favorites.
It's an outstanding manga in the action/fantasy genre.
This manga is set in medieval times and promotes the notion that to defeat a monster, one must become a monster. It highlights the significance of love, teamwork, and friendship. There's a good mix of drama and plot twists. Despite its initial setting, it’s a remarkably complex manga.
It's filled with action and has an incredible storyline. Though it might seem generic and basic at first glance, the art and action sequences keep you engaged until you reach a point where everything intensifies, drawing you completely in.
Out of all the manga I've read as a decade-long enthusiast, for me, Claymore stands out as number one... BY FAR.
Claymore is the embodiment of an RPG-like manga, with its eerie atmosphere and just the right amount of gore and "breasts," making it stand out like a perfectly cooked mild curry dish - not overly spiced yet flavorful enough.
1-Story 10/10
This is undoubtedly the most remarkable aspect of this manga. While the characters didn't exactly leap off the page, the story more than compensated for their shortcomings. Often, the narrative wasn't omnidirectional; instead, it leaned towards a storytelling style that might have been better suited as a novel. However, it worked splendidly as a manga too. The story followed the heroine's point of view, emphasizing her tragic past which profoundly influenced her growth and the plot's progression. Her past had a significant impact on shaping her actions driven by revenge and love. Set in a semi-medieval era, my favorite setting, I admit to some bias. The story isn't overly complex but still offers engaging plot twists and surprising events. The pacing was generally fine, though at times it felt rushed, albeit negligibly so.
2-Art 9.5/10
The artwork is stunning and does justice to the story, crafted with evident passion and imagination. Occasionally, distinguishing between characters was challenging due to their identical uniforms, blonde hair, and peculiar names and skills. Conversely, the art for the awakened beings was exceptional and unique, offering much more detail and background than other manga monsters. The landscapes were breathtaking, featuring beautiful European-style plains and hills. The reason for the 9.5 rating was some battle technique panels where the high-speed attacks made comprehension difficult without focused attention, though this rarely occurred.
3-Characters 9.5/10
The characters are great but not extraordinary. Their pasts receive considerable emphasis, which I personally appreciate but others might not. The heroine is exceptionally well-developed, while other characters are nothing short of amazing. My only gripe involves one or two antagonists portrayed as "evil" which felt unnecessary. Otherwise, the characters were well-rounded, each with unique skills rather than repetitive ones. Many characters emerge throughout the manga, each distinct with detailed backstories. They mature alongside the story, showcasing resilience and brilliance. The villain's portrayal is intriguing and best left unspoiled, ensuring you'll be both confused and captivated when discovered later in the story.
4-Enjoyment 1000000000/10!
I often tell friends that if Bones ever animated this, it would be the ultimate anime. The battles, enemies, techniques, and high-speed/phantom attacks... oh, how I dream about it! This manga shines brightly in my eyes, leaving me feeling as if I've completed a masterfully crafted RPG game. It delivers the vibe I've sought since beginning my anime journey, making it the ultimate manga for me.
5-Overall 10/10
I believe I've written extensively about this masterpiece. Just read it; it's only 156 chapters long. IT WILL BLOW YOU OUT OF PROPORTIONS.
Leave a Review