"D. Gray-Man" is a shounen manga that follows the tragic journey of Allen Walker, a cursed teenage boy who becomes an exorcist. He fights against "Akuma," mechanical beings containing the suffering souls of the dead, using weapons called "Innocence." These anti-Akuma weapons are central to the ancient war between exorcists and the creator of Akuma, the Millennium Earl.
The story starts with a simple premise but evolves into a complex narrative exploring themes of life, death, tragedy, and perseverance through its diverse cast. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The Characters --------------------
The characters are one of the show’s strongest points. Initially, they may seem generic, but as the series progresses, each character undergoes significant development that reveals their personalities, motivations, and internal struggles.
Allen Walker, the protagonist, is kind and polite, always ready to defend his comrades. His tragic past, marked by a curse from the Millennium Earl, makes him both human and part-Akuma. This duality inspires him to save both human and Akuma souls.
Lenalee Lee, the lead female character, is compassionate and deeply cares for her friends and brother. She transforms from a sweet girl into a brave young woman who faces dire situations head-on.
Yuu Kanda, another member of the Black Order, initially appears cold and combative. However, he shows a strong sense of duty and care for his comrades, making him one of the order's strongest fighters.
Lavi, aiming to become a Bookman, records history while fighting with a size-shifting hammer. Despite his cheerful demeanor, he struggles with his own identity and conflicts.
The Millennium Earl, the primary antagonist, creates Akuma and leads the Noah family. His cheerful yet devious nature makes him a formidable opponent linked to many characters' pasts. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What I Like ---------------
This series stands out from other shounen due to its dark tone and blend of tragedy and horror. Each arc delves deeper into the story, improving consistently. The pacing is excellent, balancing chapters, dialogue, and fights perfectly.
The characters are among the best in shounen, especially Allen, whose complexity shines through his gentle nature and hidden pain. The Noah Family and the Earl are also compelling, adding depth to the story's moral ambiguity.
Lenalee's kindness and strength make her a standout female character. Lavi and Crowley receive convincing development, showcasing Hoshino Katsura's skill in crafting multi-faceted characters.
The concept of Innocence adds intrigue, and the biblical themes enhance the analytical value of the series. The return of the manga and continuation of the anime have reinvigorated fan interest. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Things I Have a Problem With -----------------------------------
I wish there was earlier character development, as it takes time for their complexities to emerge. Early fights can feel repetitive and lack memorability, though this improves significantly in later arcs.
Kanda's role feels disjointed until his arc begins, and some major plot points need more emphasis to reduce confusion. However, these issues add to the re-read/re-watch value.
Final Thoughts
I initially found the anime unengaging, but reading the manga reignited my interest. The story deepens and becomes more complex, with compelling characters and great fights. I highly recommend it, even for non-shounen fans.
What I Like ------------- The dark tone, pacing, evolving story, well-timed comedy, beautiful quotes, compelling characters, concept of Innocence, biblical themes, Hoshino Katsura’s art style, and the continuing story.
What I Have Problems With --------------------------------- Backstories and character development come late. Early fights are repetitive. Kanda's role lacks significance until much later. Some major plot points need more emphasis to reduce confusion.
D.Gray-man incorporates many common elements of shounen manga. The protagonist possesses a rare and special ability, has endured a challenging childhood, yet remains kind-hearted. There is a clear distinction between good and evil, a large ensemble of supporting characters, and plenty of action.
Despite these familiar traits, D.Gray-man stands out from other popular shounen manga and surpasses them in quality. Most notably, it actually has a coherent plot. Rather than just a series of disconnected sagas and battles, there is a clear cause-and-effect pattern. While defeating enemies one after another to reach the goal is part of the story, it’s not the entire narrative.
Another strength lies in character development. None of the characters, especially the protagonists, can be summed up in just one word or even one sentence. The main character isn't your typical clueless or attention-seeking hero; he feels like a real person rather than a stereotype (and he's adorable too!). The supporting characters also defy stereotypes, each possessing unique personalities.
Now, let's talk about the art. As an artist myself, I find that the art in a manga is usually the most crucial aspect for me. It’s not about the technical quality but the artist’s ability to convey their vision effectively. In this regard, D.Gray-man excels! During fight scenes, it’s easy to follow the action, and you can always distinguish between the characters. There are numerous details, but they don’t overwhelm the reader. The reason I give the art 9 points instead of 10 is because I’m not fond of the monster designs. However, everything else is fantastic, exceeding my expectations for a shounen manga!
There are many more reasons why I enjoy D.Gray-man, such as the perfect balance between action and comedy and the thoughtful character design. So, go read it!
D.Gray-Man is a story centered on the holy war between "good" and "evil."
A series filled with mysteries, prompting more questions rather than providing answers to the numerous previous ones. And when the author finally provides a long-awaited answer, three new questions arise in its place.
This is a shonen that initially seems generic but unfolds into slightly different themes, resulting in a plot and characters that become much more multi-layered and multi-dimensional.
The plot's mystery is one of the most intriguing and well-developed, with twists and turns that are totally unexpected yet become clearer upon rereading previous chapters and understanding the foreshadowing.
Regarding good and evil, every side has a grey area, which is also reflected in the show's themes of religion, making you question which group is correct as both have caused significant bloodshed. The downside is that D.Gray-Man has not fully explored these themes yet due to its incomplete status.
The show focuses more on the characters, their history, and their standpoint on this endless war. Each character adds a unique color to the story, differing in design, nationality, age, history, and perspective on the war.
The villains are among the greatest, each lovable with unique personalities, forming a genuine family-like bond.
All of this is accompanied by the beautiful, ever-evolving art of the author.
