xxxHOLiC Chapter 213 Discussion

  • Thread starter Korkyros
  • Start date
  • #34
katsbad6 said:
The ending I feel was somewhat appropriate given the nature of the last few chapters.... it wasn't so much surprising as it was saddening for me. That Watanuki seems to be "alone" once again...  I don't feel that Doumeki's descendants can really replace our first Doumeki, with whom Watanuki shares blood and an eye with. I was also made sad by Watanuki's changes after Yuuko died.. he became quieter and less prone to his random outbursts which were the comedic relief throughout the story..... All in all the manga seemed to somber towards the ending, and though the people at Clamp say that Watanuki is happy in his decision, I (and I'm sure other followers of xxxHolic) am deeply saddened by it.



I can't accept that our Watanuki is going to spend the rest of his life waiting with only Doumeki's descendants for company (as Makono and the girls don't make many appearances towards the end) and the hope of meeting Yuuko again (which is clearly not going to happen based on his dream.) IT'S JUST ALL WAY TOO SAD given the silly and happy atmosphere of, basically, the rest of the manga. Also, Himawari getting a husband, even after we find out that Watanuki does share a mutual love for her... After this I was kind of hoping that, hey, maybe Watanuki might find a partner in Kohane who became really beautiful but no. The fact that we don't know what happens to Kohane, besides getting old and becoming beautiful and what-not, is similarly disappointing. Doumeki had a follow through in the form of his descendants, why not Kohane-chan!!!!!!??



I am way too sad. I would hope there would be some kind of follow up to help my fellow heavy hearted fans but it's been several years since the end of the series (I've finished it just now). Poor Watanuki, who became way emotionally distant after the death of Yuuko, and poor Doumeki and basically poor everybody who (in my eyes) didn't receive a proper sending off for the ending of what could have been a perfect series. Kohane loved Watanuki. However she agreed to marry Doumeki and have children so that the decendents would keep Watanuki company as to not make him lonely, and keep him safe, since Doumeki's bloodline is powerful. This is all because Watanuki wanted to stay in the shop forever so Kohane couldn't really be with Watanuki. :( I was also really dissapointed when they didn't get together. Doumeki should have used the egg that Yuko gave him earlier to erase his memories of Yuko-san, since it's already impossible for her to reunite with Watanuki.. I'm also curious as of what happenned to the warashi-spirit that had a crush on watanuki.
 
  • #36
So boring after Yuuko's 'dead' nothing good happen, even the ending was boring. 4/10 nothing special, I prefer the anime.
 
  • #37
The switch happened between dream 1 and dream 2 ( chapter before this one and this one ) He said he would have to strain his powers , meaning it would take time to prepare. It is also the only spot where the switch could have happened.



Anyways this ending dropped the manga's score from a 9 to a 6
 
  • #38
lol I stopped reading this after Tsubasa ended and I wanted to check up to see what the spoilers were going to be for the last chapter and wow its really that bad?? XXXHolic was good, but I liked Card Captor Sakura, X, and Tsubasa way more though and Clamp you need to finish X one day damn it.
 
  • #39



I see why people are mad about the ending and i feel the same way, maybe an open ending like just seeing him taking over the shop would have been better.

What i really missed in the ending though was what happened to Himawari... we know she got married but what about her curse? i would have loved a chapter where they again borrow some of the stuff from Tsubara, like if Watanuki used Sakuras "Gods love luck" to counter Himawaris bad luck and maybe as payment she would have to pay her happiness in the form of her memories with Watanuki since he was the first person to accept who she was.

It might also feel a bit depressing, but since he liked her the whole series I feel that her just getting married is wrong and this way it feels more like Watanuki is setting her free

Also the XXXHolic Rou (ova)ending was also more to my liking

Very good manga even with the ending 9/10

 
  • #40
You would think that they would give a series that has ran for 8 years enough time to end properly. It's not that it was a bad ending. It's just....it could have been executed better and done a better job of tying up loose ends. Hopefully we get that epilogue.

I went back and reread 212 and now that I know the ending, I get the feeling that they were hinting at it not being Doumeki anymore. Although, it might just be my imagination/wishful thinking.
 
  • #41
WTF ~ ending~ i already see again a totaly Fail ending like school rumble~

oh if they gonna give extra manga or new manga of xx holic im gonna forgive them~



WTF EGG wat about the egg? u give us mystery about the egg and u make it TAMAGO a useless egg~



or else give as new ending route~ XD
 
You must be logged in to reply here. Register an account to get started.