This is my first review, so apologies if it's not well-articulated.
I just re-read *St. Lunatic High School* about half an hour ago, and it inspired me to write a review. :)
**STORY - 7**
The plot is quite basic. A normal (human) girl ends up attending a school filled with unique creatures and demons. The story doesn't evolve much beyond that premise but remains enjoyable nonetheless. One issue I have is that it leaves me somewhat confused due to a lack of detail. I'm unsure whether the story is genuinely this simple and I'm overexpecting, or if the limited scope of two volumes restricts how much can be revealed. Some plot twists caused by seemingly trivial reasons were disappointing (though I won't spoil them for readers). Despite its imperfections, the story still feels touching and sweet. :)
*Note:* This manga is *absolutely horror-free*, despite what the description may suggest. There's nothing scary about it—rather, you'll find it more charming and cute than frightening.
**ART - 8**
The artwork is simple, clean, and adorable. It occasionally adds intricate details to backgrounds during significant scenes. None of the characters appear particularly "ugly," though they don't possess the excessive detailing seen in series like *Full Moon wo Sagashite*, where every character has elaborate hairstyles and striking features. Overall, I can't pinpoint any major flaws. However, I oddly mistook the gender of a few characters—there are three males whose appearances made me question whether they were male or female. I'm uncertain if this is just my perception or something inherent to the art style... o.O While it might not rank among the best globally, the visuals are satisfying overall.
**CHARACTERS - 7**
Most of the characters are likable. They possess straightforward personalities, making their roles in the narrative easy to discern. You likely won't despise any of them outright, though you might dislike or grow annoyed with some. One aspect I appreciate is how memorable their names are (though there aren't many named characters to begin with). For instance, the two main protagonists, Niko and Ren, are instantly recognizable from their first appearance. The characters aren't especially original; haven't we all encountered archetypes like the cheerful, strong-willed girl paired with the aloof yet talented guy whose thoughts remain mysterious?
**ENJOYMENT - 7.5 (rounded to 8)**
I found it entertaining to read. The romance element kept things engaging (after all, seeing a cute girl and a cool guy on the cover practically guarantees romance—how could they even include horror?). There's light comedy that may strike you as funny... or bizarre... or perhaps both. It's undoubtedly a fantasy, which adds to the fun of exploring its world. Action is minimal (or nonexistent, as there isn't much fighting), and adventure exists only insofar as Niko navigates her daily life at her new school. The atmosphere is pleasant, free of heavy drama, allowing for a carefree reading experience.
**OVERALL - 8**
This is a solid and satisfying manga. While it may not become an all-time favorite, it's certainly memorable enough to revisit occasionally when bored. What I love most are the main characters, Niko and Ren. Curious about what happens in this manga? Looking for a quick, uncomplicated read? Give *St. Lunatic High School* a try! (I'd recommend it to almost anyone.)
Thank you for reading my first review, and I hope you've grasped the general idea I aimed to convey about this manga. ^______^
If you're looking to kill an hour, then this manga is for you. If you're pining for an elaborate plot, character development, and an emotional conclusion... Well, St. Lunatic High School falls a little short.
Story - 6
It wasn't BAD... It had the potential to be an interesting and worthwhile series, under all the right circumstances, that is. (But I'll get to that later in the review.) The whole daytime/nighttime student concept was an intriguing idea, but Majiko! couldn't quite pull it off. However, if you're still intrigued by the thought of vampires and monsters taking classes after you go home, then I suggest you read Vampire Knight.
I'd also like to point out that the tags for this series are somewhat misleading. They describe it as "demons" and "horror," but the monster students are so cute you won't even bat an eyelash.
Art - 7
To be honest, the art wasn't very fitting for the story... But maybe that's what the mangaka intended. It's like the characters were caught between looking serious and looking all cutesy. I gave it a 7 because at least the monsters and creatures of St. Lunatic High School are pretty adorable! (Especially the penguin guy and pumpkin head!)
Character - 5
It was all too simple for me. The author tried to throw in some sort of character development, but you really can't develop anything in 2 volumes, let alone 10 chapters. The characters had their moments, but none were particularly memorable.
Enjoyment - 7
As I mentioned earlier, it wasn't BAD. It was a pleasant little read, just a way to pass an hour. The issue is, it's incredibly simple. Nothing much to it. No emotional attachment. Just read it and think nothing of it.