I rate this series a 10/10 because it takes you on a journey (not literally) filled with shocking moments, sad moments, beautiful moments, and more. By the time you catch up with the series, you won't even remember how you felt at the beginning. More than a drastic change, it felt like a relaxing progression until it reached its climax in one arc, making the whole series seem fresh and different from everything previously stated.
I believe I initially started with the anime, and it took some time before I was truly hooked on the series. After the anime concluded, I simply had to continue with the manga—it's too good not to.
Story: 10/10
Some might argue that the story or plot isn't enough to warrant full marks, but in my opinion, the individual stories and backstories of each character are genuinely amazing, exciting, sad, and unique. There's always more to come, which will surprise you. You'll even find yourself enjoying the pasts of the antagonists, their motivations, and the entire world of D.Gray-man. The concept isn't new, but the details make the series stand out—the personal stories each character carries and the complexity of the world as a whole.
Art: 10/10
I still give the art a perfect score, although those who have been reading the manga from the beginning know it wasn't always this way. Initially, while beautiful and detailed, it wasn't outstanding. However, now it has become one of the most impressive and beautiful artworks I've seen so far, especially the latest chapter after such a long hiatus. The well-drawn emotions, clothing, surroundings, and shading are mesmerizing—I have no complaints.
Characters: 10/10
At first, you might find some characters annoying, unnerving, or weird, but in the end, there are hardly any I've honestly disliked. The character development is excellent, with interesting and often shocking or sad backstories. Even the abundance of side characters is lovely—all of them have distinct personalities and are likable. Of course, every world has its less favorite people, whether due to mindset, speech, attitude, or something else, but without them, it would be boring, right?
Enjoyment: 10/10
It might take some time to get into the series as you gradually learn about the characters, the world, and the 'different forces' (good and evil). However, for me, there has always been something compelling enough to make me want to read the next chapter—to keep going. D.Gray-man covers humor, action, drama, and more emotional content. If you enjoyed the first 40-xx chapters, you'll be pleasantly surprised by what comes next because, in my opinion, the story just gets better and better as it progresses. Or let's say the real story begins after the introduction to new characters and the world.
Overall: 10/10
It is one of my favorite series of all time, and I doubt that will change anytime soon, if ever. I've been a fan of D.Gray-man for several years now, and despite finding other great series (with many more yet to come), it has left such a significant impression on me that doesn't seem to fade. Despite the several hiatuses the series has had, I've always looked forward to its continuation.
I originally wrote this review nearly 11 years ago, and I remain just as infatuated with the manga now as I was back then. If this doesn't convey how much of a 10 I think it is, then nothing will.
Another misunderstanding here—why isn't this manga reviewed more often? Here’s my second review for the manga! Let's dive in:
Story: There are stories where we can skim over a few chapters and still understand what's happening; there are stories where we can skip a few volumes and still get the gist. D.Gray-Man doesn't fall into either category. If you miss even two or three panels initially, when that subject resurfaces, you'll be lost. Everything is intricately woven together; you won't find random mentions or side plots leading to dead ends (which would waste your time). For some, this might be overwhelming, but if you want a manga with style and multiple significant plots, this is the ultimate top! A solid 10.
Art: The images are beautiful, with detailed expressions and actions. The only drawback is that sometimes the toning can be excessive (to the point where even zoomed-in scans are hard to decipher). Apart from that, for a shonen manga, this is probably the highest quality art you can get. Without any faults I can name, I give it a 10.
Character: Likely the strongest point of the manga, many long-time readers will agree that the character development is superb! All characters have stories that aren’t told in one huge chunk of flashbacks (my first pleasant surprise). Instead, details are revealed bit by bit in situations that genuinely require these explanations, making the story more engaging. No character is the same, and we often see two sides of each character (as they struggle with decisions or, in some cases, physically). You’ll never grow bored of their adventures and soon find something relatable in them. Another 10.
Enjoyment: Reading a chapter of this manga brings me immense joy. There are no visible fillers, no long conversations unless absolutely necessary, and no random character stories. The beauty of the manga lies in its balance. After reading a chapter, you're left at a cliffhanger yet satisfied for the moment; you feel like you've been given valuable information (unlike some manga where a chapter feels utterly worthless, leaving you feeling like you're back where you started). Truly, I give it a full 10!
Overall: If you're looking for something supernatural, shonen-like, and full of adventure (with a touch of romance!), you must add this to your to-read list. It’s worth both your money and time, bringing a certain amount of happiness while reading. If you have the chance, please give it a try—I hope you won’t be disappointed!
Thank you all for reading my review! I hope it was helpful to you!
So, I decided to check out D.Gray-Man on a whim because I remembered watching the anime back in 2008. I thought maybe I should give the manga a try, not expecting much, but boy, was I in for a pleasant surprise.
- S T O R Y -
The plot revolves around Allen Walker, the protagonist who possesses both a cursed eye and an anti-Akuma weapon as an apostle of God, bearing the 'Innocence.' He joins the Black Order at his Master's recommendation to exorcise Akuma and ultimately thwart their creator, the Millennium Earl, alongside fellow exorcists.
The story is well-paced, developing the world of D.Gray-Man sufficiently so you understand the overall situation with the Akuma, making it feel distinct from a generic 19th-century setting.
Due to the manga transitioning from weekly to monthly releases, the quality of both art and pacing significantly improves as Katsura Hoshino has more time to plan the story's progression and conceptualize additional elements.
The story isn't entirely unique but offers a refreshing take compared to typical Shonen series. Most cliché Shonen tropes are absent, and the manga's edgier tone fits perfectly with its setting.
