Okay. I really enjoyed the initial chapters, which introduced us to the characters and had a bit of a "monster of the week" format, though I understand many people disagree.
The best aspect of the manga is undoubtedly the art, which is phenomenal. Personally, I'm a big fan of Clamp's style, though I know it can be quite divisive. If you're not into their style, you might not share my enthusiasm.
The characters are one of the manga's strong points, especially the main character, Watanuke. His development throughout the series is truly enjoyable to follow. Other characters, such as his "boss" Yuko and his friend Doumeki, are also well-crafted.
The story can sometimes feel disjointed and confusing. Additionally, it can get perplexing if you haven't read Tsubasa Chronicle, which runs parallel to xxxHolic.
Overall, I had a great time binge-reading this over the past three days. It's an intriguing manga, although the confusion induced by the story can often detract from the experience.
xxxHOLiC is an incredible series that crosses over with Tsubasa later in the manga and during the second and third OVA seasons of the anime. Personally, I love xxxHOLiC for its various arcs and escapades. However, the art and animation leave something to be desired; characters often look rigid, and the animation quality can feel somewhat low-budget.
CLAMP has impressed me once again with this mystical series. The openings, endings, background music, and plot are all fascinating and well-crafted.
Overall, it's a series you might thoroughly enjoy watching. Rating: 10 (Masterpiece)
This series is primarily a serious yet somewhat humorous manga. Although I usually prefer stories filled with action or mystery, I still find myself thoroughly engrossed in this series. I recommend this book to anyone who has read or is currently reading Tsubasa. Just keep in mind, "there is no coincidence, only inevitability."
When I think about writing reviews for the works I've read or watched, it's way easier to talk about the ones that are just "Oh, this was really joyful" or "Such good art." Because when we talk about the one that is THE ONE for us, you might come off as a crazy fangirl trying to say more than 'omg sahjashdjkah'. XD
Let's try this! And I'm gonna start with: READ THIS, because not even in 1000 years will you forget or regret it.
About the story:
Like any other popular CLAMP 'classic' series, the plot is full of deep thoughts, meanings, and things that resonate with your personal life. From the very beginning, they show you what kind of story this is going to be—full of funny moments, love, and mystery. Even if this isn't the last of the Holic mangas, they put a good ending on it. They created a point where the story can continue without becoming boring or repetitive. This is the kind of manga that, years after you finish it, looking at the cover will make you nostalgic and want to relive those good times by reading it all over again.
The only problem I see in the plot is regarding the points where the story connects with Tsubasa, for example. If you haven't read Tsubasa, you might get lost, but reading Holic till the end, you can still follow the story. They don't explain the connections from the start, and this is the only point where you might feel lost. The other parts of the Holic world, lines that didn't get tied up in the first series, are explained later, and since there is a new series ongoing, it's too early to say, "But I didn't get that yet!"
About the art and characters:
The art may not have shining eyes, well-structured bodies, or flattering lines, nor realistic art. Yet, it matches so perfectly with the atmosphere the story gives that it almost feels surreal. Something important about the art: it is simple yet detailed in clothing and covers, requiring you to spend a long time contemplating everything. It complements the mysterious feel that the story gives you.
About the characters:
When we talk about the characters, we NEED to talk about the bonds between Yuuko and Watanuki, and between Watanuki and Doumeki. These relationships are crucial for the story development and the plot itself because, let's face it, xxxHolic is about bonds. Even the characters that in any other story would be the "good-looking but useless" type here have their special roles in the plot, none of them wasted.
___________________________
Well, to finish this short review, I'll just complement what I said before: Read this story, not because it's by CLAMP, not because it has a good score.
Read it because it's good. This funny and amusing story explains to you the importance of every single thing that happens in life, the people we meet, and teaches you the importance of making choices and how it will always bring something to your life, whether good or bad.
Although the story intersects with Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles, it is not necessary to read Tsubasa beforehand to understand xxxHOLiC. However, there may be some moments of slight confusion.
