This novel took me through the most intense emotional experiences. There is no big bad wolf here. Every one is just a victim of circumstances. If i was them i would have reacted the same way despite my beliefs. Kudos to the author
Story: The plot is quirky and moves at a rapid pace! The first main couple ties the knot within just a few pages. And the second pair falls in love over something rather trivial. Personally, I'm not a believer in 'love at first sight.' But if you are, you might appreciate the story more than I do.
Basically, this manga is really like a GAG. It's a one-shot plot-line and is best enjoyed when you just want to pass the time with a simple romantic tale.
Artwork: The artwork follows a very typical shoujo style. The girls vary from adorable to having strong personalities. The guys, as expected, are all good-looking. But even though it's a typical style, the charming situations the two main couples find themselves in are heartwarming. Or they'll bring a smile to your face.
Characters: With a plot like Tenjou no Kajitsu, your characters have very limited room for growth. There isn't enough space for much development. The main character's sudden shift from hating boys for most of her life to suddenly falling in love with the first one who is kind to her is fast-paced development. Something that I personally don't enjoy, but to each their own.
Overall: This manga is decent in its own way, but certainly can't compare to other more popular, more developed shoujo comics.
I enjoy stories where heroines aren't instantly infatuated with boys, but instead have their perspectives gradually altered through specific interactions and circumstances, leading them to realize there might be goodness in the world. However, I detest when such transformations occur merely for the sake of plot progression without adequate transitions or justifications. This story didn't let me down, though it's not among the top ten in its genre.
Introducing Tomita, who, due to some minor childhood traumas, harbors a dislike for boys and believes they're generally up to no good. She serves as the student council president at an all-girls school, which, in my opinion, is depicted exceptionally well! All her classmates contribute humorously to the overwhelmingly feminine atmosphere, and her friend and vice president, Tudou, adds charm to the storyline as the school's beloved prince-like figure who effortlessly captivates any girl with her host-like demeanor. Naturally, Tomita's cherished tranquil existence will be thrown into chaos when her school merges with an all-boys school. But what can she do to mitigate the turmoil? And why won't the male student council president, Yuuki, from that school stop trying to change her mind about boys?! What's in it for him? It's evident where this plot is headed, but its execution is handled gently to avoid alienating readers.
I believe the character development in this story unfolds at a leisurely pace, shining brightly in every chapter. Most characters are quite unique, even though they somewhat conform to standard shoujo tropes for a hate-turning-to-love narrative. The artwork deserves praise because all characters look true to their personalities and are undeniably attractive, without adhering to conventional standards of beauty. Each character is given ample opportunity to express their life grievances and grow as individuals. Scenes are humorous when appropriate and tender when intimacy is called for. Some plots feel clichéd, particularly those involving Tomita and Yuuki, but those centered on Tudou and Himeno compensate with originality and entertainment. Once or twice, you might bristle at how easily the lead female is placed in a subordinate position in a race for presidency, but such plots are unfortunately common in shoujo today.
Overall, this is a quick read, fitting if you're seeking comedy and high school drama, but it lacks the depth needed to be a great romantic tale since the characters aren't fully fleshed out. Situations and dialogue remain relatively fresh and keep you amused, while the art is soothing and visually pleasing for those who appreciate intricately drawn bishounen.
Popular Reviews
Basically, this manga is really like a GAG. It's a one-shot plot-line and is best enjoyed when you just want to pass the time with a simple romantic tale.
Artwork: The artwork follows a very typical shoujo style. The girls vary from adorable to having strong personalities. The guys, as expected, are all good-looking. But even though it's a typical style, the charming situations the two main couples find themselves in are heartwarming. Or they'll bring a smile to your face.
Characters: With a plot like Tenjou no Kajitsu, your characters have very limited room for growth. There isn't enough space for much development. The main character's sudden shift from hating boys for most of her life to suddenly falling in love with the first one who is kind to her is fast-paced development. Something that I personally don't enjoy, but to each their own.
Overall: This manga is decent in its own way, but certainly can't compare to other more popular, more developed shoujo comics.
Introducing Tomita, who, due to some minor childhood traumas, harbors a dislike for boys and believes they're generally up to no good. She serves as the student council president at an all-girls school, which, in my opinion, is depicted exceptionally well! All her classmates contribute humorously to the overwhelmingly feminine atmosphere, and her friend and vice president, Tudou, adds charm to the storyline as the school's beloved prince-like figure who effortlessly captivates any girl with her host-like demeanor. Naturally, Tomita's cherished tranquil existence will be thrown into chaos when her school merges with an all-boys school. But what can she do to mitigate the turmoil? And why won't the male student council president, Yuuki, from that school stop trying to change her mind about boys?! What's in it for him? It's evident where this plot is headed, but its execution is handled gently to avoid alienating readers.
I believe the character development in this story unfolds at a leisurely pace, shining brightly in every chapter. Most characters are quite unique, even though they somewhat conform to standard shoujo tropes for a hate-turning-to-love narrative. The artwork deserves praise because all characters look true to their personalities and are undeniably attractive, without adhering to conventional standards of beauty. Each character is given ample opportunity to express their life grievances and grow as individuals. Scenes are humorous when appropriate and tender when intimacy is called for. Some plots feel clichéd, particularly those involving Tomita and Yuuki, but those centered on Tudou and Himeno compensate with originality and entertainment. Once or twice, you might bristle at how easily the lead female is placed in a subordinate position in a race for presidency, but such plots are unfortunately common in shoujo today.
Overall, this is a quick read, fitting if you're seeking comedy and high school drama, but it lacks the depth needed to be a great romantic tale since the characters aren't fully fleshed out. Situations and dialogue remain relatively fresh and keep you amused, while the art is soothing and visually pleasing for those who appreciate intricately drawn bishounen.