- C H A R A C T E R S -
The main characters all have their motives, goals, and personal stories. They develop well throughout the series while maintaining their core personalities. The most intriguing character is undoubtedly the protagonist, Allen. His presentation makes you feel like you already know him, yet there's a sense of vagueness and mystery about his backstory and origin, which the story teases fans with.
Although other characters also fare well, they are all likable, with interesting backstories or motives and distinctive looks and personalities.
- A R T -
D.Gray-Man's art features a charming gothic style that perfectly suits the setting and tone of the manga. While it starts out simplistic, it evolves drastically due to the transition from weekly to monthly publication. Currently, the art is extremely crisp, detailed, and the action sequences are clear. The gothic charm of the manga remains intact and is even more apparent now.
- O V E R A L L -
I think D.Gray-Man is definitely worth reading if you're looking for a Shonen manga that feels different from mainstream battle Shonen titles. It focuses primarily on its characters, with battles taking a back seat, though they are still present.
Okay, to summarize, D. Gray-man is... THE BEST FREAKIN' MANGA EVER!!!!!
I love D.Gray-man; it's such an awesome manga. It's the first manga where I bought almost every single book, and I don't regret spending money on it. I enjoyed every single book. It is truly an enjoyable manga.
I rated everything as a 10 for outstanding quality.
I love all the characters. Allen, Kanda, Lavi, Lenalee, and the rest are just amazing. Every time I see them, I can't help but giggle. Only Katsura could create such good-looking, awesome characters (usually, you don’t see such good-looking manga characters in Shonen Jump), and they have such nice personalities.
The art is beautiful; I absolutely love it. When I saw the later volumes and noticed her art style had changed, I initially thought, "No way, I loved it before." But I got used to it, and I still love it. Katsura Hosino is a wonderful manga artist. Sometimes, the fighting scenes get confusing with all those lines everywhere.
The storyline can sometimes be confusing, but I usually manage to understand it.
Overall, D. Gray-man is an awesome series worth reading and buying. You wouldn’t regret it. It’s by far one of my favorite mangas.
STORY
Although this story begins as a typical good versus evil narrative, it quickly becomes more complex, filled with twists and turns that weave into a vast web of moral ambiguity. One previous review claimed the main villain is unequivocally evil. However, once readers delve deeper into the series, they will find themselves questioning this assertion. D.Gray-Man stands out as unique and compelling, evolving from a standard plot into something much more intricate and profound.
ART
The art style is highly detailed, appealing to those who appreciate meticulous craftsmanship. The main characters are beautifully designed, contrasting sharply with the Gothic 'Akuma' and sometimes grotesque Innocence. The visual appeal of D.Gray-Man never wanes, especially given the author's rapidly evolving artistic style. Comparing artwork from the beginning, middle, and end of the series, it's hard to believe they were all created by the same artist, except for the consistent detailed character designs. In recent chapters, Hoshino demonstrates a deep understanding of anatomy and muscle structure, adding immense detail to her horror-themed demons. She is undoubtedly one of the most interesting mangakas around.
CHARACTER
The characters in D.Gray-Man are far from typical. Allen Walker, the protagonist, initially seems straightforward but evolves into a completely different person. As the series progresses, revealing new questions and insights, so does Allen. He starts knowing exactly what he wants and where he’s going, but the current Allen is lost, struggling with his identity—a struggle many can relate to. Miranda Lotto provides comic relief, and it's charming to know that she was based on the author herself. Kanda Yuu, the brooding anti-hero, initially seemed unlikable, but learning about his mysterious past added layers of intrigue and respect. Lavi, another humor-oriented character, has a serious dark side, and his role in the Bookman clan adds an interesting dimension. Lenalee Lee is one of the best female characters, with a strong personality that holds its own against the male-dominated cast. The villains are phenomenal, often more likable than the heroes themselves, with Tyki Mikk and Road Camelot being prime examples—they have their own motives and ideals, just like the Exorcists.
ENJOYMENT
There is a perfect balance of comedy, tragedy, and mystery. Despite the inherently hopeless situation of the protagonist, readers remain loyal and tenacious, much like the main characters. There are very few dull moments in this manga, keeping the audience engaged throughout.
OVERALL
Highly recommended. This series offers so much depth. To truly grasp the ideas presented here (and many more not mentioned), one must invest in the work. Ultimately, D.Gray-Man deserves a 10.
When I first read D.Gray-man from Volume 1, I thought, "Hmm... the cover looks really nice." At first, it seemed a bit boring in the initial chapters, but I kept reading because I had a feeling this was going to be a neat manga. Soon, the action made me think it was similar to Bleach. After an hour, I was amazed that I had already finished the three books I had in real life.
I continued reading online since I only had those three volumes physically. In just a few days, I reached Chapter 50+. The story had very sad moments, funny moments, and OMG-what's-going-to-happen-next moments. Now, I'm at Chapter 211, waiting for January to come so I can read Chapter 212 and find out what happens next.
~ I'm glad I didn't give up on this manga. I regret that some people did because it's a lovely story and manga.
~ Main Character
Okay, let's start from the beginning (struggles to remember). The story begins with a 15/16-year-old white-haired child named Allen Walker. You might wonder why his hair is white. Well, he used to have brown hair as a child. He was homeless until he met a clown named Mana. They spent a lot of time together until Mana died. Then, the Earl came to see Allen and asked if he wanted Mana back. Long story short, the Earl brought Mana back as an Akuma (a robot-like skeleton using dead human bodies).
This is when Allen's Innocence awakened and processed him. Now, he's half-Akuma/half-human and can see Akuma around him with his special eye. He was born with this rare Innocence called Crown Clown.