I enjoyed this manga immensely, and it remains one of my favorite series. My love for this manga primarily stems from its characters, especially Watanuki, whose personality I greatly admire, with Yuko being a close second. The manga revolves around the interactions between Watanuki and those in his personal life, as well as his interactions with customers. Both aspects significantly contribute to the development of his character and, to a slightly lesser extent, the other characters. This dual focus makes me appreciate all the characters, but Watanuki stands out the most. Given the shop's theme, new characters are smoothly integrated without issue, though older characters often fade from the spotlight for long periods or permanently. This dynamic also enriches the story and does not diminish my affection for any character. However, dialogues, particularly between Yuko and Watanuki, can be difficult to follow and confusing at times. I believe the manga sometimes gets wrapped up in its mysterious themes, making it hard to follow, but this did not hinder my understanding of the story’s events and likely won't affect others either.
xxxHOLiC excels at introducing and teaching readers about Japanese folklore, as these myths play a crucial role in advancing the plot. This type of storytelling, similar to Mushishi, is something I greatly enjoy and has influenced my opinion of the story. Personally, while the art may lack detail in some areas and appear plain, I think it suits the story and the characters well.
Overall, this was a wonderful story for me, and I would be thrilled to discover another story of a similar nature. Overall, I would rate this a 9/10, but my deep affection for this manga compels me to give it an extra point for a perfect 10/10 score.
xxxHOLiC remains one of my all-time favorites. While I hesitate to give it a perfect score, I believe it deserves the highest possible rating.
Story:
The majority of xxxHOLiC's chapters are standalone stories that contribute significantly to character development and overall plot understanding. Though this structure can sometimes detract from the main narrative, it generally enhances the story. Even seemingly insignificant events help flesh out the characters in remarkable ways. Occasionally, these short stories may feel like they drag the plot, but the pacing improves in later chapters, preventing the story from becoming too monotonous (though most of the short stories are quite engaging).
It’s worth noting that segments involving Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles (TRC) feel out of place and forced. These elements shouldn’t have been included in the manga or should have been better integrated into the storyline.
Note: xxxHOLiC shares events and characters with other CLAMP works, notably Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles. However, reading these other works isn't necessary to understand xxxHOLiC. They do provide a richer context for the universe, so I recommend them if you want a deeper understanding.
Characters:
xxxHOLiC primarily focuses on four main characters, each developing gradually throughout the series. Initially one-dimensional, they grow and their relationships become more complex. By the end, no character is left underdeveloped.
However, there is one notable issue. A secondary character who becomes important later in the series is introduced but then quickly phased out. This unresolved aspect feels like a missed opportunity and an unaddressed flaw in the narrative.
Art:
The art in xxxHOLiC is unconventional yet stunning. The panel work is excellent, creating a balanced visual experience. While some scenes might look odd due to the unique character designs, it quickly becomes visually pleasing. Unlike CLAMP’s earlier works with exaggerated proportions, xxxHOLiC shows significant artistic improvement.
xxxHOLiC is often considered one of CLAMP’s masterpieces, and I wholeheartedly agree. It was a memorable journey and a visual treat. Despite its length, it’s definitely worth reading.
There are very few mangas that I would give a perfect 10 out of 10, but if any manga deserves it, xxxHOLiC surpasses even that. If it were possible, I'd give it a 100 out of 10. It's that delightful and amazing.
xxxHOLiC is a supernatural story about a young teenager named Watanuki Kimihiro who can see spirits and unwittingly attracts them due to his bloodline. One day, while fleeing from these spirits, he stumbles upon a mysterious building where the spirits vanish. Inside, he meets Yuuko Ichihara, a "witch" who can grant wishes. Watanuki wishes to be free from the troublesome spirits, but in return, he must work at Yuuko’s shop—an unusual job that leads him to learn more about the supernatural world, other dimensions, and characters from another universe: Sakura and Syaoran.