Popular Reviews
I just re-read *St. Lunatic High School* about half an hour ago, and it inspired me to write a review. :)
**STORY - 7**
The plot is quite basic. A normal (human) girl ends up attending a school filled with unique creatures and demons. The story doesn't evolve much beyond that premise but remains enjoyable nonetheless. One issue I have is that it leaves me somewhat confused due to a lack of detail. I'm unsure whether the story is genuinely this simple and I'm overexpecting, or if the limited scope of two volumes restricts how much can be revealed. Some plot twists caused by seemingly trivial reasons were disappointing (though I won't spoil them for readers). Despite its imperfections, the story still feels touching and sweet. :)
*Note:* This manga is *absolutely horror-free*, despite what the description may suggest. There's nothing scary about it—rather, you'll find it more charming and cute than frightening.
**ART - 8**
The artwork is simple, clean, and adorable. It occasionally adds intricate details to backgrounds during significant scenes. None of the characters appear particularly "ugly," though they don't possess the excessive detailing seen in series like *Full Moon wo Sagashite*, where every character has elaborate hairstyles and striking features. Overall, I can't pinpoint any major flaws. However, I oddly mistook the gender of a few characters—there are three males whose appearances made me question whether they were male or female. I'm uncertain if this is just my perception or something inherent to the art style... o.O While it might not rank among the best globally, the visuals are satisfying overall.
**CHARACTERS - 7**
Most of the characters are likable. They possess straightforward personalities, making their roles in the narrative easy to discern. You likely won't despise any of them outright, though you might dislike or grow annoyed with some. One aspect I appreciate is how memorable their names are (though there aren't many named characters to begin with). For instance, the two main protagonists, Niko and Ren, are instantly recognizable from their first appearance. The characters aren't especially original; haven't we all encountered archetypes like the cheerful, strong-willed girl paired with the aloof yet talented guy whose thoughts remain mysterious?
**ENJOYMENT - 7.5 (rounded to 8)**
I found it entertaining to read. The romance element kept things engaging (after all, seeing a cute girl and a cool guy on the cover practically guarantees romance—how could they even include horror?). There's light comedy that may strike you as funny... or bizarre... or perhaps both. It's undoubtedly a fantasy, which adds to the fun of exploring its world. Action is minimal (or nonexistent, as there isn't much fighting), and adventure exists only insofar as Niko navigates her daily life at her new school. The atmosphere is pleasant, free of heavy drama, allowing for a carefree reading experience.
**OVERALL - 8**
This is a solid and satisfying manga. While it may not become an all-time favorite, it's certainly memorable enough to revisit occasionally when bored. What I love most are the main characters, Niko and Ren. Curious about what happens in this manga? Looking for a quick, uncomplicated read? Give *St. Lunatic High School* a try! (I'd recommend it to almost anyone.)
Thank you for reading my first review, and I hope you've grasped the general idea I aimed to convey about this manga. ^______^
Story - 6
It wasn't BAD... It had the potential to be an interesting and worthwhile series, under all the right circumstances, that is. (But I'll get to that later in the review.) The whole daytime/nighttime student concept was an intriguing idea, but Majiko! couldn't quite pull it off. However, if you're still intrigued by the thought of vampires and monsters taking classes after you go home, then I suggest you read Vampire Knight.
I'd also like to point out that the tags for this series are somewhat misleading. They describe it as "demons" and "horror," but the monster students are so cute you won't even bat an eyelash.
Art - 7
To be honest, the art wasn't very fitting for the story... But maybe that's what the mangaka intended. It's like the characters were caught between looking serious and looking all cutesy. I gave it a 7 because at least the monsters and creatures of St. Lunatic High School are pretty adorable! (Especially the penguin guy and pumpkin head!)
Character - 5
It was all too simple for me. The author tried to throw in some sort of character development, but you really can't develop anything in 2 volumes, let alone 10 chapters. The characters had their moments, but none were particularly memorable.
Enjoyment - 7
As I mentioned earlier, it wasn't BAD. It was a pleasant little read, just a way to pass an hour. The issue is, it's incredibly simple. Nothing much to it. No emotional attachment. Just read it and think nothing of it.
Overall - 6