Thanks for your hard work!!!! It's not easy writing a story that keeps the readers interest, but you do an awesome job! can't wait for more been reading this series since chapter 120. I know more will come just like last time. For those of you starting to read this and wondering if it's worth it, it is! not many series do a good job of adding other characters pov or personality and if they do it's like robots only following orders. This series gets you into the world and makes it feel alive.
I haven't read this in a while, so bear with me...
Story-
The initial draw for me was the promised incestuous theme; after all, if there's incest in the plot, you know it will be filled with plenty of angst and romance. The overall concept isn't the most thought-out or original—siblings separated who have a fling in Rome, then meet again at a funeral only to discover... they are brother and sister! As I mentioned, it's not the most original. However, once we move past the love square (which, surprisingly, isn't as annoying as most), we can appreciate the manga for what it truly is: a very cute, honest, and warmly sweet story. The forbidden love element certainly enhances its appeal, though I do find fault in its overly dramatic soap-opera approach. Nonetheless, I'd say it's a decent plot.
Art-
Typically adorable! Although this style of artwork is expected from this manga, I still find myself muttering "kawaii" every time I see Kasumi, the sister, in one of her shoujo outfits. I think the art surpasses expectations and is definitely more detailed than I anticipated. Occasionally, characters are out of proportion, or the artwork looks rushed or tired, but generally, it's pleasant and worth noting.
Character-
The great thing about the characters here is that you'll likely find someone who annoys you and someone you genuinely like. My personal favorite is Yoshiki's (the brother) crazy girlfriend, Kyoko, because I believe she's the character with the most depth. Kasumi is a bit of a question mark; she never stops crying, but I think the mangaka does a good job portraying her love for Yoshiki. The characters are average but still passable.
Enjoyment-
Despite its flaws, Tsumi ni Nureta Futari is one of those manga that just pulls you in, and I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. I laughed out loud, smiled, and anxiously clawed at my screen in anticipation for the next chapter.
Overall-
This manga is one you can be satisfied adding to your "completed" list. It's naive, sugary, and touching, and despite any complaints I might have, I still recommend giving it a read.
Portrays the concept of love in an exceptionally realistic way. It highlights the contrasting approaches to love between a man and a woman.<br /><br />
"I'd rather choose the sin of loving you than the happiness of not loving you." - Yoshiki Suzumura<br /><br />
I am incredibly frustrated. More so than I have ever been before.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I rooted for a couple as fervently as I have for these two lovers.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I felt the urge to lash out at myself, wanting to punch the computer screen and curse those who perpetrate one evil deed after another.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I had my emotions so deeply divided between wanting to abandon the manga and yet still yearn to continue reading it. I want to stop because my heart can't bear the poor decisions made by the protagonists. Yet, I crave more because the story is both heartwarming and heartbreaking. I've lost myself in this 18-volume tale of incestuous romance. Words cannot fully express my conflicting feelings of love and hate for this masterpiece.<br /><br />
It seems that most adult romance novels/manga (non-comedic, non-slice of life) today include some form of sexual content. I've come to accept this as an unwritten rule. While I was initially drawn to this manga because of its focus on an incestuous relationship, the story evolved into a deep, intense romance filled with sin upon sin. I was amazed at how well-written it was, showing the world turning against the siblings' forbidden love.<br /><br />
The artwork improved over time. The early drawings are inferior compared to the latter half, particularly in character texture and facial expressions, which enhanced the characters' beauty. However, the characters often suffer from "over-sized arms and legs," though this issue was somewhat corrected in later volumes.<br /><br />
One lesson I learned from the characters in Tsumi Ni Nureta Futari is that it's better to be with a smart woman who loves you more than you love her than a foolish woman whom you adore madly. The latter could lead to unnecessary suffering mentally, physically, and professionally. Some might call me a coward, but I can't compare myself to Yoshiki Suzumura, the hero of the story. Overall, the characters are well-developed; some even to the point where you know the type of perfume they use.<br /><br />
**The following is the writer's opinion on the story and contains spoilers. Read at your own discretion.**<br /><br />
I truly enjoyed the gradual buildup of affection between the siblings. They knew their love was forbidden, yet they couldn't stop themselves or let others interfere, even if it meant hurting friends and family. Their journey from sane love to obsessive love to stay together is remarkable. The story excels in this aspect. However...<br /><br />
I am extremely disappointed with the ending for the antagonists. Despite appearing to be a win-win situation for all, I disagree with this outcome. While the romance concluded neatly and all character arcs were wrapped up, justice was not served for the evil plots against our hero and heroine. Not at all.<br /><br />
Lastly, tell me one thing (via PM or post on my comment board). Which is more SINFUL?<br /><br />
1. Allowing the siblings to engage in incest (they practice safe sex!).<br /><br />
2. Asking the man who claims to love you to impregnate your own daughter, even if it means raping her daily.
Tsumi ni Nureta Futari is a deeply moving tale of forbidden love. The two primary characters encounter each other as a man and a woman, unaware of their true familial connection. As their interactions deepen, so does their love, alongside the struggles tied to incestuous relationships.
Story 8/10: This narrative is sorrowful and intricate, drawing readers fully into its world.