~ My Story Info
The story is mostly about Allen Walker searching for or finding Innocences or people with Innocence within them. It gets more exciting where you won't want to stop reading, or you'll be thrilled by what's going to happen next, or cry over the saddest and most touching parts.
~ My Rating
Story: 10 - Reason: See above.
Art: 10 - Reason: The art is really beautiful throughout the story.
Characters: 10 - Reason: The characters here don't just say, "We're on a team, so we gotta stick together." They mean, "We may be on a team, but friendship never dies even if the world will end."
Enjoyment: 9 - Reason: Lots of amazing fights, very funny scenes where you'll laugh out loud, and emotional parts where you'll cry until there's a funny or happy part.
This is one of my favorite manga, and I've been reading it for years. There have been several hiatuses, unfortunately, but it's never hard to wait. I've reread this so many times that I can't even remember the number. I am more than willing to wait three months to read a quality chapter, especially knowing it's better for the author's health so she can continue to do her best work.
This is a very unique story, following one protagonist while giving character development to everyone who encounters him. At first, it seems like a typical shonen series, full of battles, yelling about special abilities, characters that are easy on the eyes, and a cute little "pet." Even in just the first few chapters, you get a glimpse of Allen Walker's dark past, which unfolds as the series progresses but isn't fully revealed until the more recent chapters.
The beginning itself is rather dark, with the first major arc discussing death and showing what exactly exorcists do in this world. However, it is perhaps one of the most lighthearted of the major arcs. Between these arcs, there are moments of comedic relief, which might be the worst part of the story, yet they remain enjoyable and hardly detract from the plot. If anything, they provide more chances for character development and introductions.
The antagonists of the series are extremely likable and can serve as comedic relief while also making the story much darker when you discover their true purpose. Eventually, the story becomes scattered, branching out to multiple perspectives and many flashbacks. Luckily, these flashbacks and perspectives unravel the mystery behind Allen Walker and his relationship with the Noah clan, which is perhaps my favorite part.
The only complaint I really have is the art. Don't get me wrong; you will never mistake characters in D.Gray-Man, and they all have their own unique styles. The beginning was actually quite good for the start of a manga, but you can tell the artist's health was declining midway through, and the art started to get rather inconsistent. You can even tell when she took a hiatus just by looking at the art because suddenly it changed to a fuller look, and the characters had more depth to their appearances, though it wasn't as clean as it once was. Fortunately, it improved as she got back into the swing of things.
Opinion with a semi-spoiler (take it as you wish): I love anime where, in the beginning, there are clear-cut good and bad guys, but as the story moves on, it becomes increasingly less clear. This is one of those stories, and it is executed so well that you barely even notice it because you like the apparent bad guys just as much as the good guys. It shows that good and bad are subjective, and there is good and bad on all sides.
Overall: Great story, though there were some parts that could have been explained more. The art isn't bad and is very easy to look at, but there were definitely rough patches. There are many characters, and unfortunately, the mangaka tends to give a bit too much attention to some annoying characters that I couldn't find myself liking. The Noah clan, however, is perfect. Allen Walker's current state was made very understandable and not super sudden either. The main secondary characters from the Order are great too, though Lenalee can be a bit of a Mary Sue at times. They each have their own individualities that make it easy to distinguish them, and the way they interact with each other is very enjoyable. 10/10 would recommend.
Story 10/10: A dark shounen manga, how rare. It's incredibly well-crafted, revolving around Allen Walker and a clown named Millennium Earl. The narrative delves into the battle between exorcists and demons (akuma). The story is mysterious and dark, with an excellent pacing that ensures nothing feels random or out of place. Everything flows smoothly, making it one of the best-paced stories I've encountered.
Art: There's little to complain about here. Most characters are beautifully drawn, and the mangaka deserves praise for this. However, some fight scenes can be confusing, which is common in shounen manga. One standout feature is the unique art style, reminiscent of Berserk (RIP Kentaro Miura).
Character Development: Allen's character development is outstanding. You see all facets of his personality, much like Luffy from One Piece. His emotions are palpable, making him a deeply relatable character. Additionally, minor characters have significant impacts on the story, such as Johnny, highlighting their importance and depth.
Overall: 9/10. Is it worth reading? Absolutely, without a doubt. The unpredictable story will keep you hooked and make you fall in love with the characters.
ART SECTION: 8/10
The gothic motif is commendable, and the rough outlines enhance the grim and eerie atmosphere. Like many shounen series, it features clear-cut heroes and villains dressed according to a specific theme. While the aesthetics are noteworthy, the storytelling follows familiar patterns. However, the Gothic world's decorations are particularly captivating.
STORY SECTION: 4/10
The initial chapters are excellent, drawing viewers in with an alternate Earth filled with gothic motifs. An evil demon exploits people's grief over lost loved ones, luring them into resurrecting the dead and creating chaos. The protagonists must find Innocence, powers that protect the world, and battle the Evil Earl and his minions.
Though this setup is typical for a shounen series, the Gothic setting adds an interesting twist. Initially, the story progresses well, introducing main characters, their tragic backstories, and the secret organization opposing the Earl.
However, predictability sets in after the basic plot and cast are established. Characters behave in typical shounen fashion, and battles become repetitive power-ups. This diminishes suspense quickly. Additionally, the story was abandoned by its creator, leaving an incomplete and unoriginal narrative with a promising concept that feels less novel due to the current Gothic manga trend.
