First of all, this manga is undeniably yaoi. It doesn't flirt with the edges of yaoi, it isn't deeply emotional or meaningful, and it certainly won't be a cherished gem in your memory. However, if you're in the market for straightforward yaoi, this one fits the bill perfectly because, sometimes, cliches do work, and Kishidou Club exemplifies this beautifully.
The story (6) provides just a hint of believable sentimentality and affection between the main characters, enough to make the narrative somewhat plausible. In yaoi manga, it's common for male characters to be sadistic jerks who view rape and slave-owning as acceptable, but the setting of a club filled with wealthy perverts adds an extra layer of plausibility here.
The art (8) is solid, though it lacks innovation or breathtaking elements.
The characters (5) are decent, which is quite an achievement in itself. The protagonists stay within the realm of reason—well, yaoi reason, at least.
Overall (7), I awarded this manga the highest rating a pure yaoi manga could earn from me, as I genuinely enjoyed it and didn't feel compelled to skim through the dull dialogue sections.
Popular Reviews
The story (6) provides just a hint of believable sentimentality and affection between the main characters, enough to make the narrative somewhat plausible. In yaoi manga, it's common for male characters to be sadistic jerks who view rape and slave-owning as acceptable, but the setting of a club filled with wealthy perverts adds an extra layer of plausibility here.
The art (8) is solid, though it lacks innovation or breathtaking elements.
The characters (5) are decent, which is quite an achievement in itself. The protagonists stay within the realm of reason—well, yaoi reason, at least.
Overall (7), I awarded this manga the highest rating a pure yaoi manga could earn from me, as I genuinely enjoyed it and didn't feel compelled to skim through the dull dialogue sections.
<p>