In brief, xxxHOLiC is not your typical manga. Its exquisite art and subtle storytelling make it one of CLAMP’s finest works. The series begins with a series of "events" narrated by Yuuko, each revealing something poignant about human nature. Gradually, it delves into Watanuki’s mysteries and his significance. With excellent character depth and development, the chapters flow smoothly from one event to another. Initially slow, this pacing allows for rich character development, showing their true colors. Eventually, crossovers with its sister manga, Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles, become central around chapter 100. The relationship between Yuuko, with her exhilarating beauty and omnipotent nature, and young "apprentice" Watanuki is delightful. A small main cast and minor cast allow for focused character development with respect and care, rather than superficial attempts to cover a large ensemble. The best aspect of xxxHOLiC is its appeal to those who enjoy thought-provoking, philosophical manga that remains visceral and accessible, maintaining maturity and coherence that draws readers in.
Specifically, the most wonderful aspect of this series lies in its balance and characters. Roughly one-third of the manga focuses on episodic stories, each ending with a theme or saying that may or may not resonate deeply with the reader. This part is filled with comedy—from Watanuki’s exaggerated emotions to Yuuko’s refined tastes and love for food. Here, we see the most character development. Watanuki evolves from a normal, spastic teenager into a more serious, refined, and curious man. Yuuko also changes, albeit more subtly. As Watanuki understands himself better, so do those around him, making xxxHOLiC more of a character-driven, introspective story compared to its sister series, TRC, which is more plot-driven.
The remaining two-thirds of the manga delve into crossovers with TRC, which can be tragic because to fully understand what’s happening, you’ll need to read TRC or have a good grasp of its events. This is one of the greatest weaknesses of xxxHOLiC, deterring many from reading it. However, don’t let this deter you. If you prefer to read TRC, which has a long and convoluted plot, that’s fine, but you can also get general information from sources like Wikipedia. Around this time, a dramatic shift in tone occurs—a bold move that makes the manga fantastic. xxxHOLiC starts as a comedy but ends with a darker atmosphere. Here, Watanuki’s character development truly shines, showing that just as there is a gain for something, there is also a price. Happiness is relative, and what brings joy to one person may bring misfortune to another. xxxHOLiC explores these themes excellently, providing realistic yet hopeful answers.
Lastly, xxxHOLiC excels at bringing its setting and characters to life. No character feels flat, and though some additional development could have been added, each character is unique. Most importantly, the relationships between the characters are amazing. Each relationship shapes the character differently, and as Yuuko said, these ties make us wish and make us human.
I might be rambling about how amazing xxxHOLiC really is, but it changed my entire perspective and philosophy on life, something few things can achieve. A delight that anyone should definitely read, xxxHOLiC will likely hook you at first sight.
A few years ago, I embarked on a project to re-read every CLAMP manga and rank them on a scale of 1 to 10 across three categories. xxxHOLiC stood out with a near-perfect score of 29/30. Below is my review from that time. In short, this is the only CLAMP manga I wholeheartedly recommend even to those who aren't particularly into CLAMP's usual style or manga in general—it's just that good!
Art: 10/10
While some people endlessly complain about the exaggerated proportions, I genuinely believe this is some of CLAMP's best work. The elongated figures contribute to a surreal atmosphere, which is both somber and contemplative. Nekoi was the lead artist, but Mokona drew the female characters, combining their skills to create lush, detailed scenes alongside pared-down moments of melancholic emptiness (enhanced by the lack of screentones). This combination is highly effective and visually delightful. The color illustrations are always eye-catching as well. Additionally, Nekoi's ability to convey a range of emotions through Doumeki's micro-expressions is an art form in itself, and it adds a humorous touch.
Writing: 10/10
Note that my writing score reflects someone who has read Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle multiple times, so it might be challenging for me to gauge how confusing it would be for someone unfamiliar with that series. However, while reading both concurrently offers the best experience, it's not necessary. xxxHOLiC is a slow-paced supernatural story that delves deeply into themes of alienation, grief, loss, and self-worth. The characters' struggles and development together are moving and often bittersweet. How much you enjoy the series' progression may depend on your comfort with somewhat sad endings, but if you appreciate such narratives, you'll love it.