Art 8/10: The artwork is solid, though occasionally proportions falter.
Character 9/10: Characters are skillfully crafted, with every individual's perspective vividly realized. Readers can empathize with each character's viewpoint.
Enjoyment 8/10: It's an exceptional story that kept me engaged and eager to uncover more.
Overall 8/10: Despite its controversial theme (incest), I recommend this series to those seeking a challenging love story.
Popular Reviews
Story-
The initial draw for me was the promised incestuous theme; after all, if there's incest in the plot, you know it will be filled with plenty of angst and romance. The overall concept isn't the most thought-out or original—siblings separated who have a fling in Rome, then meet again at a funeral only to discover... they are brother and sister! As I mentioned, it's not the most original. However, once we move past the love square (which, surprisingly, isn't as annoying as most), we can appreciate the manga for what it truly is: a very cute, honest, and warmly sweet story. The forbidden love element certainly enhances its appeal, though I do find fault in its overly dramatic soap-opera approach. Nonetheless, I'd say it's a decent plot.
Art-
Typically adorable! Although this style of artwork is expected from this manga, I still find myself muttering "kawaii" every time I see Kasumi, the sister, in one of her shoujo outfits. I think the art surpasses expectations and is definitely more detailed than I anticipated. Occasionally, characters are out of proportion, or the artwork looks rushed or tired, but generally, it's pleasant and worth noting.
Character-
The great thing about the characters here is that you'll likely find someone who annoys you and someone you genuinely like. My personal favorite is Yoshiki's (the brother) crazy girlfriend, Kyoko, because I believe she's the character with the most depth. Kasumi is a bit of a question mark; she never stops crying, but I think the mangaka does a good job portraying her love for Yoshiki. The characters are average but still passable.
Enjoyment-
Despite its flaws, Tsumi ni Nureta Futari is one of those manga that just pulls you in, and I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. I laughed out loud, smiled, and anxiously clawed at my screen in anticipation for the next chapter.
Overall-
This manga is one you can be satisfied adding to your "completed" list. It's naive, sugary, and touching, and despite any complaints I might have, I still recommend giving it a read.
"I'd rather choose the sin of loving you than the happiness of not loving you." - Yoshiki Suzumura<br /><br />
I am incredibly frustrated. More so than I have ever been before.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I rooted for a couple as fervently as I have for these two lovers.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I felt the urge to lash out at myself, wanting to punch the computer screen and curse those who perpetrate one evil deed after another.<br /><br />
Never in my life have I had my emotions so deeply divided between wanting to abandon the manga and yet still yearn to continue reading it. I want to stop because my heart can't bear the poor decisions made by the protagonists. Yet, I crave more because the story is both heartwarming and heartbreaking. I've lost myself in this 18-volume tale of incestuous romance. Words cannot fully express my conflicting feelings of love and hate for this masterpiece.<br /><br />
It seems that most adult romance novels/manga (non-comedic, non-slice of life) today include some form of sexual content. I've come to accept this as an unwritten rule. While I was initially drawn to this manga because of its focus on an incestuous relationship, the story evolved into a deep, intense romance filled with sin upon sin. I was amazed at how well-written it was, showing the world turning against the siblings' forbidden love.<br /><br />
The artwork improved over time. The early drawings are inferior compared to the latter half, particularly in character texture and facial expressions, which enhanced the characters' beauty. However, the characters often suffer from "over-sized arms and legs," though this issue was somewhat corrected in later volumes.<br /><br />
One lesson I learned from the characters in Tsumi Ni Nureta Futari is that it's better to be with a smart woman who loves you more than you love her than a foolish woman whom you adore madly. The latter could lead to unnecessary suffering mentally, physically, and professionally. Some might call me a coward, but I can't compare myself to Yoshiki Suzumura, the hero of the story. Overall, the characters are well-developed; some even to the point where you know the type of perfume they use.<br /><br />
**The following is the writer's opinion on the story and contains spoilers. Read at your own discretion.**<br /><br />
I truly enjoyed the gradual buildup of affection between the siblings. They knew their love was forbidden, yet they couldn't stop themselves or let others interfere, even if it meant hurting friends and family. Their journey from sane love to obsessive love to stay together is remarkable. The story excels in this aspect. However...<br /><br />
I am extremely disappointed with the ending for the antagonists. Despite appearing to be a win-win situation for all, I disagree with this outcome. While the romance concluded neatly and all character arcs were wrapped up, justice was not served for the evil plots against our hero and heroine. Not at all.<br /><br />
Lastly, tell me one thing (via PM or post on my comment board). Which is more SINFUL?<br /><br />
1. Allowing the siblings to engage in incest (they practice safe sex!).<br /><br />
2. Asking the man who claims to love you to impregnate your own daughter, even if it means raping her daily.
Story 8/10: This narrative is sorrowful and intricate, drawing readers fully into its world.
Art 8/10: The artwork is solid, though occasionally proportions falter.
Character 9/10: Characters are skillfully crafted, with every individual's perspective vividly realized. Readers can empathize with each character's viewpoint.
Enjoyment 8/10: It's an exceptional story that kept me engaged and eager to uncover more.
Overall 8/10: Despite its controversial theme (incest), I recommend this series to those seeking a challenging love story.