Blue Spring is a compilation of short stories that revolve around the theme of questioning the future. All the characters are high school delinquents, and their answers often involve crime, dissatisfaction, or even death.
As you'd expect from Taiyo Matsumoto, the presentation is unconventional in both its visuals and style. Matsumoto's art is visually appealing and effectively conveys the gritty reality he explores. The stories are comprehensible, but I believe much of their depth eludes me due to a lack of cultural context. I suspect that with some research and time, a re-reading would enable me to provide a more insightful analysis.
This is my first Matsumoto manga, and it certainly won't be my last. Taiyo Matsumoto has an incredible knack for evoking a very particular feeling and atmosphere.
These short stories aren't remarkable on their own in terms of plot or character development. They are purely tone-driven pieces. The artwork isn't particularly refined, but it exudes charm and perfectly captures the punk rock essence that permeates the book. I loved the abundance of graffiti, so much so that the bottom of the pages were filled with translator annotations. The music references (Jimi Hendrix, The Beatles, Sex Pistols) were also great—they really help establish the tone Matsumoto is aiming for. Overall, this manga serves as a perfect portrayal of teenage delinquency in 1980s and 1990s Japan, and the blues that fueled it.
I'll leave you with two quotes from Matsumoto's afterthoughts at the end of the book:
[talking about teenage delinquents] "Looking back, I realize that for these youths, whose present was already the past, the camera was a significant item. But at the time, when their actions didn't quite make sense, I was inexplicably drawn to them. They responded to reason with their fists and never questioned their excessive passions. Their honesty and commitment to being true to themselves won me over. They were my heroes."
[after discussing how those delinquents now have families and responsibilities] "No matter how passionate you were, no matter how much your blood boiled, I believe youth is a blue time. Blue - that vague blue that colors the town just before sunrise. Winter is coming."
"Blue Spring" (Aoi Haru) is an anthology comprising seven rebellious, audacious, and wild stories. These tales mirror a tumultuous, harsh, carefree, and above all, lost adolescence. The protagonists, as Matsumoto himself highlights, respond to reason with fists and never question their fervent passions. The mangaka's distinctive drawing style conveys the emotions of these characters: even without direction in their lives, they remain faithfully honest to themselves. His irregular and chaotic line work, along with the angles from which he depicts the characters, reflects this unstable reality of their adolescence—a phase the author likens to a "blue period." Matsumoto demonstrates excellent control over composition and narrative rhythm, as seen in other works like "Ping Pong." The stories unfold at breakneck speed, characterized by fragmented and skewed compositions, while the chosen images create an intriguing journey through visual sequences. His stories are so concise that it can sometimes be challenging to follow their development and immerse oneself in the narrative, a common issue in story anthologies. Nevertheless, the humor and irony with which he handles the stories capture attention and vividly represent this blue generation. Overall, I wouldn't recommend this manga to those unfamiliar with Matsumoto's work; it's best suited for readers already acquainted with and captivated by his unique style.
This work is Matsumoto's sandbox, and it's your choice whether you wish to engage with it or not. His style completely disregards mainstream boundaries; linear storytelling is replaced by the juxtaposition of almost non-cohesive panels. The result of this approach is that instead of being a passive observer, you feel as though you're inside the characters' minds.
There are no clear moral lessons here; it's more akin to sheer realism. You might even term it the conveyance of youthful boredom. As such, it doesn't aim for excitement, but the mood is masterfully crafted to maintain your interest. A positive aspect is the implementation of surreal slapstick, which Matsumoto doesn't even attempt to introduce subtly.
Character development is entirely discarded; these characters simply live their empty and purposeless lives. No justification is given for their actions, nor are there any indications of a brighter future. You'll either detest their dull existence or find it comically realistic.
It may feel quite heavy, particularly due to the abundance of Japanese pop-cultural references, the lack of vibrancy, the apparent incoherence shown through erratic presentation, and simply because Matsumoto refuses to make it easily digestible. I'm also certain that his artwork won't appeal to many, especially since it's inconsistent, though it does shine in some places.