CHARACTER SECTION: 5/10
If you've read any Jump shounen, you know what to expect: a kind-hearted boy with immense power, a supportive girl, antagonists, and sidekicks. The characters are young yet possess superpowers capable of leveling buildings, which is standard for the genre. Unfortunately, they don't develop much beyond their introductory episodes. Flashbacks provide context but little character growth. Even the villains, while visually appealing, lack depth beyond their desire to destroy the world. Monster minions serve as disposable foes, losing interest quickly after defeat.
Overall, the characters are adequate for the series but not special or unique. They are enjoyable to watch but lack completeness and development, earning them a base score for being decent.
VALUE SECTION: 2/10
Despite initial hype, the series' popularity waned quickly when a similar manga gained traction. It lacks historical value due to its incompleteness and the ongoing Gothic manga trend. Compared to other shounen, it feels generic, and compared to other Gothic manga, it falls short in atmosphere and story. Thus, rereading or remembering it is unlikely.
ENJOYMENT SECTION: 4/10
While the initial chapters and a few others were engaging, the series generally felt generic and failed to hold my interest. Therefore, I recommend titles from my Suggestion List, which are similar yet more compelling.
VERDICT: 4.5/10
A shounen series with potential but ultimately hindered by poor planning, resulting in fewer chapters than comparable long-running series like Naruto or Bleach.
SUGGESTION LIST
Soul Eater
Death Note
Bleach
Ao no Exorcist
Beelzebub
Popular Reviews
What It's About
--------------------
"D. Gray-Man" is a shounen manga that follows the tragic journey of Allen Walker, a cursed teenage boy who becomes an exorcist. He fights against "Akuma," mechanical beings containing the suffering souls of the dead, using weapons called "Innocence." These anti-Akuma weapons are central to the ancient war between exorcists and the creator of Akuma, the Millennium Earl.
The story starts with a simple premise but evolves into a complex narrative exploring themes of life, death, tragedy, and perseverance through its diverse cast.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The Characters
--------------------
The characters are one of the show’s strongest points. Initially, they may seem generic, but as the series progresses, each character undergoes significant development that reveals their personalities, motivations, and internal struggles.
Allen Walker, the protagonist, is kind and polite, always ready to defend his comrades. His tragic past, marked by a curse from the Millennium Earl, makes him both human and part-Akuma. This duality inspires him to save both human and Akuma souls.
Lenalee Lee, the lead female character, is compassionate and deeply cares for her friends and brother. She transforms from a sweet girl into a brave young woman who faces dire situations head-on.
Yuu Kanda, another member of the Black Order, initially appears cold and combative. However, he shows a strong sense of duty and care for his comrades, making him one of the order's strongest fighters.
Lavi, aiming to become a Bookman, records history while fighting with a size-shifting hammer. Despite his cheerful demeanor, he struggles with his own identity and conflicts.
The Millennium Earl, the primary antagonist, creates Akuma and leads the Noah family. His cheerful yet devious nature makes him a formidable opponent linked to many characters' pasts.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What I Like
---------------
This series stands out from other shounen due to its dark tone and blend of tragedy and horror. Each arc delves deeper into the story, improving consistently. The pacing is excellent, balancing chapters, dialogue, and fights perfectly.
The characters are among the best in shounen, especially Allen, whose complexity shines through his gentle nature and hidden pain. The Noah Family and the Earl are also compelling, adding depth to the story's moral ambiguity.
Lenalee's kindness and strength make her a standout female character. Lavi and Crowley receive convincing development, showcasing Hoshino Katsura's skill in crafting multi-faceted characters.
The concept of Innocence adds intrigue, and the biblical themes enhance the analytical value of the series. The return of the manga and continuation of the anime have reinvigorated fan interest.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Things I Have a Problem With
-----------------------------------
I wish there was earlier character development, as it takes time for their complexities to emerge. Early fights can feel repetitive and lack memorability, though this improves significantly in later arcs.
Kanda's role feels disjointed until his arc begins, and some major plot points need more emphasis to reduce confusion. However, these issues add to the re-read/re-watch value.
Final Thoughts
I initially found the anime unengaging, but reading the manga reignited my interest. The story deepens and becomes more complex, with compelling characters and great fights. I highly recommend it, even for non-shounen fans.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
TL; DR
What I Like
-------------
The dark tone, pacing, evolving story, well-timed comedy, beautiful quotes, compelling characters, concept of Innocence, biblical themes, Hoshino Katsura’s art style, and the continuing story.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What I Have Problems With
---------------------------------
Backstories and character development come late. Early fights are repetitive. Kanda's role lacks significance until much later. Some major plot points need more emphasis to reduce confusion.
D.Gray-man incorporates many common elements of shounen manga. The protagonist possesses a rare and special ability, has endured a challenging childhood, yet remains kind-hearted. There is a clear distinction between good and evil, a large ensemble of supporting characters, and plenty of action.
Despite these familiar traits, D.Gray-man stands out from other popular shounen manga and surpasses them in quality. Most notably, it actually has a coherent plot. Rather than just a series of disconnected sagas and battles, there is a clear cause-and-effect pattern. While defeating enemies one after another to reach the goal is part of the story, it’s not the entire narrative.
Another strength lies in character development. None of the characters, especially the protagonists, can be summed up in just one word or even one sentence. The main character isn't your typical clueless or attention-seeking hero; he feels like a real person rather than a stereotype (and he's adorable too!). The supporting characters also defy stereotypes, each possessing unique personalities.
Now, let's talk about the art. As an artist myself, I find that the art in a manga is usually the most crucial aspect for me. It’s not about the technical quality but the artist’s ability to convey their vision effectively. In this regard, D.Gray-man excels! During fight scenes, it’s easy to follow the action, and you can always distinguish between the characters. There are numerous details, but they don’t overwhelm the reader. The reason I give the art 9 points instead of 10 is because I’m not fond of the monster designs. However, everything else is fantastic, exceeding my expectations for a shounen manga!