Fun Factor: 9/10
This category accounts for elements that cater to my personal taste, usually trashy humor, great outfits, and Yaoi Factor. xxxHOLiC is excellent and lacks any unintentional humor, but it excels in the other areas. Yuuko's wardrobe is extensive, featuring intricately detailed outfits that become plot points when repeated. She exudes glamour, and Watanuki inherits this trait after the timeskip, though he can't quite match her level. The Yaoi Factor is high for those who enjoy intense quasi-romantic devotion that remains subtextual throughout. Since it's all very subtle, it doesn't interfere—those who dislike such elements can simply choose not to interpret it that way. My one-sentence endorsement: "Doumeki makes me want to punch a hole in drywall with my head (in a positive way)."
Congratulations if you made it through all of that. Don't waste any more time reading reviews—go read xxxHOLiC immediately.
The story revolves around Kimihiro Watanuki, a high school student who can see spirits. One day, he stumbles upon an unusual shop where he meets Yuko Ichihara, a witch and the other main character.
To fulfill his wish of no longer seeing spirits, Yuko pretends to be paid for her services. Thus, Watanuki starts working part-time at her shop, which is where the fun begins!
The concept of a wish-fulfilling shop is quite appealing. Each wish granted by Yuko leads Watanuki into a small adventure that often involves other characters, a few spirits, and plenty of humor! It's a fantastic blend of fantasy, comedy, and horror.
The art style is CLAMP's new look, characterized by characters with elongated, slender bodies.
Watanuki has a quirky personality, capable of shifting from incredibly happy (especially when talking to the girl he likes) to gloomy and depressed in an instant. This trait adds a lot of humor to the story!
Yuko also has a lively personality; she's skilled at her job but frequently drinks and laughs. She's endearing, and while Watanuki sometimes gets angry with her, it leads to some hilarious moments.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading xxxHolic, especially since I'm also following Tsubasa. The stories intertwine, sharing characters who occasionally communicate. Reading both series feels like getting twice the content, which I love because I adore both comics!
While it might come down to personal taste, if you enjoy CLAMP's work, I highly recommend giving xxxHolic a read.
All their stories seem to follow the same pattern: bland, childish, and monotonous. Perfect for a young child, but dreadfully dull for an adult. As I've aged, my appreciation for their works has steadily declined. While xxxHolic offers a slightly more intriguing atmosphere, the male characters lack any semblance of maturity, and the enigmatic female character is downright irritating.
Like other CLAMP titles, you're left in the dark about the plot and the true nature of the characters—why they do what they do remains a mystery. Initially, this storytelling style might seem mysterious, but by the end of the series, it becomes clear that the authors were just as confused about their own story.
Perhaps someone might enjoy the quirkiness and oddity of the story, but I found the elongated art style off-putting. The peculiar relationship between the indecisive protagonist and his terse companion—who seems to despise him yet continually saves him—feels forced and unrealistic. The relationships in general appear strained and unnatural, suggesting that the authors may not have much experience with real-life relationships, leading to poor writing and portrayal.
Of all the CLAMP works I've endured, this one was possibly the least painful, but looking back, it’s simply not worth the time spent reading or watching.
Popular Reviews
Okay. I really enjoyed the initial chapters, which introduced us to the characters and had a bit of a "monster of the week" format, though I understand many people disagree.
The best aspect of the manga is undoubtedly the art, which is phenomenal. Personally, I'm a big fan of Clamp's style, though I know it can be quite divisive. If you're not into their style, you might not share my enthusiasm.
The characters are one of the manga's strong points, especially the main character, Watanuke. His development throughout the series is truly enjoyable to follow. Other characters, such as his "boss" Yuko and his friend Doumeki, are also well-crafted.
The story can sometimes feel disjointed and confusing. Additionally, it can get perplexing if you haven't read Tsubasa Chronicle, which runs parallel to xxxHolic.
