Bokura no Kiseki

While I was reading this manga I was very confused. New characters kept appearing and I before I could remember the old ones so a lot of times I mixed them up. Plot is also confusing and most of the time it felt like I skipped a page or few (even a whole chapter) because story moved in new direction without any warning.
Initial plot was promising and it would have been great with much better character introduction and more coherent story telling method.

like i said, i've been fooled!
not in a bad way though. this manga is so unpredicted even i cannot think anything

all my hypothesis are falling apart. well, damn. esp the recent chapters.

not i hate that though. i love manga which cannot be predicted.
the tag Mystery is so suitable to this manga.

To be honest, I can't find the words to describe this manga. I just really, REALLY like it! Bokura no Kiseki always keeps my interest and has never let me down. When the characters find out new things about their past, it makes me super excited!

It's intriguing and unique. I'm really glad that I can read this!

Maybe it's because I believe that characters are crucial to a story, but I couldn't get attached to this. I literally do not care about any of these students, and since there are so many, I forget their names. I'm supposed to remember first and last names for a cast larger than twenty, and I just couldn't care less. It's probably because of the poor pacing, or the fact that we never got much on the modern day characters aside from the MC being bullied. He also doesn't have much of a personality himself, and is actually more of a shadow of his past life.

Also, there's are a few glaring plot-holes, such as why all of these students would give up their modern life for a thing that happened in the past; how they are able to keep all of this info a secret; and a few things about magic as well.

Honestly, it's an alright manga, but I feel like the time skips and flashbacks aren't placed well. Especially since we don't have much of a concrete modern setting with a bit of the student's backgrounds. We get like one liners about what they've been doing their whole lives that get swallowed up by who they used to be. I prefer fleshed out characters, and rather than being substantial, they can easily be blown over, since they don't really matter.

I like this and i think it got potential but man can it get confusing at times. The plot in itself can be hard to understand at times and it makes it worse with having to keep track of who everyone is and who they were in the past. After that theres their alligence and relationship with the other characters too

This manga dosn't lack in art, neither in slow pacing back fu**** lashing story.

This manga LACKS! alot in making any bond to the MC, way to many side characters with unneccary pages for the start.
Due that they have so many side kickers you wont get to know the MC that good. trust me it's a a godamn zoo.. a bad one.
For some reason this manga is just to retarded.. All the characters in this manga seems to have almost forgotten that it's the 20th century and that guns can kill someone before they can point their finger and say some random words, AND that their "new" lifes are just tossed away... seems like everyone went on this medieval thinking of honor and killing and forgot everything about them selfs and their present. (they speak about it from time to time) but HOLY SHit it's to washy and as a reader you wont accept the fact how people change over 1 day..
THE manga actully goes with a side kicker trying to kill another person for the MC.
(Note he only gotten his memories back about being someone for just a day or two ago)

I like magic, i like knights etc but this is just garbage i can't understand why people are giving it 10/0
I hardly see this as a masterpiece.

I first found this manga about two years ago. Reading the summary I wasn't really interested, but after re-finding it about six months later, I gave it a go.

And oh my god.

It was like eating a cake and finding out it was the god of all cakes. The summary really doesn't do it justice. It looked like the manga started as a Oneshot but was serialised, and the summary is based on said Oneshot: it captures the flavour of the manga, but not the brilliance of it.

Like LaLaLinzo said below, I was thinking this was a light, easy read.

NOPE NOPE NOPE. SO MUCH STORY, SO MUCH EVERYTHING.

I swear, I got way too emotionally attached to everyone. All the characters are likeable, and may I add, act like people and not overdramatic robots you usually find in mangas. No pointless crying, no pointless drama, just actual people in the situation, will real reactions.

The length is great, too. Every about two months (ish) there's a 60-80 page new chapter, enough that I don't feel frustrated but am left wanting more.

And the best thing is in the latest chapter only like one question has been answered while about a gazillion have been asked. And with nothing that actually acts as filler, I find this impressive.

Overall, READ THIS IF IT'S THE LAST THING YOU DO. Worth. Every. Second.

So I started this as a light read, ya?

Well HOLY SH*T F&(K DID I GET INVESTED INTO IT.
It's got such a solid plot line, you can tell the author knows exactly what they're doing.
I read all available chapters in one go, and I NEED THE NEXT ONE LIKE HOLY SHIZ ITS FINALLY GONNA HAPPEN~?!?!LSIDUFOISDU(FPOEISR

I am in love, and to pass time until the next (much needed!!!) chapter comes out, I'll be reading other works by this mangaka.

This wentt WAYY WAY WAYY beyond any expectations I had.
I am addicted.

Also for the two comments below: I guess it just depends on the pace you read it? I followed all that happened, but I certainly wasn't expecting for it to happen that way! It kept me on edge and guessing, thats what I loved about it 🙂

I'm going to have to agree strongly with rennov on this one. I tried to read through it, but I kept losing interest as I couldn't distinguish one female from the next! I would have to re-read the chapter until I had that "oooooh it's HER" moment.

Story-wise I think the premise has potential, but becoming disconnected from the characters really ruined it for me. The art is superb, but the artist needs to add more unique features to each character. Might re-read this in the future but for now I simply cannot.

Well, I got a mixed feeling when i read this series. The story is unique and the mystery is deducted with a fairly logical explanation (which is very important in this series), then wrapped with school life story with subtle romance (which is great). Yet, I found it really confusing when I saw how similar the face of each characters on this series with so many characters involved (plus the flashback character). When I got this "character disorientation", the fairly logical explanation chapter after chapter become null and I lost the interest to read it more. Ah, one more thing, the long release date make it worse (i really find it difficult to track who was who in this story)... I guess I need to read this from beginning again, maybe...

Around the start of the manga I was rather confused, but know that everything is coming together things'll get interesting. Seeing as how there are two potential villians whom haven't be revealed as of yet plus a lot mysteries surrounding everyone's memories. To be honest, I'm looking forward to the revelation of the prince's identity.

Unexpectedly good, mysteries stirred up pretty well and likeable characters. The romances, though are pretty absurd, which makes it more like sub plot. The story is, very unexpectedly very interesting, the mc himself is cool enough and kind of twisted, the rest of the characters are also good and enjoyable, comedies arent much, but the tenses are good, psychology aspects are also brought up well.

Pretty sure if it was published in the same magz as pandora hearts and black butler the josei tag would change into shounen lol, art styles are clean like shounen's made me really doubt it's josei