There are many more reasons why I enjoy D.Gray-man, such as the perfect balance between action and comedy and the thoughtful character design. So, go read it!
D.Gray-Man is a story centered on the holy war between "good" and "evil."
A series filled with mysteries, prompting more questions rather than providing answers to the numerous previous ones. And when the author finally provides a long-awaited answer, three new questions arise in its place.
This is a shonen that initially seems generic but unfolds into slightly different themes, resulting in a plot and characters that become much more multi-layered and multi-dimensional.
The plot's mystery is one of the most intriguing and well-developed, with twists and turns that are totally unexpected yet become clearer upon rereading previous chapters and understanding the foreshadowing.
Regarding good and evil, every side has a grey area, which is also reflected in the show's themes of religion, making you question which group is correct as both have caused significant bloodshed. The downside is that D.Gray-Man has not fully explored these themes yet due to its incomplete status.
The show focuses more on the characters, their history, and their standpoint on this endless war. Each character adds a unique color to the story, differing in design, nationality, age, history, and perspective on the war.
The villains are among the greatest, each lovable with unique personalities, forming a genuine family-like bond.
All of this is accompanied by the beautiful, ever-evolving art of the author.
I rate this series a 10/10 because it takes you on a journey (not literally) filled with shocking moments, sad moments, beautiful moments, and more. By the time you catch up with the series, you won't even remember how you felt at the beginning. More than a drastic change, it felt like a relaxing progression until it reached its climax in one arc, making the whole series seem fresh and different from everything previously stated.
I believe I initially started with the anime, and it took some time before I was truly hooked on the series. After the anime concluded, I simply had to continue with the manga—it's too good not to.
Story: 10/10
Some might argue that the story or plot isn't enough to warrant full marks, but in my opinion, the individual stories and backstories of each character are genuinely amazing, exciting, sad, and unique. There's always more to come, which will surprise you. You'll even find yourself enjoying the pasts of the antagonists, their motivations, and the entire world of D.Gray-man. The concept isn't new, but the details make the series stand out—the personal stories each character carries and the complexity of the world as a whole.
Art: 10/10
I still give the art a perfect score, although those who have been reading the manga from the beginning know it wasn't always this way. Initially, while beautiful and detailed, it wasn't outstanding. However, now it has become one of the most impressive and beautiful artworks I've seen so far, especially the latest chapter after such a long hiatus. The well-drawn emotions, clothing, surroundings, and shading are mesmerizing—I have no complaints.
Characters: 10/10
At first, you might find some characters annoying, unnerving, or weird, but in the end, there are hardly any I've honestly disliked. The character development is excellent, with interesting and often shocking or sad backstories. Even the abundance of side characters is lovely—all of them have distinct personalities and are likable. Of course, every world has its less favorite people, whether due to mindset, speech, attitude, or something else, but without them, it would be boring, right?
Enjoyment: 10/10
It might take some time to get into the series as you gradually learn about the characters, the world, and the 'different forces' (good and evil). However, for me, there has always been something compelling enough to make me want to read the next chapter—to keep going. D.Gray-man covers humor, action, drama, and more emotional content. If you enjoyed the first 40-xx chapters, you'll be pleasantly surprised by what comes next because, in my opinion, the story just gets better and better as it progresses. Or let's say the real story begins after the introduction to new characters and the world.
Overall: 10/10
It is one of my favorite series of all time, and I doubt that will change anytime soon, if ever. I've been a fan of D.Gray-man for several years now, and despite finding other great series (with many more yet to come), it has left such a significant impression on me that doesn't seem to fade. Despite the several hiatuses the series has had, I've always looked forward to its continuation.
I originally wrote this review nearly 11 years ago, and I remain just as infatuated with the manga now as I was back then. If this doesn't convey how much of a 10 I think it is, then nothing will.
Another misunderstanding here—why isn't this manga reviewed more often? Here’s my second review for the manga! Let's dive in:
Story: There are stories where we can skim over a few chapters and still understand what's happening; there are stories where we can skip a few volumes and still get the gist. D.Gray-Man doesn't fall into either category. If you miss even two or three panels initially, when that subject resurfaces, you'll be lost. Everything is intricately woven together; you won't find random mentions or side plots leading to dead ends (which would waste your time). For some, this might be overwhelming, but if you want a manga with style and multiple significant plots, this is the ultimate top! A solid 10.
Art: The images are beautiful, with detailed expressions and actions. The only drawback is that sometimes the toning can be excessive (to the point where even zoomed-in scans are hard to decipher). Apart from that, for a shonen manga, this is probably the highest quality art you can get. Without any faults I can name, I give it a 10.
Character: Likely the strongest point of the manga, many long-time readers will agree that the character development is superb! All characters have stories that aren’t told in one huge chunk of flashbacks (my first pleasant surprise). Instead, details are revealed bit by bit in situations that genuinely require these explanations, making the story more engaging. No character is the same, and we often see two sides of each character (as they struggle with decisions or, in some cases, physically). You’ll never grow bored of their adventures and soon find something relatable in them. Another 10.
Enjoyment: Reading a chapter of this manga brings me immense joy. There are no visible fillers, no long conversations unless absolutely necessary, and no random character stories. The beauty of the manga lies in its balance. After reading a chapter, you're left at a cliffhanger yet satisfied for the moment; you feel like you've been given valuable information (unlike some manga where a chapter feels utterly worthless, leaving you feeling like you're back where you started). Truly, I give it a full 10!