Overall, I had a great time binge-reading this over the past three days. It's an intriguing manga, although the confusion induced by the story can often detract from the experience.
xxxHOLiC is an incredible series that crosses over with Tsubasa later in the manga and during the second and third OVA seasons of the anime. Personally, I love xxxHOLiC for its various arcs and escapades. However, the art and animation leave something to be desired; characters often look rigid, and the animation quality can feel somewhat low-budget.
CLAMP has impressed me once again with this mystical series. The openings, endings, background music, and plot are all fascinating and well-crafted.
Overall, it's a series you might thoroughly enjoy watching. Rating: 10 (Masterpiece)
- Delaney
This series is primarily a serious yet somewhat humorous manga. Although I usually prefer stories filled with action or mystery, I still find myself thoroughly engrossed in this series. I recommend this book to anyone who has read or is currently reading Tsubasa. Just keep in mind, "there is no coincidence, only inevitability."
I enjoyed this manga immensely, and it remains one of my favorite series. My love for this manga primarily stems from its characters, especially Watanuki, whose personality I greatly admire, with Yuko being a close second. The manga revolves around the interactions between Watanuki and those in his personal life, as well as his interactions with customers. Both aspects significantly contribute to the development of his character and, to a slightly lesser extent, the other characters. This dual focus makes me appreciate all the characters, but Watanuki stands out the most. Given the shop's theme, new characters are smoothly integrated without issue, though older characters often fade from the spotlight for long periods or permanently. This dynamic also enriches the story and does not diminish my affection for any character. However, dialogues, particularly between Yuko and Watanuki, can be difficult to follow and confusing at times. I believe the manga sometimes gets wrapped up in its mysterious themes, making it hard to follow, but this did not hinder my understanding of the story’s events and likely won't affect others either.
xxxHOLiC excels at introducing and teaching readers about Japanese folklore, as these myths play a crucial role in advancing the plot. This type of storytelling, similar to Mushishi, is something I greatly enjoy and has influenced my opinion of the story. Personally, while the art may lack detail in some areas and appear plain, I think it suits the story and the characters well.
Overall, this was a wonderful story for me, and I would be thrilled to discover another story of a similar nature. Overall, I would rate this a 9/10, but my deep affection for this manga compels me to give it an extra point for a perfect 10/10 score.
xxxHOLiC remains one of my all-time favorites. While I hesitate to give it a perfect score, I believe it deserves the highest possible rating.
Story:
The majority of xxxHOLiC's chapters are standalone stories that contribute significantly to character development and overall plot understanding. Though this structure can sometimes detract from the main narrative, it generally enhances the story. Even seemingly insignificant events help flesh out the characters in remarkable ways. Occasionally, these short stories may feel like they drag the plot, but the pacing improves in later chapters, preventing the story from becoming too monotonous (though most of the short stories are quite engaging).
It’s worth noting that segments involving Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles (TRC) feel out of place and forced. These elements shouldn’t have been included in the manga or should have been better integrated into the storyline.
Note: xxxHOLiC shares events and characters with other CLAMP works, notably Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles. However, reading these other works isn't necessary to understand xxxHOLiC. They do provide a richer context for the universe, so I recommend them if you want a deeper understanding.
Characters:
xxxHOLiC primarily focuses on four main characters, each developing gradually throughout the series. Initially one-dimensional, they grow and their relationships become more complex. By the end, no character is left underdeveloped.
However, there is one notable issue. A secondary character who becomes important later in the series is introduced but then quickly phased out. This unresolved aspect feels like a missed opportunity and an unaddressed flaw in the narrative.
Art:
The art in xxxHOLiC is unconventional yet stunning. The panel work is excellent, creating a balanced visual experience. While some scenes might look odd due to the unique character designs, it quickly becomes visually pleasing. Unlike CLAMP’s earlier works with exaggerated proportions, xxxHOLiC shows significant artistic improvement.
xxxHOLiC is often considered one of CLAMP’s masterpieces, and I wholeheartedly agree. It was a memorable journey and a visual treat. Despite its length, it’s definitely worth reading.