Aoi Haru is a dichotomic creation; it's perfect in its imperfection. It's certainly not a masterpiece in every sense of the word, but for its bold attempt to address such a risky theme and present it in such an experimental manner, one could consider it a masterpiece by its own standards.
It's peculiar that no one has taken the time to review this exceptional manga. Then again, it's not entirely surprising considering its lack of promotion. Nevertheless, this manga is a hidden gem in the world of manga.
STORY: This story is actually a collection of various tales, all crafted by Taiyo Matsumoto, who is best known for his work "Black and White." It revolves around a group of students experiencing a Blue Spring, a dreary and uneventful spring. These kids exist on the fringes of society, primarily consisting of punks and thugs, and it delves into their issues, many of which are quite dark and unsettling.
That being said, while some of the stories are absolutely breathtaking (If You're Happy and You Know It Clap Your Hands, Mahjong Summer), others range from mediocre (Revolver: 1-3) to downright poor (Peace). These narratives are dark and, for the most part, thought-provoking, much like his previous work B&W, but some are merely fillers that won't leave a lasting impression. This is why I had to give it a 5 in this category, although I consider some individual stories as 9s or 10s.
ART: Similar to Taiyo Matsumoto's other works, the art here is somewhat unconventional. It doesn't adhere to the standard manga-style seen in many Shounen Jump publications; instead, it's more cartoonish and slightly less realistic. Some people might be put off by it, and it took me some time to get accustomed to it, but others will embrace it from the start and adore it until the end.
CHARACTER: As with many manga compilations, the characters can be difficult to connect with because they only appear in one story or chapter. Another issue with the characters is what I mentioned earlier; they are tough to relate to since they are mostly punks and thugs. None of them are truly driven by their own desires and generally belong to a group, following the demands and needs of the groups. Essentially, they are followers.
The only positive aspect is that some of the other characters in the manga, for the most part minor ones, seem to have more impact on the story than the main characters. Especially in the "If You're Happy and You Know It..." story. These characters are, for the most part, not followers like the main characters and thus much more likable. They truly make it worth reading.
ENJOYMENT: For the most part, I enjoyed this manga. As I mentioned before, there were a few stories that I didn't care for, but then again, there were some that I absolutely loved and frequently reread. A couple have even inspired the way I write my own stories. Overall, I genuinely enjoyed it.
OVERALL: As stated earlier, there are a few subpar stories, the art might not appeal to everyone, and some of the characters are rather weak. BUT (And this is a significant but.) some of the stories are simply masterpieces, as one would expect from a master storyteller like Taiyo Matsumoto. It's just a shame that he couldn't maintain the quality throughout.
Despite all its flaws, the positives outweigh the negatives, and it is certainly worth checking out, especially if you enjoyed Black and White. As mentioned before, it is one of the lesser-known great mangas. Definitely worth the read.
My eyes drift from the business card, to the beige envelope, then up to this woman's perfectly contoured face. She's far from the weirdest person I've seen in this homey little cafe. I'm a waitress — we practically specialize in dealing with crazies. It's just that usually, I'm an innocent bystander of that crazy; like, a man will come in without a shirt on, and I'll have to tell him that we can't serve him. The man would have been shirtless anyway. I was just the one who had to deal with it.
Popular Reviews
As you'd expect from Taiyo Matsumoto, the presentation is unconventional in both its visuals and style. Matsumoto's art is visually appealing and effectively conveys the gritty reality he explores. The stories are comprehensible, but I believe much of their depth eludes me due to a lack of cultural context. I suspect that with some research and time, a re-reading would enable me to provide a more insightful analysis.
These short stories aren't remarkable on their own in terms of plot or character development. They are purely tone-driven pieces. The artwork isn't particularly refined, but it exudes charm and perfectly captures the punk rock essence that permeates the book. I loved the abundance of graffiti, so much so that the bottom of the pages were filled with translator annotations. The music references (Jimi Hendrix, The Beatles, Sex Pistols) were also great—they really help establish the tone Matsumoto is aiming for. Overall, this manga serves as a perfect portrayal of teenage delinquency in 1980s and 1990s Japan, and the blues that fueled it.