Overall: If you're looking for something supernatural, shonen-like, and full of adventure (with a touch of romance!), you must add this to your to-read list. It’s worth both your money and time, bringing a certain amount of happiness while reading. If you have the chance, please give it a try—I hope you won’t be disappointed!
Thank you all for reading my review! I hope it was helpful to you!
So, I decided to check out D.Gray-Man on a whim because I remembered watching the anime back in 2008. I thought maybe I should give the manga a try, not expecting much, but boy, was I in for a pleasant surprise.
- S T O R Y -
The plot revolves around Allen Walker, the protagonist who possesses both a cursed eye and an anti-Akuma weapon as an apostle of God, bearing the 'Innocence.' He joins the Black Order at his Master's recommendation to exorcise Akuma and ultimately thwart their creator, the Millennium Earl, alongside fellow exorcists.
The story is well-paced, developing the world of D.Gray-Man sufficiently so you understand the overall situation with the Akuma, making it feel distinct from a generic 19th-century setting.
Due to the manga transitioning from weekly to monthly releases, the quality of both art and pacing significantly improves as Katsura Hoshino has more time to plan the story's progression and conceptualize additional elements.
The story isn't entirely unique but offers a refreshing take compared to typical Shonen series. Most cliché Shonen tropes are absent, and the manga's edgier tone fits perfectly with its setting.
- C H A R A C T E R S -
The main characters all have their motives, goals, and personal stories. They develop well throughout the series while maintaining their core personalities. The most intriguing character is undoubtedly the protagonist, Allen. His presentation makes you feel like you already know him, yet there's a sense of vagueness and mystery about his backstory and origin, which the story teases fans with. Although other characters also fare well, they are all likable, with interesting backstories or motives and distinctive looks and personalities.
- A R T -
D.Gray-Man's art features a charming gothic style that perfectly suits the setting and tone of the manga. While it starts out simplistic, it evolves drastically due to the transition from weekly to monthly publication. Currently, the art is extremely crisp, detailed, and the action sequences are clear. The gothic charm of the manga remains intact and is even more apparent now.
- O V E R A L L -
I think D.Gray-Man is definitely worth reading if you're looking for a Shonen manga that feels different from mainstream battle Shonen titles. It focuses primarily on its characters, with battles taking a back seat, though they are still present.
Okay, to summarize, D. Gray-man is... THE BEST FREAKIN' MANGA EVER!!!!!
I love D.Gray-man; it's such an awesome manga. It's the first manga where I bought almost every single book, and I don't regret spending money on it. I enjoyed every single book. It is truly an enjoyable manga.
I rated everything as a 10 for outstanding quality.
I love all the characters. Allen, Kanda, Lavi, Lenalee, and the rest are just amazing. Every time I see them, I can't help but giggle. Only Katsura could create such good-looking, awesome characters (usually, you don’t see such good-looking manga characters in Shonen Jump), and they have such nice personalities.
The art is beautiful; I absolutely love it. When I saw the later volumes and noticed her art style had changed, I initially thought, "No way, I loved it before." But I got used to it, and I still love it. Katsura Hosino is a wonderful manga artist. Sometimes, the fighting scenes get confusing with all those lines everywhere.
The storyline can sometimes be confusing, but I usually manage to understand it.
Overall, D. Gray-man is an awesome series worth reading and buying. You wouldn’t regret it. It’s by far one of my favorite mangas.
STORY
Although this story begins as a typical good versus evil narrative, it quickly becomes more complex, filled with twists and turns that weave into a vast web of moral ambiguity. One previous review claimed the main villain is unequivocally evil. However, once readers delve deeper into the series, they will find themselves questioning this assertion. D.Gray-Man stands out as unique and compelling, evolving from a standard plot into something much more intricate and profound.
ART
The art style is highly detailed, appealing to those who appreciate meticulous craftsmanship. The main characters are beautifully designed, contrasting sharply with the Gothic 'Akuma' and sometimes grotesque Innocence. The visual appeal of D.Gray-Man never wanes, especially given the author's rapidly evolving artistic style. Comparing artwork from the beginning, middle, and end of the series, it's hard to believe they were all created by the same artist, except for the consistent detailed character designs. In recent chapters, Hoshino demonstrates a deep understanding of anatomy and muscle structure, adding immense detail to her horror-themed demons. She is undoubtedly one of the most interesting mangakas around.
CHARACTER
The characters in D.Gray-Man are far from typical. Allen Walker, the protagonist, initially seems straightforward but evolves into a completely different person. As the series progresses, revealing new questions and insights, so does Allen. He starts knowing exactly what he wants and where he’s going, but the current Allen is lost, struggling with his identity—a struggle many can relate to. Miranda Lotto provides comic relief, and it's charming to know that she was based on the author herself. Kanda Yuu, the brooding anti-hero, initially seemed unlikable, but learning about his mysterious past added layers of intrigue and respect. Lavi, another humor-oriented character, has a serious dark side, and his role in the Bookman clan adds an interesting dimension. Lenalee Lee is one of the best female characters, with a strong personality that holds its own against the male-dominated cast. The villains are phenomenal, often more likable than the heroes themselves, with Tyki Mikk and Road Camelot being prime examples—they have their own motives and ideals, just like the Exorcists.
ENJOYMENT
There is a perfect balance of comedy, tragedy, and mystery. Despite the inherently hopeless situation of the protagonist, readers remain loyal and tenacious, much like the main characters. There are very few dull moments in this manga, keeping the audience engaged throughout.
OVERALL
Highly recommended. This series offers so much depth. To truly grasp the ideas presented here (and many more not mentioned), one must invest in the work. Ultimately, D.Gray-Man deserves a 10.