There are very few mangas that I would give a perfect 10 out of 10, but if any manga deserves it, xxxHOLiC surpasses even that. If it were possible, I'd give it a 100 out of 10. It's that delightful and amazing.
xxxHOLiC is a supernatural story about a young teenager named Watanuki Kimihiro who can see spirits and unwittingly attracts them due to his bloodline. One day, while fleeing from these spirits, he stumbles upon a mysterious building where the spirits vanish. Inside, he meets Yuuko Ichihara, a "witch" who can grant wishes. Watanuki wishes to be free from the troublesome spirits, but in return, he must work at Yuuko’s shop—an unusual job that leads him to learn more about the supernatural world, other dimensions, and characters from another universe: Sakura and Syaoran.
In brief, xxxHOLiC is not your typical manga. Its exquisite art and subtle storytelling make it one of CLAMP’s finest works. The series begins with a series of "events" narrated by Yuuko, each revealing something poignant about human nature. Gradually, it delves into Watanuki’s mysteries and his significance. With excellent character depth and development, the chapters flow smoothly from one event to another. Initially slow, this pacing allows for rich character development, showing their true colors. Eventually, crossovers with its sister manga, Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles, become central around chapter 100. The relationship between Yuuko, with her exhilarating beauty and omnipotent nature, and young "apprentice" Watanuki is delightful. A small main cast and minor cast allow for focused character development with respect and care, rather than superficial attempts to cover a large ensemble. The best aspect of xxxHOLiC is its appeal to those who enjoy thought-provoking, philosophical manga that remains visceral and accessible, maintaining maturity and coherence that draws readers in.
Specifically, the most wonderful aspect of this series lies in its balance and characters. Roughly one-third of the manga focuses on episodic stories, each ending with a theme or saying that may or may not resonate deeply with the reader. This part is filled with comedy—from Watanuki’s exaggerated emotions to Yuuko’s refined tastes and love for food. Here, we see the most character development. Watanuki evolves from a normal, spastic teenager into a more serious, refined, and curious man. Yuuko also changes, albeit more subtly. As Watanuki understands himself better, so do those around him, making xxxHOLiC more of a character-driven, introspective story compared to its sister series, TRC, which is more plot-driven.
The remaining two-thirds of the manga delve into crossovers with TRC, which can be tragic because to fully understand what’s happening, you’ll need to read TRC or have a good grasp of its events. This is one of the greatest weaknesses of xxxHOLiC, deterring many from reading it. However, don’t let this deter you. If you prefer to read TRC, which has a long and convoluted plot, that’s fine, but you can also get general information from sources like Wikipedia. Around this time, a dramatic shift in tone occurs—a bold move that makes the manga fantastic. xxxHOLiC starts as a comedy but ends with a darker atmosphere. Here, Watanuki’s character development truly shines, showing that just as there is a gain for something, there is also a price. Happiness is relative, and what brings joy to one person may bring misfortune to another. xxxHOLiC explores these themes excellently, providing realistic yet hopeful answers.
Lastly, xxxHOLiC excels at bringing its setting and characters to life. No character feels flat, and though some additional development could have been added, each character is unique. Most importantly, the relationships between the characters are amazing. Each relationship shapes the character differently, and as Yuuko said, these ties make us wish and make us human.
I might be rambling about how amazing xxxHOLiC really is, but it changed my entire perspective and philosophy on life, something few things can achieve. A delight that anyone should definitely read, xxxHOLiC will likely hook you at first sight.
A few years ago, I embarked on a project to re-read every CLAMP manga and rank them on a scale of 1 to 10 across three categories. xxxHOLiC stood out with a near-perfect score of 29/30. Below is my review from that time. In short, this is the only CLAMP manga I wholeheartedly recommend even to those who aren't particularly into CLAMP's usual style or manga in general—it's just that good!
Art: 10/10
While some people endlessly complain about the exaggerated proportions, I genuinely believe this is some of CLAMP's best work. The elongated figures contribute to a surreal atmosphere, which is both somber and contemplative. Nekoi was the lead artist, but Mokona drew the female characters, combining their skills to create lush, detailed scenes alongside pared-down moments of melancholic emptiness (enhanced by the lack of screentones). This combination is highly effective and visually delightful. The color illustrations are always eye-catching as well. Additionally, Nekoi's ability to convey a range of emotions through Doumeki's micro-expressions is an art form in itself, and it adds a humorous touch.
