My Ex-Girlfriend Was Appointed as a Knight Commander Chapter 23 Discussion

  • Thread starter Anari
  • Start date
  • #1
Pretty early on, which I normally don't review this early, but the NU page has a too-low rating that it doesn't deserve. 4 for now, it absolutely doesn't deserve a bunch of 1's though.

As for the story itself, I'm only 23 chapters in, and I quite like it. Interesting setting, and there's some very emotional moments. That being said, they're very... dramatic. As in, drama like a story, built by bad communication. Much of the early conflict so far relies on the MC and the ex not really talking to each other. Which, to be fair, they have a ton of baggage.

That being said, I like the two female leads so far, and judging by the harem ending the other reviewer mentioned, I'm all for it. I do disagree with him/her though, in that I quite like the Ex so far. Could get worse, I am vastly far behind them of course, but for now at least it's just fine.

My only real complaint deals with the backstory that sets up the entire story. There's a flashback for a few chapters (around c20-ish or so), and there's a pretty gaping plot hole in my mind:

Spoiler

Well, he basically was set up and cursed by the FL's evil parent and another scheming lord. The scheme itself is perfectly fine/diabolical, and it works just fine. The problem is that he's literally already cursed and his future destroyed, and they demand he break up with his girlfriend, so they have literally nothing over him. Literally nothing. He's already screwed. All he has to do is tell her she was tricked, what happened to him, and their entire scheme - which by the way is TREASON, actual treason against the crown - would fall apart. But for some reason he just listens to him. He honestly acts like he's being blackmailed, when you know, he's not? He's already ruined.

[collapse]

I'm just super confused about why he reacted like he did, besides 'for plot reasons'.

But ignoring that glaring plot hole, I like a lot of what's going on. There's a great undercurrent of emotion going on with the main character and his ex, I like his mage friend (clearly #2, or maybe even #1 harem member). I enjoy a story about knights, especially aura+magic+knights, and the setting is good.

So yeah, not perfect, but definitely not deserving of ones.
 
  • #6
Loved it! Definitely couldn't put the book down. The love that Ace had for Emerald was beautiful! Would definitely recommend this book!
 
  • #7
Love the story, so keep it up, but work on how to write in English.
 
  • #9
am really enjoyed in this story it keeps wanting to keep reading
 
  • #11
Awesome I like that the grammar was really good and the book was easy to read
 
You must be logged in to reply here. Register an account to get started.