~ My Feelings for This Manga
When I first read D.Gray-man from Volume 1, I thought, "Hmm... the cover looks really nice." At first, it seemed a bit boring in the initial chapters, but I kept reading because I had a feeling this was going to be a neat manga. Soon, the action made me think it was similar to Bleach. After an hour, I was amazed that I had already finished the three books I had in real life.
I continued reading online since I only had those three volumes physically. In just a few days, I reached Chapter 50+. The story had very sad moments, funny moments, and OMG-what's-going-to-happen-next moments. Now, I'm at Chapter 211, waiting for January to come so I can read Chapter 212 and find out what happens next.
~ I'm glad I didn't give up on this manga. I regret that some people did because it's a lovely story and manga.
~ Main Character
Okay, let's start from the beginning (struggles to remember). The story begins with a 15/16-year-old white-haired child named Allen Walker. You might wonder why his hair is white. Well, he used to have brown hair as a child. He was homeless until he met a clown named Mana. They spent a lot of time together until Mana died. Then, the Earl came to see Allen and asked if he wanted Mana back. Long story short, the Earl brought Mana back as an Akuma (a robot-like skeleton using dead human bodies).
This is when Allen's Innocence awakened and processed him. Now, he's half-Akuma/half-human and can see Akuma around him with his special eye. He was born with this rare Innocence called Crown Clown.
~ My Story Info
The story is mostly about Allen Walker searching for or finding Innocences or people with Innocence within them. It gets more exciting where you won't want to stop reading, or you'll be thrilled by what's going to happen next, or cry over the saddest and most touching parts.
~ My Rating
Story: 10 - Reason: See above.
Art: 10 - Reason: The art is really beautiful throughout the story.
Characters: 10 - Reason: The characters here don't just say, "We're on a team, so we gotta stick together." They mean, "We may be on a team, but friendship never dies even if the world will end."
Enjoyment: 9 - Reason: Lots of amazing fights, very funny scenes where you'll laugh out loud, and emotional parts where you'll cry until there's a funny or happy part.
Overall, I give it a 10 :D
Quick Review: Minor spoilers.
Story 10/10: A dark shounen manga, how rare. It's incredibly well-crafted, revolving around Allen Walker and a clown named Millennium Earl. The narrative delves into the battle between exorcists and demons (akuma). The story is mysterious and dark, with an excellent pacing that ensures nothing feels random or out of place. Everything flows smoothly, making it one of the best-paced stories I've encountered.
Art: There's little to complain about here. Most characters are beautifully drawn, and the mangaka deserves praise for this. However, some fight scenes can be confusing, which is common in shounen manga. One standout feature is the unique art style, reminiscent of Berserk (RIP Kentaro Miura).
Character Development: Allen's character development is outstanding. You see all facets of his personality, much like Luffy from One Piece. His emotions are palpable, making him a deeply relatable character. Additionally, minor characters have significant impacts on the story, such as Johnny, highlighting their importance and depth.
Overall: 9/10. Is it worth reading? Absolutely, without a doubt. The unpredictable story will keep you hooked and make you fall in love with the characters.
ART SECTION: 8/10 The gothic motif is commendable, and the rough outlines enhance the grim and eerie atmosphere. Like many shounen series, it features clear-cut heroes and villains dressed according to a specific theme. While the aesthetics are noteworthy, the storytelling follows familiar patterns. However, the Gothic world's decorations are particularly captivating. STORY SECTION: 4/10 The initial chapters are excellent, drawing viewers in with an alternate Earth filled with gothic motifs. An evil demon exploits people's grief over lost loved ones, luring them into resurrecting the dead and creating chaos. The protagonists must find Innocence, powers that protect the world, and battle the Evil Earl and his minions. Though this setup is typical for a shounen series, the Gothic setting adds an interesting twist. Initially, the story progresses well, introducing main characters, their tragic backstories, and the secret organization opposing the Earl. However, predictability sets in after the basic plot and cast are established. Characters behave in typical shounen fashion, and battles become repetitive power-ups. This diminishes suspense quickly. Additionally, the story was abandoned by its creator, leaving an incomplete and unoriginal narrative with a promising concept that feels less novel due to the current Gothic manga trend. CHARACTER SECTION: 5/10 If you've read any Jump shounen, you know what to expect: a kind-hearted boy with immense power, a supportive girl, antagonists, and sidekicks. The characters are young yet possess superpowers capable of leveling buildings, which is standard for the genre. Unfortunately, they don't develop much beyond their introductory episodes. Flashbacks provide context but little character growth. Even the villains, while visually appealing, lack depth beyond their desire to destroy the world. Monster minions serve as disposable foes, losing interest quickly after defeat. Overall, the characters are adequate for the series but not special or unique. They are enjoyable to watch but lack completeness and development, earning them a base score for being decent. VALUE SECTION: 2/10 Despite initial hype, the series' popularity waned quickly when a similar manga gained traction. It lacks historical value due to its incompleteness and the ongoing Gothic manga trend. Compared to other shounen, it feels generic, and compared to other Gothic manga, it falls short in atmosphere and story. Thus, rereading or remembering it is unlikely. ENJOYMENT SECTION: 4/10 While the initial chapters and a few others were engaging, the series generally felt generic and failed to hold my interest. Therefore, I recommend titles from my Suggestion List, which are similar yet more compelling. VERDICT: 4.5/10 A shounen series with potential but ultimately hindered by poor planning, resulting in fewer chapters than comparable long-running series like Naruto or Bleach. SUGGESTION LIST Soul Eater Death Note Bleach Ao no Exorcist Beelzebub
Leave a Review