Writing: 10/10
Note that my writing score reflects someone who has read Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle multiple times, so it might be challenging for me to gauge how confusing it would be for someone unfamiliar with that series. However, while reading both concurrently offers the best experience, it's not necessary. xxxHOLiC is a slow-paced supernatural story that delves deeply into themes of alienation, grief, loss, and self-worth. The characters' struggles and development together are moving and often bittersweet. How much you enjoy the series' progression may depend on your comfort with somewhat sad endings, but if you appreciate such narratives, you'll love it.
Fun Factor: 9/10
This category accounts for elements that cater to my personal taste, usually trashy humor, great outfits, and Yaoi Factor. xxxHOLiC is excellent and lacks any unintentional humor, but it excels in the other areas. Yuuko's wardrobe is extensive, featuring intricately detailed outfits that become plot points when repeated. She exudes glamour, and Watanuki inherits this trait after the timeskip, though he can't quite match her level. The Yaoi Factor is high for those who enjoy intense quasi-romantic devotion that remains subtextual throughout. Since it's all very subtle, it doesn't interfere—those who dislike such elements can simply choose not to interpret it that way. My one-sentence endorsement: "Doumeki makes me want to punch a hole in drywall with my head (in a positive way)."
Congratulations if you made it through all of that. Don't waste any more time reading reviews—go read xxxHOLiC immediately.
The story revolves around Kimihiro Watanuki, a high school student who can see spirits. One day, he stumbles upon an unusual shop where he meets Yuko Ichihara, a witch and the other main character.
To fulfill his wish of no longer seeing spirits, Yuko pretends to be paid for her services. Thus, Watanuki starts working part-time at her shop, which is where the fun begins!
The concept of a wish-fulfilling shop is quite appealing. Each wish granted by Yuko leads Watanuki into a small adventure that often involves other characters, a few spirits, and plenty of humor! It's a fantastic blend of fantasy, comedy, and horror.
The art style is CLAMP's new look, characterized by characters with elongated, slender bodies.
Watanuki has a quirky personality, capable of shifting from incredibly happy (especially when talking to the girl he likes) to gloomy and depressed in an instant. This trait adds a lot of humor to the story!
Yuko also has a lively personality; she's skilled at her job but frequently drinks and laughs. She's endearing, and while Watanuki sometimes gets angry with her, it leads to some hilarious moments.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading xxxHolic, especially since I'm also following Tsubasa. The stories intertwine, sharing characters who occasionally communicate. Reading both series feels like getting twice the content, which I love because I adore both comics!
While it might come down to personal taste, if you enjoy CLAMP's work, I highly recommend giving xxxHolic a read.
I grow increasingly weary of CLAMP's work.
All their stories seem to follow the same pattern: bland, childish, and monotonous. Perfect for a young child, but dreadfully dull for an adult. As I've aged, my appreciation for their works has steadily declined. While xxxHolic offers a slightly more intriguing atmosphere, the male characters lack any semblance of maturity, and the enigmatic female character is downright irritating.
Like other CLAMP titles, you're left in the dark about the plot and the true nature of the characters—why they do what they do remains a mystery. Initially, this storytelling style might seem mysterious, but by the end of the series, it becomes clear that the authors were just as confused about their own story.
Perhaps someone might enjoy the quirkiness and oddity of the story, but I found the elongated art style off-putting. The peculiar relationship between the indecisive protagonist and his terse companion—who seems to despise him yet continually saves him—feels forced and unrealistic. The relationships in general appear strained and unnatural, suggesting that the authors may not have much experience with real-life relationships, leading to poor writing and portrayal.
Of all the CLAMP works I've endured, this one was possibly the least painful, but looking back, it’s simply not worth the time spent reading or watching.
Leave a Review