I'll leave you with two quotes from Matsumoto's afterthoughts at the end of the book:
[talking about teenage delinquents] "Looking back, I realize that for these youths, whose present was already the past, the camera was a significant item. But at the time, when their actions didn't quite make sense, I was inexplicably drawn to them. They responded to reason with their fists and never questioned their excessive passions. Their honesty and commitment to being true to themselves won me over. They were my heroes."
[after discussing how those delinquents now have families and responsibilities] "No matter how passionate you were, no matter how much your blood boiled, I believe youth is a blue time. Blue - that vague blue that colors the town just before sunrise. Winter is coming."
<p>
There are no clear moral lessons here; it's more akin to sheer realism. You might even term it the conveyance of youthful boredom. As such, it doesn't aim for excitement, but the mood is masterfully crafted to maintain your interest. A positive aspect is the implementation of surreal slapstick, which Matsumoto doesn't even attempt to introduce subtly.
Character development is entirely discarded; these characters simply live their empty and purposeless lives. No justification is given for their actions, nor are there any indications of a brighter future. You'll either detest their dull existence or find it comically realistic.
It may feel quite heavy, particularly due to the abundance of Japanese pop-cultural references, the lack of vibrancy, the apparent incoherence shown through erratic presentation, and simply because Matsumoto refuses to make it easily digestible. I'm also certain that his artwork won't appeal to many, especially since it's inconsistent, though it does shine in some places.
Aoi Haru is a dichotomic creation; it's perfect in its imperfection. It's certainly not a masterpiece in every sense of the word, but for its bold attempt to address such a risky theme and present it in such an experimental manner, one could consider it a masterpiece by its own standards.
<p>
STORY: This story is actually a collection of various tales, all crafted by Taiyo Matsumoto, who is best known for his work "Black and White." It revolves around a group of students experiencing a Blue Spring, a dreary and uneventful spring. These kids exist on the fringes of society, primarily consisting of punks and thugs, and it delves into their issues, many of which are quite dark and unsettling.
That being said, while some of the stories are absolutely breathtaking (If You're Happy and You Know It Clap Your Hands, Mahjong Summer), others range from mediocre (Revolver: 1-3) to downright poor (Peace). These narratives are dark and, for the most part, thought-provoking, much like his previous work B&W, but some are merely fillers that won't leave a lasting impression. This is why I had to give it a 5 in this category, although I consider some individual stories as 9s or 10s.
ART: Similar to Taiyo Matsumoto's other works, the art here is somewhat unconventional. It doesn't adhere to the standard manga-style seen in many Shounen Jump publications; instead, it's more cartoonish and slightly less realistic. Some people might be put off by it, and it took me some time to get accustomed to it, but others will embrace it from the start and adore it until the end.
CHARACTER: As with many manga compilations, the characters can be difficult to connect with because they only appear in one story or chapter. Another issue with the characters is what I mentioned earlier; they are tough to relate to since they are mostly punks and thugs. None of them are truly driven by their own desires and generally belong to a group, following the demands and needs of the groups. Essentially, they are followers.
The only positive aspect is that some of the other characters in the manga, for the most part minor ones, seem to have more impact on the story than the main characters. Especially in the "If You're Happy and You Know It..." story. These characters are, for the most part, not followers like the main characters and thus much more likable. They truly make it worth reading.
ENJOYMENT: For the most part, I enjoyed this manga. As I mentioned before, there were a few stories that I didn't care for, but then again, there were some that I absolutely loved and frequently reread. A couple have even inspired the way I write my own stories. Overall, I genuinely enjoyed it.
OVERALL: As stated earlier, there are a few subpar stories, the art might not appeal to everyone, and some of the characters are rather weak. BUT (And this is a significant but.) some of the stories are simply masterpieces, as one would expect from a master storyteller like Taiyo Matsumoto. It's just a shame that he couldn't maintain the quality throughout.
Despite all its flaws, the positives outweigh the negatives, and it is certainly worth checking out, especially if you enjoyed Black and White. As mentioned before, it is one of the lesser-known great mangas. Definitely worth the read.